Care Quality Commission
|Printable version||E-mail this to a friend|
Judge finds rating review process fair, factual accuracy improved
SPP Health Ltd is a GP provider in the North-West with approximately 40 locations.
They requested a rating review of the location Seaforth Village Surgery. As the request did not meet the grounds for review as set out in the Provider Handbook, CQC’s Rating Review Manager declined to consider the request. SSP was granted permission to seek a judicial review of this decision.
At the judicial review hearing before the High Court on 28 July 2016, SSP was permitted to advance a substantially different case, raising a challenge to a number of CQC’s pre- and post-publication processes.
In a judgment handed down on 12 August 2016, Mrs Justice Andrews does not find that CQC’s rating review process is unfair, nor that it was applied unfairly in this case.
In effect, this judgment helpfully defines and approves CQC’s processes for pre- and post-inspection challenge to reports. The Judge confirms CQC’s rating review process is fair. However, the Judge’s remarks suggest one further amendment to our current practice:
- To avoid the risk of this approach being taken in the future, the Judge asks that CQC develop a further mechanism to ensure the factual accuracy process has been properly followed, which involves someone independent of the inspection, before a report is published. All factual accuracy responses will be reviewed by another member of the Commission’s staff from the relevant Inspection Directorate. This staff member will be independent of the original inspection visit.
Work was already underway to improve the factual accuracy form and guidance for all sectors which was facilitated by the business improvement team and agreed by sector continuous improvement groups. The requirements of this judgment have been reflected in the outcome of this work.
Latest News from
Care Quality Commission
CQC publishes independent review into data security breach23/09/2016 13:10:00
On 28 July 2016 CQC publicly reported a data security breach involving the loss of Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) certificates from CQC premises in Newcastle.
Shropshire care home and manager fined in prosecution brought by the Care Quality Commission22/09/2016 11:10:00
A Shrewsbury care home owner and its former manager have been fined over £50,000 in a prosecution brought by us after admitting they failed to provide safe care.
CQC launches an updated code of practice on confidential personal information16/09/2016 15:05:00
The CQC have updated the code of practice that their staff will follow to obtain, handle, use and disclose confidential personal information.
My diabetes, my care: diabetes care review launched07/09/2016 10:10:00
Yesterday CQC launched their review exploring the quality of care for people with diabetes in England.
Outstanding: First top ratings for NHS mental health trusts02/09/2016 11:10:00
Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust and East London NHS Foundation Trust have become the first two NHS mental health trusts in England to be awarded overall ratings of outstanding, as detailed in inspection reports published yesterday (Thursday 1 September).