Brexit: recent UK proposals do not offer the safeguards the EU and Ireland need
On Wednesday 2/10, Michel Barnier debriefed the Members of EP Brexit Steering group on UK government's latest proposals. Following an exchange of views, the Members agreed on a statement.
"The BSG does not find these last minute proposals of the UK government of 2 October, in their current form, represent a basis for an agreement to which the European Parliament could give consent. The proposals do not address the real issues that need to be resolved, namely the all - island economy, the full respect of the Good Friday Agreement and the integrity of the Single Market.
While we remain open to workable, legally operable and serious solutions, the UK’s proposals fall short and represent a significant movement away from joint commitments and objectives.
In particular, concern was expressed about three aspects of the proposals.
First, the UK proposals on customs and on regulatory aspects explicitly provide for infrastructure, controls and checks but are unclear as to exactly where and how these would be carried out. Any form of controls and checks in and around the border would signify the end of frictionless trade and as such would harm the all-island economy as well as represent a serious risk to the peace process, and could imply a serious risk for consumers and businesses. The proposals tabled by the UK Government thus breach a range of fundamental principles and red lines passed in the resolutions of this house. At the same time, such controls would not be sufficient to guarantee the protection of EU consumers and businesses in all circumstances, thereby potentially leaving the EU with a significant hole in its Single Market.
Second, the UK proposals would operationally only be worked out in detail by the EU and the UK, or in the UK unilaterally, during the fourteen-month transition period. This does not provide the necessary certainty or fulfil the agreed principles in the Withdrawal Agreement. This would mean the European Parliament would have to give consent to the Protocol without knowing its full implications, nor having any guarantee as to its legal operation. This is unacceptable.
Third, the right of consent being offered to the Northern Irish Assembly effectively makes an agreement contingent, uncertain, provisional and unilateral decision, instead of the safety net provided for by the backstop. Furthermore, the Northern Irish Assembly has not sat for nearly three years and it is questionable whether it would be able to reconvene and take on the responsibility for an international treaty of this nature.
In summary, the BSG has grave concerns about the UK proposal, as tabled. Safeguarding peace and stability on the island of Ireland, protection of citizens and EU’s legal order has to be the main focus of any deal. The UK proposals do not match even remotely what was agreed as a sufficient compromise in the backstop.
The European Parliament remains open to explore all proposals, but these need to be credible, legally operable, and in practise have the same effect as the compromises found in the Withdrawal Agreement. "
Note to editors
The European Parliament continues to support an “orderly Brexit” based on the already negotiated Withdrawal Agreement, MEPs reaffirmed in the resolution adopted with a large majority on 18 September. Any withdrawal agreement and future association or international agreement with the UK will need to be approved by the European Parliament.
Latest News from
Plans to keep EU budget funding in 2020 in the event of a no-deal Brexit15/10/2019 15:25:00
UK Researchers, students and farmers would continue to get EU support in the event of a no-deal Brexit, under provisions adopted by the Budgets Committee on Monday.
Article – Hohlmeier: fighting climate change is the priority for the EU's 2020 budget15/10/2019 13:37:00
The EU's budget for 2020 should include more climate action funding and higher investment in sustainable technologies, according to Monika Hohlmeier, Parliament's budget negotiator.
EPPO: Council confirms Laura Codruţa Kövesi as first European chief prosecutor15/10/2019 12:25:00
The Council has agreed to the appointment of Laura Codruţa Kövesi to be the first European chief prosecutor. The appointment must now also be confirmed by the European Parliament.
Chemical weapons: Council renews EU sanctions regime for one year15/10/2019 10:37:00
The Council has extended restrictive measures by the EU addressing the use and proliferation of chemical weapons until 16 October 2020.
Brexit: EC statement following this weekend's technical talks with the UK14/10/2019 16:47:00
Michel Barnier briefed EU27 Ambassadors this afternoon, following constructive technical-level talks with the UK over the weekend. He will also inform the European Parliament's Brexit Steering Group this evening.
Young people, particularly those low qualified, bear the brunt of social inequalities in Spain14/10/2019 15:25:00
This week Spain celebrates the Fiesta Nacional, and we mark the occasion by sharing our research data, findings & analysis to provide a snapshot of the country’s living & working conditions.
Plant Health: prioritising the fight against 20 quarantine plant pests on the EU territory14/10/2019 14:37:00
The Commission recently (11 October 2019) published a list of 20 regulated quarantine pests qualifying as priority pests, including Xylella fastidiosa, the Japanesebeetle, the Asian long-horned beetle, Citrus greening and Citrus Black Spot, whose economic, environmental and social impact on EU's territory is the most severe. Member States will have to launch information campaigns to the public, do annual surveys, prepare contingency plans, simulation exercises, and action plans for the eradication of these pests.
Priority plant pests in the EU: 5 things you need to know14/10/2019 13:43:00
The 20 pests on the list published by the EC in October 2019 are quarantine pests that have been identified as top priorities for EU Member States based on the severity of the economic, social and environmental problems they can cause.
Article - Brexit: plans in place to mitigate impact of no deal11/10/2019 16:25:00
If the UK leaves the EU without a deal, the effects will be felt by people and companies across Europe. The EU has adopted measures to mitigate the impact of a disorderly withdrawal.