CJEU: A Member State may exclude EU citizens from certain non-contributory social security benefits
Foreigners who go to Germany to obtain social assistance or whose right of residence arises solely out of a search for employment are excluded from entitlement to German benefits by way of basic provision (‘Grundsicherung’).1 In the judgment in Dano, 2 the Court of Justice recently held that such exclusion is lawful in the case of Member State nationals who go to another Member State with no intention of finding employment there.
In the present case, the Federal Social Court (Bundessozialgericht, Germany) seeks to ascertain whether such an exclusion is also lawful concerning Union citizens who have gone to a host Member State to search for employment and have already worked for a period in that State, where those benefits are granted to nationals of the host Member State who are in the same situation.
This question has arisen in proceedings between the Jobcenter Berlin Neukölln and four Swedish nationals: Ms Alimanovic, born in Bosnia, and her three children Sonita, Valentina and Valentino, born in Germany in 1994, 1998 and 1999 respectively. The Alimanovic family left Germany in 1999 for Sweden and returned to Germany in June 2010. Following their return, Nazifa Alimanovic and her eldest daughter Sonita worked in several temporary jobs lasting less than a year. Since then they have not been engaged in any occupational activity. The Alimanovic family was subsequently, during the period from 1 December 2011 to 31 May 2012, paid benefits by way of basic provision, namely subsistence allowances for the long-term unemployed (‘Arbeitslosengeld II’) payable to Nazifa Alimanovic and her daughter Sonita and social allowances for beneficiaries unfit to work for the children Valentina and Valentino. In 2012, the competent authority (Jobcenter Berlin Neukölln) finally ceased payment of the benefits; taking the view that Ms Alimanovic and her eldest daughter were excluded from entitlement to the allowances concerned as foreign jobseekers whose right of residence arose solely out of the search for employment. Consequently, that authority also excluded the other children from entitlement to the allowances pertaining to them.
In response to the questions referred by the German court, the Court has held, in its judgment delivered yesterday, that denying Union citizens whose right of residence in the territory of a host Member State arises solely out of the search for employment entitlement to certain ‘special noncontributory cash benefits’,3 which also constitute ‘social assistance’, 4 does not contravene the principle of equal treatment. 5
Latest News from
COVID-19: Budget MEPs call for quick progress on post-2020 contingency plan03/04/2020 14:33:00
Considering the health crisis and consequent delays to finding a timely agreement on the new long-term EU budget, Budget MEPs reiterate their call for an urgent 2021 contingency plan.
ESMA Publishes 24th Extract From Its EECS Database03/04/2020 13:25:00
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU securities markets regulator, today publishes the 24th extract from its database of enforcement decisions on financial statements.
10 things the EU is doing to fight the coronavirus03/04/2020 12:48:00
Find out what the European Institutions are doing to mitigate the impact of the Covid19 outbreak, protect people and the economy and promote solidarity.
ESMA Publishes 2019 Report on Enforcement of Corporate Disclosure03/04/2020 11:33:00
Convergence work on financial and non-financial disclosure.
Over 35,000 EU asylum officials trained by EASO03/04/2020 10:38:00
Despite the COVID-19 restrictions, EASO continues training Member States’ asylum and reception officials through e-learning and virtual sessions.
Fact-checking Day: Fighting the virus of disinformation on Covid-1903/04/2020 09:25:00
The outbreak of the coronavirus has led to fake news and disinformation spreading, which hamper efforts to contain the pandemic.
Robust monitoring and targets are key in shifting Europe to a more circular economy02/04/2020 15:25:00
Introducing more robust monitoring and targets to spur Europe’s move to a circular economy would help improve resource efficiency, according to a European Environment Agency (EEA) report published yesterday.
ESMA Advises The European Commission on Inducements And Costs And Charges Disclosures02/04/2020 14:33:00
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU’s securities markets regulator, yesterday published its advice to the European Commission (EC) on inducements and costs and charges disclosures under MiFID II.
Statement by Frans Timmermans, Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, on the announcement to postpone the COP2602/04/2020 13:25:00
Statement given yesterday by Frans Timmermans, Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, on the announcement to postpone the COP26.