A ‘career’ in the Community and Voluntary Sector, really?
Jayne Graham MBE, Executive Director, Society Matters cic
The Community and Voluntary Sector (CVS) is probably better known as a route for people to volunteer, perhaps as a way to ‘give back’ at the end of a career, than as a provider of formative or developmental career opportunities. That’s understandable. To the unaccustomed the ‘third sector’ or ‘not-for-profit sector’ can appear to be a bit detached from ‘real life’ compared to the cut and thrust of the private sector, and the gargantuan establishment that is the public sector. But if you think about it, selecting the CVS as your career choice has the potential to transport you to as close to ‘real life’ as you can get.
So can you have a ‘career’ in the sector, really?
What’s the shape and size of the sector?
If we stand back and look at the sector in all of its different guises, there’s no wonder really there’s uncertainty about its potential. At one end of the spectrum we have un-constituted community groups run entirely by volunteers that deliver localised support, and at the other we have social enterprises that operate, from the outside, as a commercial private business, but with the unique characteristic of creating social rather than material wealth; and this comes with varying levels of obligation – some, like Society Matters cic for example, are asset locked, meaning that all profits/assets must go to the community they serve. Then firmly in the centre we have the charity sector, governed by the Charities Commission.
As a result of this diversity and varying levels of formality it’s really difficult to get absolute clarity on the numbers of people actually employed overall, however according to the UK Civil Society Almanac 2020 the voluntary sector has a paid workforce approaching one million, almost 3% of the total paid workforce, and representing a 17% growth rate in jobs since 2010. Most of these jobs are in voluntary organisations with less than 50 paid staff (which is a similar proportion to the private sector). Over a third of employees are engaged in social work activities, followed by education and residential care which each represent around 12%. It should also be said that although the sector’s primary focus is social wealth, a significant economic contribution is also made, estimated by NCVO and ONS to be valued at £18.2bn 2017/18, or 0.9% of total GDP.
Obviously when reviewing the shape and size of the sector, we can’t get away without making reference to Covid19 which has had an inordinate impact on the CVS. For some organisations income has been lost, with a fifth of small UK charities reported to be expecting an income reduction of more than 50% as a direct result of the pandemic, and as many as 1 in 10 charities are said to be facing imminent bankruptcy. Income through trading has been slashed due to lockdown restrictions, particularly in the case of charity shops, but for others their capacity has grown exponentially as a result of the availability of volunteers, which will improve their impact statistics which has the potential of helping them raise funds for next year.
However in my view the most fundamental shift is the heightened recognition of the part that not only the CVS, but citizens individually and collectively, can (should) play in supporting society and societal change. At every level the concept of community has entered spheres of influence that had been severely lacking. Beyond Covid19 this presents a tangible opportunity for growth for a sector that stands out for its essential contribution to all our lives.
So, onto career prospects and the need for new skills. Interestingly, according to the UK Civil Society Almanac 2020, employees in the sector are highly educated, with over half of the workforce being educated to degree level of higher, similar to the public sector and much higher than in the private sector. What also stands out is that reported skills gaps are lower than the other sectors, however the skills gaps that do exist contrast with other sectors, mainly focusing on hard skills such as complex analytical, operational and digital skills, and on soft skills most particularly self-management and management and leadership. This mirrors my own experience which can be explained in part by the starting point generally being that the charity and its people tend to be for society first, and a business second.
But of course, despite the social drivers, CVS organisations are economic structures – they are businesses: they employ people, they manage finance, they market, they manage facilities and IT, they develop operating models that enable services to be delivered. Although this is evolving, the culture of resisting ‘behaving’ like a business, combined with skills gaps that potentially get in the way of innovation, marketing and strategic change, present a significant barrier to survival and growth for many. However it must also be said, as someone who has worked in both the private and the community and voluntary sector, running a social business is far more complex than its private counterparts – at the very least because your main customer is highly unlikely to be able to pay for what you have to offer.
