Consider the financially vulnerable, CCW urges the CMA
Careful consideration should be given to the future affordability of water bills, the Consumer Council for Water (CCW) has told the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA). Steve Hobbs, Senior Policy Manager, reflects on the latest hearing.
In a late-scheduled second hearing on 17 November, CCW was invited to provide additional evidence to the CMA, giving us a final opportunity to speak up for consumers ahead of final decisions being made. At this hearing, we called for the CMA to carefully consider the implications of its proposed price changes on the affordability of bills, particularly given the ongoing backdrop of the financial uncertainty caused by Covid-19.
While the average bill increases proposed in the CMA’s Provisional Findings were relatively modest in relation to Ofwat’s Final Determination, any year-on-year increases can cause problems for households who are already struggling to afford their water bill, and could be the final straw pushing those who are ‘just about managing’ into debt.
We are already seeing that the Covid-19 pandemic is affecting household finances, and is impacting the ability of customers to pay their water bills. Given the wider economic situation and the extension of the furlough scheme, we do not yet know the full implications of Covid on affordability. However, we do know that it is highly likely that we will see a surge in customers struggling with their water bills and seeking support. If this coincides with a bill increase, the consequences for consumers’ finances could be devastating.
At times like these, providing clear and tangible value for money is more important than ever. As such, it’s difficult to see how consumer views were taken into account by the CMA in its decision to allow greater returns to water company shareholders by increasing the cost of capital (WACC) to a level higher than seen recently in other regulated sectors. In the past, the over-generosity of Ofwat on the WACC has led to significant windfalls for companies, which we know has had a negative impact on consumers’ perceptions of value for money and the fairness of bills. In this price review, Ofwat has been far less generous, and the CMA’s decision to reverse this for the four appellant companies appears to come at the expense of customers, while delivering no material benefit to consumers.
Our most important message for the CMA is that there is still time to improve on its Provisional Findings by reconsidering the potential impact of its proposed bill increases. There are many aspects where we support the CMA, but if we were to change one thing, it would be the WACC. Reconsidering this would make the biggest positive difference to water consumers and reduce the potential for long-term financial implications.
Latest News from
Faster complaint response times in the pipeline for most water customers14/01/2021 09:20:00
Water customers can expect a faster response to their complaints in the future after ten water companies answered the consumer watchdog’s call to show more ambition.
CCW seeks views on ambitious three-year strategy08/01/2021 15:05:00
Making sure water is affordable for every household and safeguarding services in the face of our rapidly changing climate are among the leading priorities in the Consumer Council for Water’s (CCW) most ambitious ever strategy.
A simple recipe to avoid a dinnertime disaster23/12/2020 12:20:00
With Christmas just around the corner, you may have already started to plan your festive feast.
Water retailers urged to keep helping businesses on the road to recovery17/12/2020 13:38:00
Retailers must keep doing everything in their power to help struggling businesses impacted by Covid-19 get back on their feet without the threat of debt recovery action.
As easy as A, B, C? Survival tips for a peaceful winter10/12/2020 12:20:00
This year in particular has probably been a more challenging year than usual for most of us. Having to adapt quickly to find ways to deal with the ‘new normal’.
Learn more from complaints to improve services for customers, water companies are urged30/11/2020 13:27:00
Green investment plans must have customer backing27/11/2020 09:20:00
The road to recovery from Covid-19 is going to be a long and hard one but we believe water companies can play a vital role in helping us to overcome the economic and social challenges we now face.
Lifting the lid on leaky loos20/11/2020 09:20:00
Our recent Water Makes It Possible campaign gave us the opportunity to appreciate just how amazing water is, and sadly how much we can all be guilty of taking it for granted.