Civitas - Small business owners experience ‘a great disconnect’ from government – despite repeated claims they form the ‘backbone of the economy’
Politicians of all parties repeatedly declare that small businesses form the ‘backbone of the British economy’. Yet a new survey shows that those same politicians too often fail to provide the right level of support for small business, resulting in ‘a great disconnect’, a new Civitas book reveals.
Tim Knox finds in two surveys that many small business owners feel that government tend to listen to big business far more closely to that of small business – and that multi-national companies receive preferential treatment from government.
Micro-business owners (with five of employees or less) feel unenthusiastic about the support they get from government. About one in three business owners surveyed felt government support for their business had got worse over the last five years, while almost half said it was neither better or worse. Those trends are contributing towards a sense of neglect from government for small business. Knox writes:
‘With over two-thirds of respondents feeling that they receive no positive support from government, it is clear that the rhetoric of politicians claiming to support small businesses is not reflected on the ground.’
‘Another concern for government should be the extraordinary sense among the majority (60%) of micro-business owners that there are no business services provided by government which are intended to help small businesses, despite the fact that there are many such services.’
This marks the great disconnect. Several proposals are set out to help government reconnect with the small business sector, including:
- Government could reverse the easy inclination to listen to big business as if it were the voice of all;
- The government should undertake regular polling of small business owners to ensure that it has an accurate register of small business opinion, of how that opinion changes and of the reason for any such changes;
- It could develop communication strategies to ensure that initiatives intended to support small businesses are being heard and are having the desired effect;
- Government services could be better communicated by adopting the Charity Commission advice it sends to all charities as a template;
- The government could focus any attempt to support SMEs in those regions which have a relatively low number of businesses per head of the population.
Update: ‘Unleashing the potential’ of the regions
Following criticism of the government’s business Councils in this report, Boris Johnson last week announced plans to axe the ineffectual ‘Small Business, Scale ups and Entrepreneurs Business Council’ and the four other Councils in the business council network. Tim Knox comments:
‘It is excellent news that the government is now trying to reconnect small business and government. When doing so, it should also focus on the significant regional disparities in SME activity: for example, the North East of England has just 694 businesses per 10,000 people compared to 1,544 in London.
‘“Unleashing the potential” of the regions should be a priority. And a first step should be to engage better with small business owners by following through with the recommendations in my report.’
The Great Disconnect
Latest News from
The Spending Review is 'unlikely to be enough to address health and care pressures': The King's Fund responds to the Spending Review26/11/2020 14:35:00
Sally Warren, Director of Policy at The King’s Fund, responded to the Chancellor’s Spending Review
Initial reaction from IFS researchers on Spending Review 2020 and OBR forecasts26/11/2020 13:35:00
IFS Director Paul Johnson says: “Rishi Sunak has been spending truly astonishing amounts of money this year and plans to continue to do so next year in response to Covid.
Spending Review 2020: IPPR response26/11/2020 12:35:00
Spending review misunderstands 'basic economics' and will leave economy needlessly damaged
Rishi cannot tax our way out of debt or spend our way out of a recession — Adam Smith Institute26/11/2020 11:35:00
Following the spending review by the Chancellor, the Adam Smith Institute’s Deputy Director Matt Kilcoyne criticises the public sector spending splurge
Chancellor’s words ring hollow as less is spent on levelling up - JRF26/11/2020 10:35:00
Helen Barnard, Director of the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation responded to the Chancellor’s Spending Review
IEA - The Chancellor’s diagnosis was correct but “the medicine is inadequate”26/11/2020 09:35:00
Mark Littlewood, Director General at the free-market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to the Chancellor’s Spending Review
Adam Smith Inst - UK Free Speech Under Threat24/11/2020 13:35:00
Government should introduce a United Kingdom Free Speech Act modelled on the First Amendment of the USA
Civitas - Think-tank report warns of dangers that campus relations at universities are becoming ‘racialised’ – as sector seeks to address disparities through ethnic grouping24/11/2020 12:35:00
“There is a real danger that campus relations at universities will become racialised”, says Dr Ruth Mieschbuehler, in this new report for Civitas.
Public sector pay freeze “appropriate” at this time, says IEA expert24/11/2020 11:35:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at the free-market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to reports that the Treasury will announce a public sector pay freeze in this week’s Spending Review
IFS - Minimum unit pricing works better if implemented alongside reformed alcohol taxes24/11/2020 10:35:00
The UK government has put out a call for evidence, seeking views on how well the alcohol duty system currently works and how it could be reformed. In new IFS research – funded by the European Research Council and the Economic and Social Research Council and published last week- we show that minimum unit prices for alcohol are reasonably well targeted at heavy drinkers, but come at the cost of hindering competition and reducing tax revenues. A minimum unit price, combined with a more coherent set of taxes on alcohol, would be just as well targeted at heavy drinkers and would limit the fall in revenue for the exchequer.