CMA: is the customer voice being heard?
More customer engagement was carried out at PR19 than in any previous price review. But how has this translated into tangible outcomes for consumers, and is the CMA listening? CCW’s Mike Keil explores whether the customer voice is being heard as the appeal process continues.
A step change in both the quality and quantity of customer research and engagement was apparent at PR19 compared to previous price reviews. Water companies used a wide range of techniques and combined varied sources of customer opinions to gain a clearer picture of the diversity of priorities and expectations from different customer groups.
What’s less clear, though, is how that research and engagement was carried through into companies’ business plans, and the extent to which the customer voice is now being heard by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) as it makes its decisions on four company appeals.
It is hard at times in the CMA’s provisional finding to understand how the consumer voice has been acted on and in places it’s difficult to identify the “golden thread” linking customers’ views with the decisions made. While our own analysis of PR19 revealed several areas for improvement in terms of customer research, we have to guard against dismissing or minimising the consumer perspective merely because of these limitations.
Ensuring the consumer voice is heard is about more than just research. CCW has been a strong advocate for companies – and the CMA – using triangulation to take a wide view on consumer evidence, and the lack of clarity over how consumer evidence has been used leads us to question how the customers’ voice has been taken into account in the round – and consequently, how closely the CMA’s decisions are reflecting the voice of consumers.
A case in point: the cost of capital (WACC). It’s clear from CCW’s annual tracker survey, Water Matters, that fairness and value for money of water bills are areas where consumer sentiment is lower than it should be. The CMA’s decisions on the WACC and the removal of the gearing outperformance sharing mechanism – both of which appear to tip the balance in favour of shareholders over customers – do not appear to have considered either the potentially damaging effect this will have on customers’ perceptions of the water industry.
A lack of transparency over the impact these changes will have on customers’ bills also leads us to question how far consumers are really being considered. Bill profiles are important because they allow customers to understand how the decisions made by the CMA will affect them in practical terms – what’s my bill going to look like next year compared to what I pay now? Basic, yet important, information for consumers.
This lack of transparency over the real impact on customers’ bills will add to their financial worries at an extremely uncertain time. We are very concerned about the affordability of these increases given the impact of Covid-19. These bill increases, coupled with annual inflation, could be a tipping point for some struggling households.
These are just a couple of several areas where it’s hard to see how the CMA has fully considered the consumer perspective. The CMA’s decisions are extremely important as they impact millions of water consumers and will also have implications beyond the water sector. The need for the CMA to listen to consumers and amplify their voice has never been more important, and that’s what CCW will continue to campaign for as the CMA reaches its final decisions.
Latest News from
Green investment plans must have customer backing27/11/2020 09:20:00
The road to recovery from Covid-19 is going to be a long and hard one but we believe water companies can play a vital role in helping us to overcome the economic and social challenges we now face.
Consider the financially vulnerable, CCW urges the CMA23/11/2020 09:10:00
Careful consideration should be given to the future affordability of water bills, the Consumer Council for Water (CCW) has told the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). Steve Hobbs, Senior Policy Manager, reflects on the latest hearing.
Lifting the lid on leaky loos20/11/2020 09:20:00
Our recent Water Makes It Possible campaign gave us the opportunity to appreciate just how amazing water is, and sadly how much we can all be guilty of taking it for granted.
Water retailers reminded to treat struggling business customers fairly13/11/2020 16:20:00
Making sure that business customers who have been impacted by Covid-19 are well supported by their water retailer has been a pressing priority for CCW since the outbreak of the pandemic.
Consumer watchdog pledges to help more households access water company support13/11/2020 13:25:00
A fresh bid to break down the barriers to households getting the support they need from their water company during Covid-19 and other periods of disruption has been launched by the industry’s consumer watchdog.
Sky’s the limit when it comes to valuing water06/11/2020 09:20:00
Whether it’s brushing our teeth and watering the garden or washing or hands to keep ourselves protected from COVID-19 – almost every aspect of our lives depend on water.
CCW supports Consumer Vulnerability and Debt Conference (1-3 Dec)30/10/2020 09:20:00
The Consumer Council for Water (CCW) is delighted to be supporting and taking part in the 2020 Utility Week Consumer Vulnerability and Debt Conference (1-3 December).
CMA plans could tip the balance for struggling households28/10/2020 09:20:00
The Consumer Council for Water (CCW) yesterday called on the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to “think again” after voicing concerns over its provisional plans for four water companies’ future bills and service commitments.