Building a Collaborative Society: The Power of Community
Collaborate has a resolution for 2019: to be bold about the future we want to create. Specifically, what a Collaborative Society could look like, how you build it, and where the green shoots are already paving the way.
We have invited a number of leading thinkers and do-ers to contribute their ideas about this concept and its implications through a blog series, as well as events and a podcast series in the autumn. In the first blog of this series, Ed Wallis, Head of Policy and Public Affairs from Locality shares his views, focusing how community organisations can be supported to form the bedrock of the #collaborativesociety.
For those committed to positive social change, our current circumstances can feel incredibly daunting.
Long-term trends alone — like rising inequality, an ageing society and climate change — would have placed huge strain on the public sector and required imaginative new policy approaches. But combined with deep austerity and our ongoing political instability, bold solutions of the required scale can seem nigh on impossible to grasp.
Indeed, one of the greatest tragedies of the austerity decade we have been living under is that its impacts have been weighted towards the local level. For this is where the innovation to tackle the economic, social and environmental challenges we face is most likely to be found. As such, we have been failing to catalyse our best hope for the future: the power of community.
It is well established that what characterises our biggest policy problems is their complexity. They are therefore unable to be solved by top-down plans or simple market incentives. Instead they require deep and lasting relationships to be forged, with power widely dispersed and services joined-up around the distinct needs of every person.
At Locality, we believe that community organisations are particularly well-suited to this task. They are locally rooted and trusted, and there for the long term. They have strong existing relationships with local people, especially with those whom public services traditionally find “hard to reach”. They are multi-purpose organisations that can respond flexibly and provide services which are tailored to the individual.
What’s more, they also help commissioned services add up to so much more than the sum of their parts. They do this by linking service users with other community development activities, encouraging social action and volunteering, getting people connected locally and building self-confidence and pride.
Performing this role effectively is, of course, hugely dependent on the health of the wider system. Many Locality members were originally set up in the face of egregious system failure. This quote from a Locality member formed on a council estate in Hull in the early nineties captures the origin story for many community organisations:
“What the residents on this estate did was: band together and say this isn’t good enough. No one else is going to help us. No one else is bothered. We’ve got to do it ourselves. Let’s not talk about it: let’s do it.” Stuart Spandler, Goodwin Development Trust.
At the heart of this is the idea of community ownership. If poor communities take ownership of physical assets, this gives them real power. They are less dependent on the vagaries of political decision-making or the lottery of grant funding. They can earn their own income, generate and retain wealth for their neighbourhood, and invest in the services and activities they know their community wants — rather than waiting (experience suggests in vain) for someone else to choose to do something on their behalf.
In times like these — defined, as they are politically, by a particularly catastrophic mix of chaos and inertia — these stories of communities coming together to take action for themselves are incredibly inspiring. But this clearly isn’t how things should be. Imagine how transformative community organisations could be if they were enabled to play a collaborative role in a changing system, rather than having to kick against a failing one?
At their best, community organisations are a critical cog that make our places tick. They work interdependently with the local public and private sectors, delivering public sector contracts, coordinating services at a neighbourhood-level, and supporting local businesses. And they build and strengthen the roots of the system, working in partnership with local community groups, residents, neighbours and friends.
So how do we support community organisations to maximise their role in creating and sustaining a “Collaborative Society”? Some of the work Locality has been doing over the last few years offers some clues.
First, we need to support community ownership. There is a growing consensus that community ownership is not only the critical bedrock for strong and successful community organisations, it can also bring wide-ranging benefits to neighbourhoods. When our swimming pools, community centres, nurseries and cafes are owned by local people, they can drive regeneration, spur social action and give people a real sense of control.
Second, we need to transform commissioning to make it “local by default”. Recent years have seen councils trying to find savings by outsourcing services at scale: bundling up services into big contracts that go to large providers at the lowest price possible. Not only has this been creating the wrong kind of services, it’s been shutting out smaller, local organisations and preventing them playing their vital role in the local service landscape. Our Keep it Localcampaign is showing where local authority commissioning is taking a different path: building strong local partnerships, sharing power, and maximising local strengths.
Third, we need to completely reframe how we think about power. Instead of looking towards Westminster, we need to focus on unlocking the vast reservoir of ideas, energy and commitment that lives in our neighbourhoods. Our Commission on the Future of Localism set out a framework for how we might do this by building a new “power partnership” between councils and communities, which we’re now exploring in practice in four places.
These are some key steps we could take to help create a more supportive environment for community organisations. And we know from our work there are lots of places across the country where this is starting to happen.
But the real task now is to join up and develop a much wider vision for our places and how we change them for the better — and the idea of a Collaborative Society can help us do that. So we’re excited to be part of the conversation: to see what we can contribute, what we can learn, and how we can build a Collaborative Society together.
Locality is hosting a Keep it Local conference on 12 June that brings together leaders and practitioners from local government and community organisations to help you explore what this means for your place and community.
Latest News from
A Whole New World: Public Service in the time of Coronavirus25/03/2020 12:20:00
Responding to Coronavirus is causing public servants to turn off the target-based tools of public management that have been standard practice for the last 30 years.
Today we are pleased to launch Collaborate’s new Manifesto for a Collaborative Society.21/01/2020 15:43:00
Over the past year, building on work with our partners and conversations with a wide range of people, we have asked: what if we could change the lens through which we see our world – from individualism, competition, hierarchy and heroic leadership, to collaboration, mutuality, networks and shared leadership? What if this became the dominant way of working? What difference would this make?
Starting with purpose, not projects: learning from a Council-Funder collaboration17/10/2019 16:47:00
Over the past three years we have been working with colleagues at Newcastle Business School (Northumbria University) exploring alternative approaches to commissioning, funding and managing social support which better respond to real-life complexity.
Embracing a Different Worldview: Collaborative Society Reflections07/08/2019 12:20:00
In January the Collaborate team set out our new year’s resolution for 2019: to be bold about the future we want to create.
Connecting the pioneers of future public services through the Upstream Collaborative02/08/2019 13:37:00
An exciting new partnership between Nesta and Collaborate.
Embracing complexity to do what’s best for people15/07/2019 13:20:00
Toby Lowe and Dawn Plimmer discuss funding, commissioning and managing services in a world where relationships rather than KPIs or simplistic numerical targets are what matters most.
Place-based system change: Demystifying the practice13/06/2019 16:37:00
For over two years now Collaborate has been a partner in Lankelly Chase’s action inquiry into how places can be supported to build the nine system behaviours that they have identified as foundational to system change. As Lankelly set out in their approach to change document,
Collaborate CIC’s Summer 2019 Event14/05/2019 13:20:00
We are delighted to announce that Collaborate CIC will be hosting an evening event on Thursday 13th June – How can we build a Collaborative Society?
Reflections on the value of a place-based plan from Hannah Anderson, Director at Collaborate CIC18/04/2019 13:20:00
For some time now Collaborate has been an advocate of the place-based plan; a collaborative statement of intent across key organisations that draws on a range of insights, and sets out an ambitious, place-specific approach to improving outcomes.