Criminal Cases Review Commission
CCRC Research Committee publishes two new research projects
The CCRC Research Committee has published two new research papers as part of its ongoing commitment to sponsor a wide range of academic projects that benefit the wider criminal justice system.
New insights and emerging issues or patterns are always of interest, and the CCRC will make its data available to academic researchers who identify areas of potential research which might be of benefit to the criminal justice system.
These two reports join an extensive library of academic research covering a variety of topics, including the impact of legal aid cuts on the quality of applications to the CCRC, a paper by the Centre for Women’s Justice on “Women who kill” and a paper on the criminalisation of refugees.
Published today are papers on;
- the impact of R v Jogee on joint enterprise liability applications made to the CCRC (by the University of Greenwich’s Dr Louise Hewitt)
- Crown Court cases accepted for review on the basis that there were ‘exceptional circumstances’ (by CCRC intern Megan Morrison)
Dr Hewitt’s study reviewed 247 applications made between 2009 and 2020 by individuals convicted under joint enterprise law between 1978 and 2020, and focused on:
- The type of joint enterprise that is the subject of applications to the CCRC.
- How the corrected law in Jogee is being used in applications.
- The number of applicants that had legal representation.
- The demographic characteristics of applicants.
The Research Committee also oversees internal research projects carried out by CCRC staff drawing on its own data. The most recent internal research report has been produced by CCRC intern Megan Morrison and analyses Crown Court cases accepted for review by the CCRC on the basis that there were ‘exceptional circumstances’ justifying the CCRC’s involvement despite there being no previous attempt to appeal.
The CCRC is always looking for ways to improve our service to applicants including those who – exceptionally – cannot appeal to the Courts in the usual way. This latest piece of research aims to improve our engagement with applicants who are unable to appeal and simplify the CCRC process for them. Read more here (add link to website)
Who sits on the CCRC Research Committee?
The CCRC Research Committee comprises of CCRC Commissioners and staff, and is supported by two independent academic advisors, Professor Barry Goldson (University of Liverpool) and Professor Anthea Hucklesby (University of Birmingham) – who are widely respected for their work in the field of criminal justice.
The Committee meets four times a year to monitor progress on research projects and consider potential new areas of interest. The Committee issues a call for new research proposals approximately once every two years.
Committee Chair and CCRC Commissioner, Rob Ward said:
“The Committee, which was formed in 2015, benefits greatly from the commitment of its members and the knowledge and experience of its independent academic advisors.
“We believe we are the only agency operating in the criminal justice system that has a committee dedicated to promoting and sponsoring research.
“I’m proud of the projects that the Committee has been able to support. The quality of the research conducted by leaders in the field of criminal justice, drawing on our data, has contributed significantly to the CCRC’s effectiveness and to wider understanding of the criminal justice system, the needs of its users and the pressures upon it.”
Current projects sponsored by the Research Committee include:
- “Evaluation of witness evidence in CCRC cases” – Dr Rebecca Helm, Exeter University.
- “Human Trafficking and Modern Slavery” – Prof. Richard Vogler, Dr Shahrzad Fouladvand, Sussex University;
- “Digital Communications and Digitised Third Party Records as evidence in Adult Sexual Offence Applications to the CCRC” – Prof. Michelle Burman et al, Glasgow University;
- “Young People and the CCRC” – PhD student, Northumbria University
Notes to editors
- CCRC can only support research proposals from recognised academic and/or research institutions.
- Whilst CCRC is unable to offer funding, it can support funding applications and provide access to nearly 25 years of data.
- The CCRC also supports PhD projects -subjects include “predictors of wrongful convictions”, “guilty pleas” and “Innocence”.
- We put out research calls approximately every 2 years.
Propose a research project to the CCRC.
Anyone interested in proposing an academic research project to the Commission should consider the following documents:
We also recommend that you make yourself aware of existing research.
All researchers will be required to sign an appropriate confidentiality agreement before access to CCRC data can be given.
Latest News from
Criminal Cases Review Commission
Five more ex Post Office workers have convictions set aside28/09/2023 14:05:00
Five more former sub-postmasters have had convictions set aside after their cases were sent back to court by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC).
Convicted ex Post Office workers urged to apply for a free case review22/09/2023 10:15:00
Former Post Office workers with criminal convictions linked to the discredited Horizon computer system are being encouraged to apply to have their cases reviewed following this week’s government announcement that anyone with a quashed conviction will be offered £600,000 in compensation.
Blog: Reaching children in care who might have suffered a miscarriage of justice20/09/2023 09:20:00
Blog posted by: Cathy Dilks, CCRC Head of Applicant Outreach, 19 September 2023.
Psychiatric assessments form basis of CCRC referral18/09/2023 12:20:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission (“CCRC”) has referred a 2013 murder conviction to the Court of Appeal after commissioning fresh psychiatric assessments about the defendant’s mental health at the time of the offences.
Support for under-represented Traveller community18/09/2023 10:10:00
A clear under-representation of applications from the Traveller community to the body that reviews potential miscarriages of justice has raised concerns that unjust convictions might be going unchecked.
Final call for research proposals to the CCRC – deadline for entries 11 September 202305/09/2023 15:25:00
The CCRC is the body that investigates possible miscarriages of justice.
The CCRC welcomes cross-organisational inquiry into handling of Andrew Malkinson case24/08/2023 16:20:00
Lord Chancellor Alex Chalk has today (24 August) ordered an independent inquiry into the circumstances and handling of Andrew Malkinson’s case after his conviction was quashed by the Court of Appeal earlier this month.
Specifics of upcoming independent review into CCRC investigations22/08/2023 13:10:00
A leading King’s Counsel will conduct the review into three Criminal Cases Review Commission investigations into Andrew Malkinson’s rape conviction, the Terms of Reference published yesterday have confirmed.