Car emissions: manufacturers and a former EU Commissioner quizzed by MEPs
The EU needs a common definition of “normal car use”, says Renault. Diesel engine NOx emissions are the price paid to hit lower CO2 targets, says the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association. But Volkswagen is ashamed of cheating to beat strict US emissions laws. So said contributors to the “triple bill” of hearings in held by the Committee of Inquiry into Emission Measurements in the Automotive Sector (EMIS) on Wednesday and Thursday. Its work will continue after the summer break.
On Wednesday morning, MEPs also unanimously approved an interim report, drafted by co-rapporteurs Pablo Zalba Bidegain (EPP, ES) and Gerben-Jan Gerbrandy (ALDE, NL), summarising the committee's activities so far and outlining its work programme for the second half of its one-year mandate. The report is to be debated by Parliament as a whole on 13 September in Strasbourg.
Renault: legislator should define “normal conditions” for real-drive tests
Immediately after the vote, MEPs asked the Renault Group’s Executive Vice-President of in charge engineering Gaspar Gascon Abellan how manufacturers interpret EU legislation on emissions limits. He replied that “normal car use”, during which the vehicle should comply with emission standards, is too vague and should be clearly defined in EU rules.
Asked why Renault did not switch to the most efficient ways to reduce emissions earlier, when today’s standards were set, he explained that technology evolves constantly and that it takes 3 years to move from idea to product. Renault also has to consider car model life-spans of up to 10 years, he added.
Volkswagen: “we are ashamed and we apologise for deceiving customers”
Volkswagen Group Chief Technology Officer Ulrich Eichhorn, who took the post only after the emission test “defeat devices” scandal broke in the USA, pledged that VW is cooperating in all investigations and is committed to full transparency.
Asked how VW employees feel about the scandal, he replied “We are ashamed, we are demoralised and we apologise for deceiving our customers.” He affirmed that in Europe, VW’s diesel engine software does not manipulate test results, adding that it will be replaced anyway and that this should not affect the cars.
ACEA: reducing both CO2 and NOx emissions is a huge challenge
Emission and Fuels Director at the European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA) Paul Greening was grilled mostly about the issue of car manufacturers’ influence on drafting EU legislation. He predicted that measures to reduce diesel engine NOx emissions will eventually halt the trend towards smaller diesel car engines, because the challenge of packing all systems into a relatively small space, which might prove technically impossible to meet or simply too expensive.
Former Commissioner Dimas: “EU legislation is clear: a defeat device breaks the law”
EU Commissioner for the environment from 2004 to 2009 Stavros Dimas, the first Commission contributor to an EMIS hearing, explained that at that time, reducing air pollution was the main task of his department, which drafted legislation on new emissions standards, known as the Euro 5 and 6 regulations. These regulations were approved by the Commission in 2007.
Mr Dimas categorically rejected claims that the rules were ambiguous: “The VW case is fraud. Defeat devices are banned, the law is clear. Over-optimising exemptions is not in the spirit of the law - these should not be the rule.”
However, in further exchanges with MEPs, no clear agreement emerged on the issue of whether the “normal car use” definition might indeed be too vague.
The committee will meet again on Tuesday, 30 August in the afternoon, when Günter Verheugen, Commissioner for enterprise and industry from 2004 to 2010 and Peter Lakin, Vice-President of Faurecia Emissions Control Technologies, will reply to MEPs’ questions.
Latest News from
Make it easier for 11 million EU citizens to participate in European elections02/12/2022 14:33:00
MEPs adopted a series of proposals to reinforce the right of mobile EU citizens to vote and stand in European elections in the EU country in which they reside.
State aid: Commission opens in-depth investigation into Lithuanian measure to compensate Litgas for operation of LNG terminal02/12/2022 13:25:00
The European Commission has opened an in-depth investigation to assess whether the compensation granted by Lithuania to Litgas UAB (‘Litgas') for supplying a mandatory quantity of liquefied natural gas (‘LNG') to the LNG terminal in Klaipėda between 2016 and 2018 is in line with EU State aid rules.
Waste shipments: stricter rules to protect the environment and human health02/12/2022 12:38:00
The Environment Committee yesterday adopted its position on revised rules governing shipments of waste to boost the EU circular economy, resource efficiency and zero pollution goals.
State aid: Commission approves €1 billion French scheme to support companies in the context of Russia's war against Ukraine02/12/2022 11:33:00
The European Commission has approved a €1 billion French scheme to support companies in the context of Russia's war against Ukraine.
Energy saving: EU action to reduce energy consumption02/12/2022 10:38:00
Saving energy is key to fighting climate change and reducing the EU's energy dependency. Find out what MEPs are doing to reduce consumption.
Investment Plan for Europe: €35 million EIB loan for Spanish company GAM to support electric rental fleets and sustainable last-mile delivery02/12/2022 09:33:00
The European Investment Bank (EIB) will lend €35 million to the Spanish multinational GAM (BME ticker: GALQ), which specialises in turnkey machinery solutions for industry, to make its rental fleet electric and develop more sustainable last-mile solutions for its subsidiary Inquieto.
MEPs adopt EU budget 2023: focus on Ukraine, energy and recovery30/11/2022 10:33:00
For next year’s EU budget, MEPs secured better and more effective support for addressing the consequences of the war in Ukraine and the pandemic recovery process.
Youth Action Plan: Council involves young people in policy-making30/11/2022 09:25:00
The Council recently (28 November 2022) approved conclusions on the Youth Action Plan for engaging young people in EU external action.
World Cup in Qatar: FIFA should help compensate families of dead migrant workers29/11/2022 16:33:00
With the 2022 FIFA World Cup having kicked off in Qatar, Parliament deplores the deaths of thousands of migrant workers ahead of the tournament.
State aid: Commission approves €557 million German support to compensate Deutsche Bahn for damages suffered by its subsidiary DB Fernverkehr due to the coronavirus pandemic29/11/2022 15:25:00
The European Commission has found a €557 million German support measure in favour of Deutsche Bahn to be in line with EU State aid rules.