“It’s not been a great day for the Coalition. In addition to council losses, the mayoral referendums didn’t give David Cameron the ‘Boris for every city’ he wanted. With all results declared 9 out of 10 cities where referendums were held voted against mayors.
It’s not all bad of course. Bristol choosing a mayor is an important step and Liverpool, Leicester and Salford have also switched to the mayoral system. And Doncaster voted to keep the system after actually experiencing mayoral government.
Still, the government clearly struggled to convince the electorate of the benefits that mayors would bring. Apathy was compounded by three factors: the refusal of government to be clear about the precise additional powers mayors would be given; campaigning by local councillors who mobilised party machines to resist changes that would mean less power for them; and wariness of claims about additional costs.