Scottish Government
Printable version

Calls for clarity over £12 billion cuts

Concerns over Scotland Bill’s proposals.

The UK Government needs to clarify the extent of its proposed £12 billion welfare cuts and urgently outline how they will impact on Scotland’s new devolved social security powers, Social Justice Secretary Alex Neil said today.

In a letter to Secretary of State for Scotland David Mundell, Mr Neil asked for the Joint Ministerial Working Group on Welfare to be reconvened as soon as possible in order to discuss the impact of the proposed cuts.

The Cabinet Secretary also reiterated the Scottish Government’s concerns that the current Scotland Bill’s proposals for the devolution of social security and employment support services do not yet meet the spirit or substance of the Smith Commission.

His letter follows the publication of two welfare reform studies which reveal many people accessing UK Government benefits are being pushed into crisis situations and living in constant fear of further cuts, with disabled people particularly distressed by their treatment.

Mr Neil said: “Both Governments need to come together as a matter of urgency to discuss how the draft Scotland Bill can be amended to fully meet the proposals of the Smith Commission.

“After the hard work of the Smith Commission it is disappointing to see the Scotland Bill neither matches its recommendations on substance or in spirit. If enacted, the Bill as published will not provide future Scottish Governments with the powers it was promised to be able to take distinct policy decisions or deliver reform.

“The Secretary of State for Scotland also needs to outline the detail of the UK Government’s planned £12 billion benefit cuts, and explain how they could impact on the Scotland Bill’s social security powers.

“Personal Independence Payment will be devolved to the Scottish Parliament, but we have already heard the UK Government plans to slash it by 20 per cent – a move we have strongly argued against on the grounds of fairness.

“The UK Government is planning make even more swingeing cuts to benefits and we need to know if this includes benefits that are to be devolved. This would be wholly unacceptable.

“For the past five years we have had organisations lining up to tell us about the damaging effect of welfare reform and benefit cuts on the people of Scotland and we have seen report after report highlighting the distress and desperation caused. That is why I am so concerned about the further cuts that the UK Government is planning to make.”

Notes To Editors

The Joint Ministerial Working Group was established to provide a forum for discussion and decision-making to ensure the implementation of welfare-related aspects of the Smith Commission Report.

The Welfare Reform Tracking Study is available at:

Inclusion Scotland’s report How Welfare Reform Marginalises Disabled People, which was published on May 31, is available at:


Channel website:

Share this article

Latest News from
Scottish Government