If we can get over this stand-off, a significant opportunity does exist for a heightened focus on leadership and management development across the sector (not necessarily delivered by those already in the sector), and a call for collaboration with the buoyant and growing digital sector, to uplift the capability of the CVS to build its efficiency and its ability to compete.
A word about volunteering
Volunteering and employability do go hand in hand, both with respect to presenting opportunities for acquiring work experience and employment-related skills and assets, and as a direct route into employment. As an example, over 20% of paid employees at Citizens Advice Gateshead, the parent charity of Society Matters cic, started with the charity as a volunteer.
As the employment landscape continues to change as a result of the pandemic, the need for reframing and retraining to enable people in the sectors worst hit to move forward, volunteering in the CVS has the potential to provide the answer. An investment in making this work for the sector, however, is critical; the misnomer that volunteers provide ‘free’ resource needs to be eradicated, as under-investment will have a catastrophic effect on the sector, and will prevent this workforce development opportunity to be realised alongside draining the already limited resources needed to deliver social value.
Jayne Graham is Commercial Director of local charity Citizens Advice Gateshead and Executive Director of its trading subsidiary, social enterprise Society Matters cic. Jayne’s career has spanned private, public and charitable sectors. After graduating in business she developed what she calls her formative career in the recruitment industry, ultimately leading the growth of a private national recruitment business to a turnover of £24m. In 2000 she took on a new challenge as the CEO of a publicly funded business support agency in County Durham, again growing it from £1m to £10m and from a staff of 24 to over 100. In 2004 she set up her own consultancy business which she ran from her home in Gateshead, combining working full time with looking after her young family, until 2018 when she took up her current role, after spending three years supporting local charities with strategic direction, digital communications and income generation. Jayne was awarded an MBE for services to the small business sector in the North East in 2017.
Latest News from
Join us at the FED National Education Summit23/02/2021 14:15:00
On 1 – 4 March, the Foundation for Education Development (FED), supported by NCFE, is holding a virtual National Education Summit to explore how a long-term plan for education is needed for our country – with over 100 high profile speakers across 4 days and more than 32 hours of thought leadership discussions.
How employers can re-build their communities through inclusive apprenticeship programmes11/02/2021 10:10:00
In celebration of National Apprenticeship Week 2021, NCFE has produced a podcast with some well-known voices from the apprenticeship and skills sector, discussing the relevance of qualifications as part of the recruitment process.
The importance of formative assessment01/02/2021 16:15:00
David Redden, NCFE Product Manager, looks at why formative assessment is more important now than ever before.
Yes, there’s a digital skills crisis in the UK, but we can solve it!28/01/2021 11:15:00
Liz Williams MBE, chief executive of FutureDotNow, discusses the crisis and how it can be tackled.
SEND students use our RSHE qualifications to build happy and healthy lives, inside and outside of the classroom27/01/2021 11:15:00
Learners at Meadowcroft School have been undertaking RSHE qualifications from CACHE – part of the NCFE family, to reach personal success.
Skills for Jobs White Paper – summary and media coverage26/01/2021 14:15:00
Last week, the government published the long-awaited Skills for Jobs White Paper. Described as FE’s ‘day in the sun’, the paper shines a light on the national training landscape and provides some much-needed reassurance amid the Covid-19 crisis.
Keeping motivated during lockdown25/01/2021 11:15:00
Research from The Health Foundation in December 2020, showed that the most common issues affecting wellbeing during the pandemic were worry about the future (63%), feeling stressed or anxious (56%) and feeling bored (49%).
Blue Monday: Practical mental health solutions18/01/2021 15:43:00
Scrolling through social media on Blue Monday each January can feel like falling into an endless pit of doom, with gloomy posts referring to the ‘most depressing day of the year’.
Supporting the development of Health and Science, and Digital qualifications18/12/2020 14:15:00
Building on the progress of Digital and Health and Science T Level Technical qualification developments and insight gathered from education providers and employers, we are excited to be developing further qualifications in these sectors to provide learning and career progression pathways.