Civitas - Think-tank report warns of dangers that campus relations at universities are becoming ‘racialised’ – as sector seeks to address disparities through ethnic grouping
“There is a real danger that campus relations at universities will become racialised”, says Dr Ruth Mieschbuehler, in this new report for Civitas.
Earlier this year, the Government announced the Commission on race and ethnic disparities, with its main purpose to review inequality in the UK, including in the area of education. This followed the growing interest among many members of the public, but in particular students, towards race relations in the UK.
The report focuses on ‘racialisation’ – referring to the process of emphasising racial and ethnic grouping – to show how higher education policies and practices implemented to address the ‘ethnic’ attainment gap are driving this trend.
“The result of these interventions is that students are ‘minoritised’. They are held to be in need of special treatment.”
“The minoritisation of students drives racialisation on campuses because the higher education sector is trying to understand and address disparities through ethnic grouping…”
“Racialisation, in turn, minoritises students because it denies students their individuality by emphasising their group identity and vulnerability.”
By reflecting on the so-called ‘ethnic’ attainment gap in higher education, the report finds that:
“What appears to be a significant gap when attainment is reported by ethnicity has been shown to be significantly reduced when other factors known to impact on attainment are taken into account.”
“…There is no statistical evidence that ‘ethnicity’ determines educational attainment of higher students. Yet policymakers and practitioners believe in the ‘ethnic’ attainment gap and introduce measures to address it with adverse consequences.”
This stigmatises students based on their ethnicity and contributes to the racialisation of campus relations.
The practice of defining and grouping students by their skin colour and basing attainment policies and practices on these divisions drives a wedge between people and removes any sense of our common humanity.
Meanwhile, the continued rise of a new type of ‘deficit talk’ depicts students as being vulnerable – and ultimately, it denies students the opportunity to develop fully academically while accommodating them to failure.
Ruth Mieschbuehler suggests a long-overdue change in approach. Universities need to re-examine the reporting of statistical data on attainment that has contributed unjustly to the perpetuation of the diminished educational status of students from minority ethnic backgrounds. The report concludes by rejecting the practice of grouping higher education students by their skin colour and ethnicity in future policies and practices.
To address the current drivers behind the racialisation of campus relations, it is recommended universities will need to:
- “Firstly, re-examine the reporting of statistical data on attainment that has contributed unjustly to the perpetuation of the diminished educational status of students from minority ethnic backgrounds.”
- “Secondly, reject the practice of grouping and referring to higher education students by their skin colour and ethnicity for basing policies and practices.”
- “Thirdly, recognise that students are not vulnerable and have agency and can take charge of their own learning.”
- “Fourthly, refocus on subject-based teaching and provide students with the academic education they desire and deserve.”
Latest News from
National League should suspend the season “with immediate effect”, says IEA expert21/01/2021 10:35:00
Statement by Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at free-market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs
BBC licence fee is “anachronistic and in dire need of reform”, says IEA expert21/01/2021 09:35:00
IEA responds to NAO report on the BBC licence fee
Hiking corporation tax would be ‘illogical and counterproductive”, says IEA expert19/01/2021 11:35:00
Mark Littlewood, Director General at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to reports that the Chancellor Rishi Sunak is considering raising corporation tax
IPPR - UK risks EU retaliation if workers’ rights are rolled back19/01/2021 10:35:00
IPPR trade and EU relations expert says leaked proposal to cut working time protections would also be damaging and deeply unpopular
Any extension of the Universal Credit uplift should not be made permanent, says IEA expert19/01/2021 09:35:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to calls to extend the £20 a week Universal Credit uplift
King's Fund - Boost for local health partnerships as six areas secure place on £3 million grant-funding programme14/01/2021 12:35:00
Six areas in England have been chosen to join the first phase of a major grant-funding and development programme designed to improve the health and wellbeing of communities and tackle health inequalities.
IEA - JRF proposals constitute a “costly and unrealistic wish list”14/01/2021 11:35:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s report on poverty
The King’s Fund responds to Office for National Statistics deaths data for 202014/01/2021 10:35:00
Richard Murray, Chief Executive of The King’s Fund responded to the latest Office for National Statistics data on deaths in England and Wales in 2020
JRF - After a decade of deprivation, we need policies that prioritise recovery for families in poverty14/01/2021 09:35:00
In yesterday’s state of the nation report, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation warns that ministers must make tackling poverty an economic priority in 2021 or they risk being defined by a record of worsening hardship.