Civitas - Warnings on early reinforcement of transgender feelings among young children
A new essay published by Civitas warns of the dangers of reinforcing childhood feelings of ‘gender dysphoria’ at too young an age.
Parent coach and teacher trainer Stephanie Davies-Arai cautions that encouraging pre-pubescents identifying as transgender to believe that they really are will often not be in the child’s best interests.
This ‘gender affirmative’ approach is increasingly adopted by organisations that come into contact with young gender dysphoric children and yet it is not an approach based on clinical research. It may also set children on a path towards medical interventions such as puberty blockers, the long-term effects of which are also poorly understood.
‘“Affirmation” is the political treatment of a clinical condition – its very aim is to facilitate persistence,’ she writes.
‘Until we are honest about that, the most vulnerable children and young people will continue to be subject to experimental and unnecessary medical interventions with lifetime consequences which can never achieve the goal of changing a child’s sex.’
‘Gender affirmation’ is often regarded as the only compassionate response. But about 80 per cent of children outgrow their gender dysphoria during adolescence and, before puberty, children are still learning to distinguish between fact and fantasy. Often children may not even be aware of their natal sex.
‘A child cannot distinguish between personally-held beliefs and facts, nor does the child know that this is a minority belief which involves the denial of biological reality. To the child, the adult knows everything; the child’s developing understanding of reality and interpretation of the world depends on the information imparted to them by adults,’ Davies-Arai writes.
‘Unquestioning affirmation of a child’s belief is not a neutral act of kindness, but an active intervention that shapes and changes a child’s understanding and development. Affirmation by trusted adults forms or reinforces a child’s perception of reality. Living, and being affirmed daily as the opposite sex will affect and change the child’s developing sense of self, which risks creating a self-fulfilled prophesy of outcome.’
The essay is published in Transgender Children: A discussion alongside a further piece by the educationalist and writer Toby Young, who asks whether the growing phenomenon of children registering as transgender should be a cause for alarm.
Many activists argue that the rise in young people identifying as transgender or ‘gender non-conforming’ is due to the decline of the stigma attached to doing so and, as such, it should be celebrated. Others are concerned that it has become fashionable to identify as transgender and that it is unlikely that the true underlying rate of gender dysphoria is as high as it has recently seemed to be, especially in certain geographical areas.
Young cautions schools against ‘parroting every word of the pro-trans lobby’ and encouraging children to take feelings of gender dysphoria more seriously than they need to.
‘Schools probably shouldn’t fret about the growing number of children who want to experiment with different gender labels,’ he writes.
‘The risk of treating them all with the same furrowed-browed intensity, nodding along gravely when they say they’re “non-binary” or “tri-gender” and handing them leaflets about transitioning, is that they’ll take what may be a temporary phase more seriously than they should.
‘We owe it to adolescents at risk of making medical mistakes to urge caution and not just unthinkingly applaud their “honesty” and pack them off to private clinics. Schools need to find the courage to stand up to the trans activists and not let them dictate best practice in this area.’
Latest News from
NIESR: Boosting digital infrastructure will help close regional gaps05/12/2019 14:20:00
Significant investment in digital infrastructure to increase the coverage of ultrafast and full fibre internet for everyone in the UK may help to reduce regional disparities as the access is unevenly distributed across the country, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
NIESR: Productivity improvement needed to raise living standards05/12/2019 10:20:00
The next government must follow a robust, methodical and wide-ranging approach to kickstart a recovery in productivity growth in order to mend the “slow puncture” in UK economic growth, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
Researchers need to work harder to combat misinformation online, says Demos04/12/2019 14:20:00
A new report from Demos looking into how research and development is discussed and communicated about online shows the need for researchers to work harder to be a bigger part of the online conversation, in order to combat the rise of misinformation.
IEA: Evidence so far suggests minimum pricing in Scotland has been “an expensive flop”04/12/2019 13:15:00
Head of Lifestyle Economics at the Institute of Economic Affairs Christopher Snowdon commented on new evidence from the Office for National Statistics showing that the number of alcohol-related deaths fell in England by 145, fell in Wales by 13 and rose in Scotland by 16
Manifesto Promises: CSJ reports03/12/2019 11:35:00
Election manifestos provide an important reality check for organisations like the Centre for Social Justice. It is a clear indication, in black and white, as to whether government is listening to us and whether we are having an impact.
The King's Fund comments on new GP workforce figures and NHS vacancy data03/12/2019 10:35:00
Sally Warren, Director of Policy at The King’s Fund commented on new GP workforce figures and NHS vacancy data from NHS Digital
Policy Exchange - Time to plant – and harvest – more trees03/12/2019 09:35:00
All political parties agree that the UK needs more trees, but stimulating markets to support forestry and supporting sustainable wood use also needs to be part of land policy after Brexit, argues a new paper from Policy Exchange’s award-winning Energy and Environment unit.
NIESR: Tough lessons for new government on raising education standards28/11/2019 11:25:00
The incoming government must embark on a wholesale reform of the education from nursery schools through to adult education to help close gaps between the UK and other comparable economies, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Social and Economic Research.
NIESR: Hiking minimum wage too fast may undermine policy’s success27/11/2019 11:20:00
Raising minimum wage levels too quickly risks undermining the strong consensus between employers, workers and political parties that has been built up during the past two decades, especially if the increases lead to falls in employment that are difficult to reverse, according to an election briefing by the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR).