Wired-GOV Newswire (news from other organisations)
CIPD research reveals that employers are divided on employment tribunal fees as cases drop by 70%
Employers are split over the future of employment tribunal fees, which have resulted in a substantial 70% drop in the number of employment tribunal claims made by employees since their introduction in July 2013.
New research by the CIPD, the professional body for HR and people development, found that the majority of employers (38%) said that it should be left as it is, but a similar number (36%) believe that the fees should be either significantly reduced or abolished altogether and a quarter (27%) were undecided on what should be done.
|The report, Conflict Management: A Shift in Direction?,is based on a survey of 1,000 employers and highlights the CIPD’s call for business to take a more proactive approach to managing conflict in the workplace while exploring the impact of recent legislative changes, such as fees. It closely follows calls from Business Secretary Vince Cable for a review of the new fees system to be progressed “as a matter of urgency”.|
Commenting on the report, the Business Secretary Vince Cable said: “It's vital that the employment tribunal system strikes the right balance between employee and employer protection. I welcome this report from the CIPD and its valuable insights. The fact that employers are so split over whether the introduction of tribunal fees has been a good or a bad thing further reinforces the need for a review, despite opposition in some quarters. I've now set one in motion in my Department.
|The fee system was introduced as claims can cost employers several thousand pounds and an average of 19 working days for each individual case. Currently, employees can expect to pay up to £1,200 to bring a claim before an employee tribunal, a fee put in place in order to reduce the number of weak or vexatious claims. The knock-on effect of this has been a 70% drop in single claims made between April to June 2014 compared to the same period in 2013*.|
|Mike Emmott, Employee Relations Adviser for the CIPD, comments: “The introduction of fees has had a major impact on the behaviour of both employees and employers. The drop in claim volumes is unprecedented and shows just how far the terms of trade have shifted. Employers have long complained about the damaging effect that weak or unsubstantiated claims have on their business but given the staggering drop in claims since, it must be the case that some perfectly valid claims have been discouraged as a result of the new fees. Fees may not make it impossible for claimants to pursue their case but they’ve certainly made it more difficult, which begs the question: are we putting too high a price on justice?”|
|“It’s unlikely that the current fees regime will survive the General Election in May by many months as all three major political parties have indicated an intention to review it. Assuming that fees survive in some shape or form, it will be important to get the balance right between having a fee structure that is simple to understand and one that is proportionate to the type of claim being made.”|
|The reduction in claims volumes is accompanied by greater support for alternative forms of dispute resolution that seek to strike a balance between formal discipline and grievance processes, and more informal methods such as early conciliation and mediation.|
|The CIPD’s research indicates that the two fastest growing methods adopted by employers for dealing with conflict over the last 12 months have been training line managers to handle ‘difficult conversations’ or managing conflict (47%), and facilitated discussions or trouble shooting by HR managers (38%). In general, there has been greater emphasis on tackling conflict within the workplace. Almost a quarter (24%) of employers conducted internal mediation by a trained member of staff compared to almost one in ten (9%) who relied on external mediation.|
|The combination of reduced claims and ongoing emphasis on conciliation and mediation has led some employment lawyers to anticipate the possibility of a marked reduction in the role of the law in the dispute resolution process.|
|Emmott continues: “Conflict in the workplace can harm both employee wellbeing and productivity so it’s important that businesses build cultures that both minimise and prevent conflict from occurring in the first place. The CIPD has long promoted better people management, including the use of mediation, to deal with problems rather than simply relying on formal procedures and defaulting to a reactive stance on conflict. “It’s encouraging to see how many employers are making use of alternative methods of resolving issues and it’s welcome news that more managers are getting mediation training. This will improve the quality of conversations between them and their staff and help to defuse conflict before it can escalate; prevention is better than cure. “However, many managers are still stuck in a procedural paradigm, worried that any departure from established procedures will expose them to criticism and possible legal challenge. Better training in conflict management will give them the confidence they need to tackle issues when they arise. To support this, we also recommend that Acas should consider amending its Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures so as to give more guidance on mediation and performance management to support both line managers and HR professionals.”|
Other key findings in the report include:
A further CIPD report on conflict management - Getting Under the Skin of Workplace Conflict - explores the sources of conflict in the workplace and will be available at the end of March 2015. *Data from Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunal Service
Latest News from
Wired-GOV Newswire (news from other organisations)
NHS Confederation responds to Health Foundation polling on public priorities ahead of general election27/09/2023 13:25:00
Matthew Taylor responds to Health Foundation polling that shows four in five members of the public support more investment for the NHS.
RoSPA - Falls in descent: a look into our latest fall prevention report27/09/2023 12:25:00
RoSPA's joint study with Trent & Dove on Fall Prevention reveals that 69% of falls could be avoided
NHS Confederation responds to Ed Davey MP's speech at Liberal Democrat party conference27/09/2023 11:25:00
Dr Layla McCay comments from Bournemouth on the Leader of the Liberal Democrat's conference speech.
Retail Sales slump eases in September - CBI Distributive Trades Survey26/09/2023 16:05:00
Retail sales volumes fell in the year to September for a fifth consecutive month, but at a much slower rate than last month, according to the latest monthly CBI Distributive Trades Survey.
TUC: Ministers must bring in new laws to protect women from sexual harassment at work26/09/2023 12:05:00
TUC General Secretary Paul Nowak yesterday commented on more reports that demonstrate the scale and extent of sexual harassment and assault in the workplace.
Manufacturing output falls further, with volumes tipped to be flat through to the year's end - CBI Industrial Trends Survey22/09/2023 14:05:00
Manufacturers reported that output volumes declined more quickly than expected in the three months to September, according to the CBI’s latest Industrial Trends Survey. Output volumes are expected to stagnate over the next three months.
‘New workforce plan needed to drive economic growth’ – CIPD publishes its ‘Manifesto for Good Work’22/09/2023 10:10:00
CIPD sets out core themes for skilled, fair and healthy work that should underpin a new workforce strategy for the next UK Government
NHS Confederation - NHS doing all it can to meet demand for care22/09/2023 09:10:00
Assistant director of the Welsh NHS Confederation Nesta Lloyd-Jones responds to the latest NHS performance statistics in Wales.