Civitas - Towards Strategic Coherence: Reform proposals following ‘Inadvertently Arming China?’
A Civitas report, Inadvertently Arming China? in February this year revealed the widespread sponsorship of scientific research centres in UK universities by Chinese military-linked conglomerates and universities. It found research at some of these centres is being sponsored by the British taxpayer.
Notably, some of these conglomerates produce Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs) including intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) and nuclear warheads. Others manufacture strike fighter engines, stealth aircraft, military drones and navy ships.
Given the wider debate and UK policy announcements that followed this report, focusing on how rival states might use economic tools to undermine the economic and security interests of rivals, combined with increased competition for scarce natural resources, this follow-up report proposes detailed policy solutions to this ‘strategic incoherence’.
‘The risk of the Chinese military sponsorship of UK academia is not just that outputs may be put to use by the Chinese military, but that they create other strategic risks’, the report argues.
‘The UK Government has not yet prevented Chinese military companies from investing in the UK and benefitting from UK-based research, despite their products being put to use by the Chinese state in what is credibly called a genocide in Xinjiang, and supplying regimes including Burma and Syria. A sanctions regime would prevent investment in the UK, including its research facilities.’
Academic Technology Approval Scheme (ATAS)
‘The Academic Technology Approval Scheme (ATAS) has been strengthened. But it should be further reviewed. The central ATAS requirement is to ‘ensure that people who are applying to study certain subjects in the UK do not have existing links to WMD programmes’. ATAS should be amended to prevent the entry into the UK of the staff and students of certain military-linked universities, laboratories and conglomerates in China (and equivalents in some other autocracies).’
UK equivalent of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS)
‘CFIUS is an inter-agency body, whereas the UK’s new Investment Security Unit (ISU) is to be based under the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), whose priority is liable to be inward investment. An inter-departmental ISU would be preferable’.
Defence research funding for universities
‘In the US, Defense Department funding comprises 40 per cent of all engineering research and development (R&D) in universities: the UK may need an equivalent of its Defense University Research Instrumentation Program (DURIP).’
‘The UK should better distinguish between Basic and Applied Research in universities; university departments should also need to outline all the uses research could be put to, instead of what they think it will be used for.’
Five Eyes cooperation
‘The UK should push to expand university collaboration under the Five Eyes’ Technical Cooperation Program. A formal research collaboration programme funded by Five Eyes governments could closely involve leading universities.’
‘Some of the Export Control Order (ECO) is unclear. For example, the requirement to “[have] grounds for suspecting” allows considerable leeway. Article 34(3)(a) states that an offence will be committed if the person “has been informed” that goods (and so forth) “may be intended for [military] use”, but this allows activities to be treated differently depending on the claims of researchers. The system’s complexity is a concern in itself: leading lawyers say they do not fully grasp its implications.’
‘A number of requirements, such as to “check whether your potential collaboration partner [has] been involved in activities of potential concern using [e.g.] internet searches” are unreliable.
‘The “public domain” exclusion for published research also creates risks: other spin-offs from research that has also produced published papers may help military advancement. This needs clarification that restrictions on other transfers may still apply.’
Latest News from
IFS - Higher education enables graduates to move to places with better career prospects – but this leads to brain drain from the North and coastal areas17/09/2021 11:20:00
By age 27, graduates are 10 percentage points more likely to have moved away from the area where they grew up than otherwise similar non-graduates. Graduates who move tend to move to London and other affluent cities and experience large gains in earnings. This suggests that higher education enables people to move to areas that offer better labour market opportunities.
JRF - New Cabinet faces living standards crisis if they go ahead with cut to Universal Credit16/09/2021 15:20:00
JRF responds to House of Commons debate on the planned cut to Universal Credit and Working Tax Credit.
Civitas - Two Tests for UK Trade: Does seamless, tariff-free trade boost exports and does distance matter?16/09/2021 14:20:00
During the UK’s departure from the European Union, debate about UK trade policy was dominated by two assertions:
Inflation could reach 5 per cent by Christmas, says IEA Expert15/09/2021 16:10:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, responded to ONS consumer price inflation figures for August 2021
IEA - Think tank helped ensure UK-EU FTA “against the odds”15/09/2021 14:15:00
The Institute of Economic Affairs has reached the final of this year’s Templeton Freedom Award, which celebrates organisations that have made a meaningful impact on the proliferation of free market ideas through education, policy research or media outreach.
JRF - New research highlights ‘shameful’ racial disparities in housing system15/09/2021 09:10:00
Welfare and immigration policies are contributing to sharply unequal access to affordable housing among BAME communities. A new report from the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) analyses the impact of these policies.
IEA - UK ranks 12th amongst 165 jurisdictions in economic freedom14/09/2021 15:20:00
The UK ranks 12th out of 165 countries and territories included in the Economic Freedom of the World: 2021 Annual Report, released today by the Institute of Economic Affairs in conjunction with Canada’s Fraser Institute. Last year, the UK ranked 13th.
Adam Smith Inst - 2.1 Million Vulnerable Unvaccinated14/09/2021 10:05:00
Raft of measures proposed to protect human life and liberty as Covid-19 becomes endemic
Adam Smith Inst - NEW POLL: Brits back freer movement with New Zealand14/09/2021 09:05:00
A new poll from the Adam Smith Institute and C|T Group RSR confirms that Brits are eager to strike a trade deal with New Zealand which includes freer movement and mutual recognition of qualifications.
IFS - NHS funding boost should be enough to meet pressures over the next two years, but not in the medium term13/09/2021 14:20:00
Last Tuesday the Prime Minister announced a new funding settlement for health and social care in England. This included an additional £6.6 billion for NHS England in 2022−23 and £3.6 billion in 2023−24, on top of pre-pandemic plans, in the face of ongoing pressures from the COVID-19 pandemic.