Ministry of Justice
Controlling the costs of defamation cases
The Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice, David Gauke, yesterday made the following written ministerial statement.
The Government is committed to controlling the costs of civil litigation while allowing appropriate cases to proceed. Part 2 of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders (LASPO) Act 2012 reformed the operation of no win no fee conditional fee agreements in order to address the high costs of civil litigation. In particular, section 44 of the LASPO Act provided that the lawyer’s success fee would no longer be recoverable from the losing party. This provision came into effect for the majority of cases in April 2013 but was delayed in respect of defamation and privacy claims pending the outcome of the Leveson Inquiry. The then Coalition Government accepted the Leveson recommendation that there should be a costs protection regime in place for defamation and privacy claims, before commencing the LASPO Act conditional fee agreement reforms. It consulted on a draft bespoke costs protection regime in 2013. In the event, there was opposition to the detail of that regime, and the then Coalition Government did not implement the proposal.
Having considered the responses to the consultation, the Government has now decided on a different approach that will further control the costs of these cases and will also give effect to our legal obligations under the MGN v UK judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in 2011. In the MGN case, the court concluded that the obligation for the defendant to pay a 100% ‘success fee’ to the claimant was disproportionate, and that the conditional fee agreements regime was therefore in breach of the defendant’s rights under Article 10 (freedom of expression) of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The Government will therefore now commence section 44 of the LASPO Act in relation to defamation and privacy cases. However, the Government will keep in place, at least for the time being, the existing costs protection regime. This means that after the event insurance premiums will remain recoverable for these cases. After the event insurance covers the risks of having to pay the other side’s costs in unsuccessful cases.
This approach - of abolishing recoverability of the conditional fee agreement success fee, but retaining it for the after the event insurance premium - will protect access to justice, since parties with good cases can still benefit from recoverable after the event insurance in respect of adverse costs; after the event insurance discourages weaker cases as these are unlikely to be insured. This provision will come into force for new cases on 6 April 2019.
The Government has also published today its response to the 2013 consultation, ‘Costs protection in defamation and privacy claims: the Government’s proposals’.
Latest News from
Ministry of Justice
Government publishes landmark domestic abuse bill21/01/2019 13:22:00
The government has unveiled the most comprehensive package ever to tackle domestic abuse.
10 prisons project gathers pace04/01/2019 13:15:00
Prisons Minister announces arrival of x-ray scanner at HMP Leeds.
In-cell phones for more prisons in drive to cut crime28/12/2018 10:15:00
Justice Secretary announces more prisoners will get in-cell phones to help maintain the family ties which can cut reoffending by 40%.
Trio of justice bills become law20/12/2018 13:15:00
Justice Secretary David Gauke today spoke of his pride in a department ‘delivering real change’, after 3 important justice bills all became law on the same day (20 December 2018).
£15m government funding to fix court buildings18/12/2018 16:15:00
Work to improve the condition of court buildings is underway thanks to an additional £15 million set aside for much needed security and maintenance work.
The Product Management Handbook for Government10/12/2018 15:15:15
Blog posted by: Scott Colfer, 7 December 2018 – Categories: Agile, Our services, Product management.
Swindon court users to benefit from £2.6m government investment10/12/2018 13:15:00
People in Swindon will benefit from improved facilities at two of the town’s courts following £2.6m of government funding.
Drive to employ ex-offenders attracts over 120 businesses07/12/2018 12:15:00
More than 120 further businesses have registered to work with prisons and set offenders on a path to employment, Justice Secretary David Gauke yesterday revealed.