Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Brexit: the EU data protection package report debated in the Lords
Today the House of Lords debate the Committee’s report on the options available to the Government for securing uninterrupted data flows between the UK and EU after the UK leaves the EU.
- Parliament TV: Watch the debate
- Report: Brexit: the EU data protection package (HTML)
- Report: Brexit: the EU data protection package (PDF)
- Inquiry: Brexit: the EU data protection package
- EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee
The Committee found that maintaining unhindered and uninterrupted data flows between the UK and EU after Brexit is an important aim, as any arrangement that results in greater friction could present a non-tariff trade barrier that puts the UK at a competitive disadvantage and hinders police and security cooperation. Although the Government has said it wants to ensure unhindered and uninterrupted data flows post-Brexit, little detail has so far been offered on how the Government plans to deliver this outcome.
The debate follows the publication of a report by the EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee which, by looking at four elements of the EU's data protection package, examines the options available to the Government for securing uninterrupted data flows between the UK and EU after the UK leaves the EU.
The Committee's main conclusions included:
- There was consensus among our witnesses that the most effective way to achieve unhindered flows of data would be to secure adequacy decisions from the European Commission under Article 45 of the General Data Protection Regulation and Article 36 of the Police and Criminal Justice Directive, thereby confirming that the UK's data protection rules would offer an equivalent standard of protection to that available within the EU.
- EU adequacy decisions can only be taken in respect of third countries – i.e. countries that are not EU Member States – and there will therefore be legal impediments to having such decisions in place at the moment of exit. If there is no transitional arrangement on data protection post-Brexit, this could put at risk the Government's objective of securing uninterrupted flows of data, thereby creating a cliff-edge.
- Without a transitional arrangement, the lack of tried and tested fall-back options for data-sharing in the area of law enforcement would raise concerns about the UK's ability to maintain deep police and security cooperation with the EU and its Member States in the immediate aftermath of Brexit.
- Even if the UK's data protection rules were aligned with the EU regime to the maximum extent possible at the point of Brexit, there remains the prospect that over time, the EU would amend or update its rules. Maintaining unhindered data flows with the EU post-Brexit could therefore require the UK to continue to align domestic data protection rules with EU rules that it no longer participates in setting.
- It is imperative that the Government consider how best to replace those structures and platforms that have allowed it to influence EU rules on data protection and retention. It should start by seeking to secure a continuing role for the Information Commissioner's Office on the European Data Protection Board.
Speakers in the Debate
- The Lord Jay of Ewelme GCMG, Chairman of the EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee, will open the debate on the report Brexit: the EU data protection package
- The Baroness Williams of Trafford, Minister of State at the Home Office, will respond on behalf of the Government.
Other members of the House of Lords who are due to speak in the debate can be viewed on the Speakers' List.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Ensure ports have necessary IT structures and customs checks capabilities post-Brexit20/02/2018 09:25:00
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee calls for a fund to prepare British farming for Brexit, a specific impact analysis for each agricultural sector, plans for physical and IT infrastructure to be drawn up now, and for new trading partnerships to be explored.
Government must reconsider high interest rates on student loans19/02/2018 12:25:00
The Government is due to undertake a major review of university funding and student financing.
Boost Inspectorate to reverse decline in prisons16/02/2018 12:15:00
Recommendations made by HM Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) did not lead to improvements at HMP Liverpool, and given this appears to be the case in other prisons, HMIP should be given additional resources to follow-up on their recommendations - according to a report from the Justice Committee.
Time for urgent action on 'another major misselling scandal'16/02/2018 09:25:00
The Work and Pensions Committee publishes a report on British Steel Pension Schemes (BSPS). The Committee says, another major misselling scandal is already erupting on defined benefit pension transfers, and calls on the responsible authorities to take urgent action.