Criminal Cases Review Commission
CCRC to refer 39 Post Office cases on abuse of process argument
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has so far decided to refer for appeal the convictions of 39 Post Office applicants.
The Commission will be referring all those cases, which involve convictions for theft, fraud and false accounting, on the basis of the argument that each prosecution amounted to an abuse of process. (The details of the individual cases being referred are listed at the end of this release).
The abuse of process argument is based on issues with the Post Office’s Horizon computer system which may have had an impact on the cases referred.
The argument arises out of two civil court judgments – the Common Issues Judgment of the 15th March 2019 (Bates v Post Office  EWHC 606 (QB)), and particularly the Horizon Issues Judgment handed down on the 16th December 2019 (Bates v Post Office  EWHC 3408 (QB)).
The CCRC can only refer a case for appeal if it considers that there is new evidence or new argument that raises a real possibility that the appeal court will quash the conviction(s).
The 39 cases to be referred are among a total of 61 applications to the CCRC from Post Office applicants.
In relation to the remaining 22 cases, the CCRC has further work to do before it will be in a position to announce decisions as to whether or not it can refer those cases.
Those involved in the Post Office cases at the CCRC will continue their work and the decision-making committee will convene again as necessary so that the remaining decisions can be made and communicated as soon as possible.
Unusually, and because of the Covid-19 situation, the CCRC decision making committee met virtually using remote access IT technology over two days on the 24th and 25th March.
The referrals will be formally made when the appropriate papers are sent to the relevant appeal courts (36 cases will be referred to the Court of Appeal as convictions obtained in Crown Court, and three will be referred to the Crown Court as magistrates’ court convictions). Covid-19 restrictions may mean that that process may now take a some time to complete.
Helen Pitcher, Chairman of the Criminal Cases Review Commission, said:
“This is by some distance the largest number of cases we will ever have referred for appeal at one time. Our team has got through a huge amount of work, particularly since the judgment in December, in order to identify the grounds on which we are referring these cases.
“The Covid-19 situation threatened to delay things but we used an IT solution to resolve that and we will continue to do whatever we need to in order to make decisions in the remaining cases as quickly as we reasonably can.”
Latest News from
Criminal Cases Review Commission
Commission refers the murder convictions of Robert and Lee Firkins to the Court of Appeal07/08/2020 09:20:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred the murder convictions of Robert and Lee Firkins to the Court of Appeal.
CCRC complains to IPSO about Times article on the independence of the Commission03/08/2020 12:20:00
CCRC were very disappointed about the recent article in The Times headlined “Watchdog’s work was not independent, court rules” (page 56 of The Times 23rd July*).
CCRC Annual Report and Accounts 2019/20 laid in Parliament15/07/2020 09:20:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission’s Annual Report and Accounts for 2019/20 was yesterday laid in Parliament.
The CCRC refers eight more Post Office cases for appeal – bringing total to 47 so far04/06/2020 12:10:00
Criminal Cases Review Commission has decided to refer a further eight Post Office workers’ convictions for appeal – this brings to 47 the number of cases to be sent for appeal so far on grounds related to the Horizon computer system.
Commission refers a further six Shrewsbury 24 convictions27/05/2020 09:20:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred to the Court of Appeal the convictions of a further six members of the Shrewsbury 24.
Commission refers the murder conviction of Gary Walker19/05/2020 12:20:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred for appeal the 2004 murder conviction of Gary Walker.
Commission refers the convictions of eight members of the Shrewsbury 2405/03/2020 15:38:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred for appeal the convictions of eight members of the Shrewsbury 24.
Commission refers the conviction of E to the Crown Court20/02/2020 14:38:00
The Criminal Cases Review Commission has referred the conviction of E to the Crown Court.