CJEU: Cancellation fees charged by airline companies may be assessed for unfairness
Cancellation fees charged by airline companies may be assessed for unfairness. In addition, the various items which make up the final price to be paid to the airline companies must be indicated separately.
The German airline company Air Berlin included a term in its general terms and conditions stating that, when a passenger cancels a flight booking at an economy rate or does not take the flight, a sum of €25 is to be charged as a handling fee on the amount due to be reimbursed. The Bundesverband der Verbraucherzentralen (Federal Union of Consumer Organisations) considers that that term is invalid under German law, since it unduly disadvantages customers. Moreover, as it is the performance of a legal obligation, Air Berlin cannot charge separate fees. The Bundesverband accordingly brought an action before the German courts for an order prohibiting Air Berlin's practices.
In the context of the same action, the Bundesverband also challenges Air Berlin's practices concerning the display of prices on its website. During an online booking simulation in 2010, the Bundesverband noted that the taxes and charges indicated were much lower than those actually collected by the airports concerned. The Bundesverband considers that that practice may mislead the consumer and that it is contrary to the rules on price transparency laid down by the EU regulation on the operation of air services.
It is in that context that the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice, Germany) asked the Court of Justice for an interpretation of that regulation. The Bundesgerichtshof considers, in the same way as the Bundesverband, that the term relating to the handling fees of €25 in the event of cancelling a flight booking or not taking a flight unduly disadvantages customers and is accordingly invalid in accordance with the provisions of German law transposing the EU directive on unfair terms.2 The Bundesgerichtshof asks, however, whether the pricing freedom recognised for air carriers by the regulation on the operation of air services precludes a national law transposing EU law on consumer protection from applying to such a term.
Latest News from
We must speed up our cooperation on migration and forced displacement says EIB President Werner Hoyer16/10/2017 14:05:00
Better coordination of the work of Multilateral Development Banks could have a significant impact on the millions of people around the world affected by the migration and forced displacement challenge.
More attention must be given to Europe’s working poor16/10/2017 12:10:00
Eurofound Research Manager Daphne Nathalie Ahrendt looks at the increase in the number of workers that are at risk of poverty and are materially deprived following the 2008 economic & financial crisis, and evaluates the potential social ramifications for Europe.
Independence far from reality for many people with disabilities16/10/2017 09:25:00
Many people with disabilities in the EU still live in institutions. They risk being isolated, marginalised and prevented from living a full, independent life, and face worse conditions than people without disabilities.
Fifth round of Article 50 negotiations with the UK14/10/2017 09:15:00
Press statement by Michel Barnier following the fifth round of Article 50 negotiations with the United Kingdom
Operation in FIFA World Cup media rights-related investigations13/10/2017 15:05:00
Eurojust supported the international joint operation launched by the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) of Switzerland, in close cooperation with the judicial and law enforcement authorities of France, Greece, Italy and Spain.