CJEU: Rejection as asylum seeker for participation in the activities of a terrorist network
In 2006, Mr Mostafa Lounani, a Moroccan national, was convicted in Belgium by the Brussels Criminal Court and sentenced to six years imprisonment, with respect to his participation in the activities of a terrorist group - namely the Belgian cell of the ‘Moroccan Islamic Combatant Group’ (‘the MICG’) – as a member of its leadership, criminal conspiracy, use of forged documents, and illegal residence. That court found in particular that Mr Lounani was guilty of ‘active participation in the organisation of a network for sending volunteers to Iraq’. In particular, the fraudulent transfer of passports was described as ‘an act of participation in the activities of a cell providing logistical support to a terrorist movement’.
In 2010, Mr Lounani applied to the Belgian authorities for refugee status. He claimed that he feared persecution in the event of his being returned to Morocco because of the likelihood that he would be regarded by the Moroccan authorities as a radical Islamist and jihadist, following his conviction in Belgium. That application for asylum was rejected.
An action against that decision having been brought before it, the Belgian Council for asylum and immigration proceedings (‘the CCE’) held in 2011 that Mr Lounani should be granted refugee status. The CCE confirmed its decision in 2012 after its initial decision was set aside by the Belgian Conseil d’État. The CCE took the view that the acts of which Mr Lounani was specifically convicted did not constitute terrorist offences as such, since the Brussels Criminal Court had found Mr Lounani to be guilty of belonging to a terrorist group, but had not convicted him of committing or participating in a terrorist act. No specific act by the MICG, even in inchoate form, falling within the scope of that type of offence had been established, nor had the fact of personal conduct on the part of Mr Lounani, giving rise to his individual liability for the performance of such an act, been established. According to the CCE, nothing in the conduct in respect of which Mr Lounani had been convicted reached the required degree of gravity to be categorised as ‘acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations’ within the meaning of the directive on refugee status, and accordingly Mr Lounani could not be excluded on that ground from refugee status.
An appeal on a point of law having been brought before it, the Conseil d’État decided to refer questions for a preliminary ruling to the Court of Justice. The Conseil d’État seeks in particular to ascertain under what circumstances an applicant for asylum can be excluded from refugee status for ‘acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations’ where he has been convicted in a criminal court of participation in the activities of a terrorist group but has not himself committed a terrorist act.
The Court notes, first, that it is clear from the file that Mr Lounani did not personally commit terrorist acts, or instigate such acts, or participate in their commission.
Latest News from
President Michel’s MFF proposal not acceptable for Parliament21/02/2020 09:25:00
Ahead of a special summit on 20 February, the EP’s negotiating team expresses its opposition to President Michel’s proposal for the next long-term budget.
Budgetary Control Committee asks for stronger measures to protect EU spending20/02/2020 15:25:00
On Wednesday, the Budgetary Control Committee signed off on the Commission’s 2018 budget, but rules to fight fraud and conflict of interest must be strengthened.
COVID-19 outbreak: Commission supports repatriation of EU citizens from cruise ship in Japan20/02/2020 12:25:00
The EU is co-financing the repatriation of EU citizens from the Diamond Princess cruise ship docked in Yokohama, Japan, thanks to flights from Italy mobilised through the EU Civil Protection Mechanism.
Shaping Europe's digital future: Commission presents strategies for data and Artificial Intelligence20/02/2020 11:38:00
The EC has unveiled its ideas and actions for a digital transformation that works for all, reflecting the best of Europe: open, fair, diverse, democratic and confident.
Fabio Panetta: Deepening & widening Economic and Monetary Union: finding the right speed19/02/2020 13:20:00
Introductory remarks by Fabio Panetta, Member of the Executive Board of the ECB, at the European Parliamentary Week.
"EU Budget risks being a failure for people & a gift to populism" warns CoR President19/02/2020 12:20:00
The European Committee of the Regions (CoR) asks to preserve funds for hospitals, schools, local transport, environment, universities and small businesses.
Council sets its priorities for the 2021 EU budget19/02/2020 11:20:00
The Council adopted the following conclusions setting out its priorities for the 2021 EU budget.
Human rights: EU adopts conclusions on EU priorities at UN Human Rights Fora in 202018/02/2020 13:25:00
On the occasion of the year marking the 75th anniversary of the entry into force of the UN Charter, the Council conclusions reaffirm EU's commitment to the rule-based international order – human rights protection being an important part of it.
Consultation on Air Quality - Executive Summary14/02/2020 12:20:00
The Secretariat of the Commission for Environment, Climate Change and Energy (ENVE) of the CoR is in the process of informing other EU institutional and non institutional actors about the Implementation Report of the consultation on Air Quality, whose Executive Summary is already available here.