Charity regulator concerned by quality of external scrutiny of charity accounts
Commission working with accountancy profession to drive up standards.
A new study published yesterday by the Charity Commission, has found that only around half of charity accounts reviewed met the regulator’s external scrutiny benchmark. This follows reviews of the quality of charity accounts which show that auditors and independent examiners are failing to identify significant failings in charity accounts.
A sample of 296 charities’ accounts have been assessed against a new external scrutiny benchmark developed by the Commission to determine whether a minimum standard of scrutiny by auditors and independent examiners has been met. Compliance with the benchmark does not amount to full compliance with the requirements of the Charities SORP; the benchmark is about ensuring that the basic requirements have been met, making yesterday’s findings particularly concerning.
Failings included incomplete reporting of related party transactions*; of 77 cases in which these were not properly disclosed, although in all likelihood an oversight, none were reported to the Commission by auditors or independent examiners. This raises additional concerns that the failure by trustees to manage conflicts of interest is also being under-reported.
Accounts reviewed by an auditor met the benchmark more frequently than those reviewed by an independent examiner. Although qualified examiners performed better, only 44% of accounts submitted by qualified examiners met the benchmark. Just 18% of unqualified examiners met the benchmark.
The regulator is working closely with ICAEW and ACCA to improve their members’ awareness of charity reporting and accounting requirements. It has passed details of accounting practitioners that failed to meet the benchmark to their relevant professional bodies so that they can assist them. The Commission may also use non-compliance with the benchmark to raise formal complaints with professional bodies.
The Commission is making its benchmark available on GOV.UK and expects those scrutinising charity accounts to make use of it and trustees and those interested in charity accounts to be aware of it.
Nigel Davies, Head of Accountancy Services at the Charity Commission yesterday said:
We know from research we have carried out into public trust in charities that the public care deeply about transparency. It is therefore vital that charities are able to provide an accurate and clear picture of their finances.
External scrutiny is an essential part of the checks and balances process that charity accounts go through and so it is disappointing that so many independent examiners and auditors appear to lack the necessary understanding of the external scrutiny framework.
Those that are getting this right are playing an important role in upholding charities’ accountability to us as regulator, and the public. Clearly others are letting the profession and charities down. We are working closely with the accounting profession to tackle shortcomings and raise standards; I am encouraged by the commitments to work with us that have already been made.
The benchmark will also support the Commission’s regulatory casework, by identifying external scrutiny that failed the benchmark. The regulator has already contacted 135 charities that filed trustees’ annual reports, external scrutiny reports and/or accounts that failed the benchmark, and provided guidance to help them improve the quality of future trustees’ reports and accounts.
Nigel Davies added:
I hope trustees will learn from this study, in terms of the expectations around reporting, and in ensuring they select an independent examiner that knows about and understands the requirements.
The Commission has updated its ‘Independent examination of charity accounts: guidance for trustees (CC31)’, to make it more accessible to trustees. The guidance is aimed at helping trustees appoint an independent examiner with the right ability and practical experience to carry out a competent examination of the accounts, and allowing them to prepare appropriately.
Notes to Editors
- *Further detail on the reporting of related party transactions is available in Accounts monitoring review: reporting of related party transactions in charity accounts, also published.
- Research published in July 2018 looked at the factors the public associate with a trustworthy charity. The findings are available on GOV.UK.
- Charities with incomes over £25,000 must arrange for either an audit or an independent examination of their charity’s accounts and if the charity’s income is more than £250,000 the examiner must be qualified. Charities with incomes over £1 million (and those with incomes over £250,000 and gross assets over £3.26 million) must have an audit. Most other charities can opt for an independent examination, unless an audit is required for another reason, such as by the charity’s governing document.
Press enquiries – office hours 0300 065 2123
Press enquiries – out of hours 07785 748787
Latest News from
Regulators set out plans to ensure the charity accounting framework better serves the public16/09/2019 09:20:00
New SORP-making process announced following governance review.
Charity Commission disqualifies trustee for ‘wholly inadequate’ running of charitable fund for Syria13/09/2019 15:10:00
Trustee failed to adequately demonstrate how charitable funds raised had been spent
If your charity last did an annual return before 12 November 201812/09/2019 09:15:00
The Charity Commission changed its systems on 12 November 2018. If you have not submitted an annual return online since then, you’ll need to do things differently.
Regulator investigates seven linked charities over financial concerns09/09/2019 13:20:00
Significant discrepancies in charity accounts raise serious concerns.
Trustees disqualified for serious misconduct and mismanagement at charity misused for terrorism offences involving children09/09/2019 09:20:00
Charity regulator reports on its inquiry into Essex Islamic Academy.
Safeguarding improved at Catholic Diocese after charity regulator investigates03/09/2019 15:42:00
Charity Commission expects ‘momentum of progress and improvement' to be maintained at Birmingham Diocesan Trust after finding misconduct and/ or mismanagement around safeguarding
Charities Against Fraud Awards 201921/08/2019 09:20:00
The Fraud Awards will recognise and celebrate the achievements of people proactively fighting fraud in the charity sector.