Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Churn and political interference hampering major project delivery, says PACAC report
Political pressures and staff turnover can significantly impact the Government’s ability to successfully deliver major infrastructure projects, finds an interim report published
Effective project design and delivery is vital for taxpayer returns
Government annual spending on high-profile construction and defence infrastructure projects runs into the billions of pounds, and although these are often projected to provide considerable taxpayer returns in the future, effective project design and delivery is vital if these forecasts are to be realised.
In an interim report published ahead of the dissolution of Parliament, PACAC outlines key themes raised so far during its inquiry and recommends that a successor Committee continues investigating these issues in the future.
Chair of the Committee, Sir Bernard Jenkin MP said:
“The purpose of major infrastructure projects should be to deliver benefits to the public, and our Civil Service is rightly charged with ensuring these are delivered as originally advertised. However, our inquiry to date has raised familiar concerns: capability, churn, conflicts of interest, and perhaps most concerningly, individual political imperatives overriding proper scrutiny of business cases.
“With Government’s Major Projects Portfolio currently overseeing 133 projects with a value of £423 billion, addressing these issues to the benefit of all taxpayers should be high on the list of priorities for any future Government.”
Central Government oversight
The report highlights a trend of increasing oversight from the centre of Government, although individual departments remain responsible for major project delivery. It recommends further examination of the relationship between the Infrastructure Projects Authority and individual departments, and how it can best develop capability through its leadership of the cross-government Project Leadership Function.
Civil Service capability and skills
This has been an issue long highlighted by PACAC inquiries, and the report welcomes investment in developing the skills base necessary for the delivery of major projects. It also highlights the need for long-term assessment of whether this investment has yielded better delivery.
Churn and conflicts of interest
Alongside capability, the impact of ‘churn’ has been similarly highlighted as posing considerable challenges across the Civil Service. The Committee’s report acknowledges that while the lengthy nature of many major projects makes a certain level of staff turnover inevitable, and sometimes desirable as projects unfold, there are undeniably negative consequences that can only be partially mitigated against; such as the potential for conflicts of interest. It recommends that a successor Committee focus on potential solutions to this acute challenge.
Political pressure in planning
The report argues that a poorly planned project often never recovers, and pre-approval scrutiny of business cases must therefore be robust and unvarnished in its ultimate assessment of project viability. Whilst it is entirely appropriate for Ministers to initiate projects, political pressure must not undermine in this scrutiny process.
Evaluating project benefits
The report fully accepts the difficulties inherent in forecasting the benefits of major projects, and subsequently evaluating whether they have been delivered as planned. However, it underlines that major projects should not be viewed as an end in themselves but rather as a way of delivering public policy goals. The linkage between projects and the needs they are supposed to address, and proper evaluation of whether they have done so, cannot be overlooked when considering how best to deliver them in the future.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Report published on the Withdrawal Agreement Bill15/01/2020 11:25:00
The Constitution Committee has published a report on the constitutional issues in the Government’s Withdrawal Agreement Bill. The Bill is of the highest constitutional significance, given its intended effect of implementing Brexit.
Brexit: revised Withdrawal Agreement and Political Declaration report published by Committee10/01/2020 14:25:00
The House of Lords EU Select Committee has today published its report on the revised EU Withdrawal Agreement and the Political Declaration on future UK-EU relations ahead of House Lords consideration of the Withdrawal Agreement Bill, which starts on Monday 13 January.
Public service broadcasters are essential and need to be supported, says Lords Committee06/11/2019 13:20:00
The Communications and Digital Committee warns that public service broadcasters (PSBs) need to be better supported to ensure that they can continue to produce high-quality drama and documentaries which reflect and examine UK culture. In return, the broadcasters need to adapt to ensure that they serve and reflect all audiences.
Implications of Withdrawal Agreement Bill examined06/11/2019 12:20:00
The Constitution Committee publishes an interim report on the constitutional issues in the Government’s Withdrawal Agreement Bill. The bill is of the highest constitutional significance, given its intended effect of implementing a Brexit deal.
NHS property services set up to fail06/11/2019 11:25:00
NHS Property Services Limited has made progress in tackling some of the issues that it inherited when it was set up. However, it has struggled to get its tenants to sign rental agreements for the properties they occupy, and it is unacceptable that 70% of its tenants still do not have rental agreements in place.
Court reforms slow to check impact of changes05/11/2019 14:25:00
HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS) has again fallen behind on critical reforms. HMCTS is now 3 years into its ambitious £1.2 billion programme to modernise the courts, which plan to change the way people access justice by digitising paper-based services, moving some types of cases online, introducing virtual hearings, closing courts and centralising customer services.
Committee calls for measures to help avoid next corporate collapse05/11/2019 11:25:00
The Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee yesterday wrote to Andrea Leadsom (PDF 77 KB), the Secretary of State for the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, with a series of recommendations on corporate governance, executive pay and bonuses, and audit reform following its recent public evidence sessions examining the collapse of Thomas Cook.
UK electoral law poses "serious and unnecessary risks"04/11/2019 14:25:00
Current UK electoral law poses serious and unnecessary risks for everybody involved, concludes Electoral Law: the urgent need for reform, a report published recently (01 November 2019) by the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee (PACAC).