Civitas - Social democracy faces extinction without a new high-growth economic strategy – John Mills
The centre-left faces ‘extinction’ unless it can break free of neoliberal economic dogma and find a way to credibly deliver significantly higher rates of growth in the years ahead, a new book by the businessman and Labour donor John Mills warns.
Social democratic parties across the west face ‘potentially existential threats’ and ‘secular decline’ like that which led to the demise of the Liberal Party in the early 20th century, he writes.
He traces the demise of the centre-left – supplanted in the Labour Party by a far-left agenda – to its failure to offer a credible alternative to the free-market policies that supplanted Keynesianism in the 1970s. This led to relatively poor growth while in power, and an inadequate critique of austerity policies once ejected from office.
In Left Behind: Why voters deserted social democracy – and how to win them back, Mills writes:
‘The main reason for this state of affairs lies in the fact that the centre-left has consistently failed to mount a successful counter-attack to the neoliberal overturn of the Keynesian policies which were crucial to the economic success of the immediate post-war period.
‘Instead, across the West, the centre-left establishment fell in line behind the dominant new monetarist and neoliberal doctrines, although it was always apparent that they served the interests of the right much better than the people whom the left was supposed to be representing.’
This problem was exacerbated by two further developments, he argues:
- Redistributive policies became increasingly ineffective in the face of widening disparities between those doing well out of globalisation and those doing badly.
- Differences in attitudes and values widened and became more conspicuous, and notably so between social democratic political leaders and their traditional electoral base.
‘The thesis in this book is that the first and most crucial way ahead for social democracy is for it to be better at running the economies for which it might be responsible, and better at mounting critiques against right-of-centre administrations which are performing poorly – and therefore relatively harshly, especially on the most vulnerable – on the economic front.
‘To do this, the critical requirement is that social democracy breaks free from some of the key tenets of neoliberalism and embraces policies which will produce considerably higher rates of economic growth than we have seen recently. This is not going to be an easy task, but the alternative for the moderate left of centre may be something close to extinction.’
Mills calls for economic policy to be geared towards raising investment from 16% of GDP at present to the world average of 25%, particularly in technology, mechanisation and power.
To make such investment feasible, there needs to be a reduction in the cost base for manufacturers by reducing the exchange rate for sterling, which is currently too high for UK manufacturing to compete adequately in world markets.
All of this requires an end to the fixation with keeping inflation to 2 per cent per annum instead of prioritising a faster rate of economic growth sufficient to raise living standards for everybody.
‘If industrial competitiveness in world markets is the key to the transition which needs to be accomplished and a lower exchange rate is needed to trigger the changes in incentives which have to be made to achieve this goal, we will never get there if the mantra is 2% inflation,’ he writes.
‘It is this target that keeps the exchange rate too high, discourages investment, deindustrialises the country, causes our balance of payments deficits and borrowing, and generates inequality. If social democracy is to recover, social democrats need to be willing to take some more risks with inflation and to substitute growth targets for those based on corralling inflation at 2%.’
Latest News from
IEA: Labour Party is “wrong to focus purely on social housing”21/11/2019 15:35:00
Head of Political Economy at the Institute of Economic Affairs Dr Kristian Niemietz responded to Labour’s manifesto announcement, calling for the biggest council and social house building programme for decades
IEA - Merging taxes not “tinkering with NI thresholds” would better help low-paid21/11/2019 14:35:00
Editorial and Research Fellow Professor Len Shackleton responded to the Conservative Party’s announcement to raise the National Insurance threshold for workers
The King’s Fund responds to the Liberal Democrat manifesto21/11/2019 13:35:00
Richard Murray, Chief Executive of The King's Fund, commented on the Liberal Democrat manifesto
IEA responds to Liberal Democrats’ manifesto21/11/2019 12:35:00
Director General at the Institute of Economic Affairs Mark Littlewood commented on the Liberal Democrats’ manifesto
Liberal Democrats Manifesto: A jump to the left on economics, says ASI21/11/2019 11:35:00
The Adam Smith Institute has responded to the Liberal Democrats Manifesto announcement.
Demos - Create a National Minimum Wage for the self-employed, says think tank21/11/2019 10:35:00
A new report from Demos looking at financial security for the modern, liquid workforce is calling for the next government to introduce a Self-Employed National Minimum Wage, as a crucial step towards improving financial security for lower paid self-employed workers.
IFS - Labour plans to raise income tax for 1.6 million people – the highest-income 3% of adults21/11/2019 09:35:00
The Labour Party has announced plans to introduce a 45% income tax rate on annual incomes over £80,000 and a 50% rate on incomes over £125,000 from 2020–21. New analysis by IFS researchers, funded by the Nuffield Foundation, examines the likely effects of this policy.
IFG - Costs of creating a new government department revealed19/11/2019 16:35:00
The incoming – or returning – prime minister may want to stamp his or her authority on government by rearranging departments, but new research lays bare the total costs involved in creating new departments.
Public demand “fundamental reform” of UK economy finds new poll for IPPR19/11/2019 15:35:00
IPPR/YouGov poll finds majority across party and Brexit divides in favour of significant changes to how the UK economy is run
The King's Fund responds to the General Medical Council's new report on the wellbeing of doctors19/11/2019 14:35:00
Suzie Bailey, Director of Leadership and Organisational Development at The King’s Fund, commented on a new report on the wellbeing of doctors commissioned by the General Medical Council