Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Claims on EU opt-outs and special deals not credible
The Scottish Affairs Committee publishes its report into the Referendum on Separation for Scotland: Scotland's Membership of the European Union (EU).
- Report: The Referendum on Separation for Scotland: Scotland's Membership of the EU
- Report: The Referendum on Separation for Scotland: Scotland's Membership of the EU (PDF)
- Inquiry: Referendum on Separation for Scotland
- Scottish Affairs Committee
Parliament’s Scottish Affairs Committee warns that a separate Scotland would face protracted and uncertain negotiations when attempting to secure its position in the European Union, and that while it is likely that it would eventually be accepted as a Member state, it is not credible that it would emerge with the benefits it now enjoys as part of the UK in the EU.
Complex negotiations would be required, with both the UK and the EU, and any agreement would have to be ratified by 28 Member States. There is no evidence or precedent to support the notion that Scotland would get better terms than any of the other recent applicant countries.
Interim period outside EU
The Committee believes that a separate Scotland is more likely to have interim period outside EU than to complete UK/EU negotiations and processes of joining within its self-imposed timeline of 18 months. It is likely Scotland will lose all or most of the special arrangements presently enjoyed as part of the UK:
- Budget rebate, the loss of which will cost each Scottish household around £900 over the Budget period. Scotland will have to pay part of the UK rebate
- Opt out from promise to join the Euro
- VAT charges for which the UK has negotiated opt outs - on food, children’s clothes, books and newspapers –at a standard rate of 15% or a minimum rate of 5%
- CAP farm payments at a higher rate than given to accession states
- Loss of valuable EU structural funds currently redirected to Scotland through the UK
- Opt outs from Justice and Home Affairs
Discriminate against students
In addition, it is inconceivable that the UK and other EU member states will allow Scotland to discriminate against UK students on tuition fees.
Some negotiations with the EU,
eg on Schengen, will be dependent on an agreement with the UK on mutually
acceptable immigration policies, thus affecting the timetable.
Today Scotland’s interests in the European Union are represented by the UK which, as one of the largest Member States, has the voting power and leverage to influence decisions to the benefit of Scotland. A separate Scotland would lose this advantage.
The UK government and EU authorities have ruled out allowing Scotland to use the legal mechanism it proposes for joining the EU (Article 48), which makes it almost impossible that the Scottish Government’s self-imposed accession timetable could be met.
Ian Davidson MP, Chair of the Committee, said:
"It seems the Scottish Government has drastically under-estimated the time, complexity and cost of negotiating a new position in the EU, as well as the factors weighted against Scotland in any such negotiations.
It is likely that a separate Scotland would have its application to join the EU accepted – but not on the timetable or terms that the Scottish Government wants. It is simply not credible that the Scottish Government would achieve the terms of entry that it seeks and especially not from the weakened position of its self-imposed deadline. The Scottish Government has not acknowledged the true scale of the difficulty it will encounter in seeking better terms than have been achieved by other recent applicants.
The people of Scotland deserve to be told the truth about the costs and difficulties or re-joining the EU if Scotland votes to leave the UK – and thus the EU.
We believe that the Scottish Government cannot meet its negotiating objectives within the timetable it has promised.
The people should be told by the Scottish Government which concessions will be made and what the costs will be. Will the timetable for Independence slip or will there be a period outside the EU? What is their Plan B?"
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Government must learn lessons from the use of criminal law in the covid-19 pandemic24/09/2021 15:33:00
The Justice Committee has called on the Government to learn lessons from its use of the criminal law in the covid-19 pandemic.
Treasury Committee publishes responses to Greensill report24/09/2021 13:33:00
The Treasury Committee today publishes the responses from the Government, FCA and Bank of England to its report on Lessons from Greensill Capital.
Government’s focus on Levelling Up must not turn back the clock on hard-won equal rights24/09/2021 11:38:00
In its new Report, Levelling Up and equality: a new framework for change, the House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee continues to argue that the Government must create a new Cabinet level Secretary of State for Equalities and Levelling Up.
Senior parliamentarians criticise failures in government security planning20/09/2021 09:20:00
A Parliamentary committee concerned with national security strategy says there are serious weaknesses in the workings of UK Government structures that deal with national security, as exemplified by both the covid-19 pandemic and recent events in Afghanistan.
Reforms required if Parliamentary scrutiny of treaties is to be effective, report finds17/09/2021 13:15:00
The International Agreements Committee has today published a new report on Working Practices. It reflects on our experience of parliamentary treaty scrutiny and proposes further reforms to make scrutiny more effective.
Scottish renewables progress hampered by grid connection charges17/09/2021 11:05:00
The Scottish Affairs Committee calls for transmission charges and grid investment to be equally shared across the UK to help strengthen the Scottish renewables sector.
European Statutory Instruments Committee publishes fourth report16/09/2021 15:05:00
Following the Committee's meeting on Tuesday 14 September, its fourth report of Session 2021-22 has been published.
Treasury Committee publishes additional Government response to Tax after Coronavirus Report14/09/2021 11:20:00
The Treasury Committee today publishes a further Government response to its report on Tax after Coronavirus.