CJEU: Court should dismiss the EC’s action against the UK concerning allowances for children
Advocate General Cruz Villalón proposes that the Court should dismiss the EC’s action against the UK concerning allowances for children. Checking whether claimants are lawfully resident in the host Member State in accordance with EU law when claims for certain social benefits are dealt with is justified by the necessity of protecting that State’s public finances.
Checking whether claimants are lawfully resident in the host Member State in accordance with EU law when claims for certain social benefits are dealt with is justified by the necessity of protecting that State’s public finances
Regulation No 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems1 lays down a series of common principles to be observed by the legislation of the Member States in this sphere. Those principles guarantee that persons exercising their freedom of movement and of residence within the EU will not be adversely treated by the various national systems because they have exercised that right. One of those common principles is the principle of equality. In the particular ambit of social security, it takes the form of prohibiting discrimination on grounds of nationality.
The Commission received many complaints from nationals of other Member States resident in the United Kingdom, stating that the competent UK authorities had refused their claims for certain social benefits because they had no right of residence in that State. The Commission has brought an action against the UK for failure to fulfil obligations on the grounds that the legislation of that Member State was incompatible with the provisions of Regulation No 883/2004, inasmuch as it required checking whether applicants for certain social benefits, including child benefit and child tax credit,2 which are the subject-matter of this case, are lawfully resident in its territory. The Commission takes the view that that condition is discriminatory and contrary to the spirit of that regulation, which takes into consideration only the claimant’s habitual residence.
In response to those arguments, the United Kingdom, relying on the judgment in Brey, 3 maintains that the host State may lawfully make the grant of social security benefits to EU citizens conditional upon them meeting the requirements for obtaining a right of residence in its territory, which are laid down in Directive 2004/38.4 On the other hand, the UK, although acknowledging that it is easier for UK nationals, who as a matter of principle enjoy the right to reside in that Member State, to fulfil the conditions giving entitlement to the social benefits in question in this case, claims that its national system is not discriminatory and that the condition of a right of residence is, at all events, a proportionate measure for ensuring that the benefits are paid to persons sufficiently integrated in the United Kingdom.
In his Opinion yesterday, Advocate General Pedro Cruz Villalón proposed that the Court of Justice should dismiss the Commission’s action.
Latest News from
Speech by President von der Leyen at the World Health Summit25/10/2021 15:25:00
Speech given yesterday by President von der Leyen at the World Health Summit.
Conference on the Future of Europe: second Plenary session concludes25/10/2021 13:25:00
On Saturday 23 October, the second Conference Plenary meeting took place in the European Parliament in Strasbourg to discuss citizens' contributions.
Mergers: Commission approves acquisition of IHS Markit by S&P Global, subject to conditions25/10/2021 12:38:00
The European Commission has approved, under the EU Merger Regulation, the proposed acquisition of IHS Markit by S&P Global.
Opening remarks by President von der Leyen at the joint press conference with President Michel following the meeting of the European Council of 21-22 October 202125/10/2021 11:33:00
Opening remarks given recently (22 October 2021) by President von der Leyen at the joint press conference with President Michel following the meeting of the European Council of 21-22 October 2021.
European Health Union: Commission establishes portfolio of 10 most promising treatments for COVID-1925/10/2021 10:25:00
Delivering on a key action from the EU Strategy on COVID-19 Therapeutics, the Commission is establishing a portfolio of 10 potential COVID-19 therapeutics.
EU Civil Protection celebrates 20th anniversary delivering assistance to people25/10/2021 09:25:00
The European Union is marking the 20th anniversary of its EU Civil Protection Mechanism tomorrow which has been activated more than 500 times to coordinate assistance people affected by natural disasters and other crises in Europe and worldwide.
The Commission makes Erasmus+ and European Solidarity Corps more inclusive22/10/2021 15:25:00
Today, the Commission has adopted a framework to increase the inclusiveness and diversity of the Erasmus+ and European Solidarity Corps programmes for the period 2021-2027.
Remarks by President Charles Michel before the European Council meeting on 21 October 202122/10/2021 13:25:00
Remarks given yesterday by President Charles Michel before the European Council meeting.
Main messages from the Tripartite Social Summit22/10/2021 09:25:00
EU leaders and social partners met, via video conference, at the Tripartite Social Summit to discuss "transforming Europe's recovery into long-term sustainable growth supporting more and better jobs".