CJEU: Execution of a European arrest warrant must be deferred if there is risk of inhuman or degrading treatment
If the existence of that risk cannot be discounted within a reasonable period, the authority responsible for the execution of the warrant must decide whether the surrender procedure should be brought to an end.
In Case C-404/15, a Hungarian investigating magistrate issued two European arrest warrants with respect to Mr Pál Aranyosi, a Hungarian national, so that a criminal prosecution could be brought for two offences of forced entry and theft, allegedly committed by Mr Aranyosi in Hungary.
In Case C-659/15 PPU, a Romanian court issued a European arrest warrant with respect to Mr Robert Căldăraru to secure the enforcement in Romania of a prison sentence of one year and eight months imposed for driving without a driving licence.
The two men having been located in Germany, it is the task of the German authorities to examine the warrants.
The Hanseatisches Oberlandesgericht in Bremen (Higher Regional Court of Bremen, Germany), which has to decide whether those warrants should be executed, found that the detention conditions to which Mr Aranyosi and Mr Căldăraru might be subject in the Hungarian and Romanian prisons respectively were contrary to fundamental rights, in particular the provision of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union prohibiting inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. In judgments of 10 June 2014 and 10 March 2015 the European Court of Human Rights held that Romania and Hungary had infringed fundamental rights due to the prison overcrowding which is characteristic of their prisons.
Latest News from
Brexit: EC welcomes decision by EU27 Member States to relocate UK-based Agencies21/11/2017 15:15:15
The EC welcomes the agreement at the General Affairs Council (Article 50 format) to move the European Medicines Agency (EMA) and the European Banking Authority (EBA) to Amsterdam and Paris, respectively. Both Agencies are currently located in London.
Michel Barnier - 'The Future of the EU'21/11/2017 14:25:00
Speech by Michel Barnier at the Centre for European Reform on 'The Future of the EU'
A Europe of equals: EC stands up for women's rights in turbulent times21/11/2017 13:10:00
A new Eurobarometer survey emphasises that gender equality is still not achieved in EU Member States. The EC is announcing concrete action to put an end to the gender pay gap through an Action Plan to be delivered between now and the end of its mandate in 2019.
The new organic Regulation21/11/2017 11:47:00
The EC welcomes the Council's endorsement of the co-legislators' agreement on the new rules on organic production and looks forward to the final steps leading to the adoption of the new Regulation. Once adopted, the new rules will enter into force on 1 January 2021.
ESMA publishes final report on Money Market Funds rules20/11/2017 14:25:00
ESMA has published a final report on the Money Market Funds Regulation (MMFR), which contains final versions of the technical advice, draft implementing technical standards (ITS), and guidelines on stress test scenarios carried out by MMF managers under the MMFR.