Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill fails to protect constitutional principles, warns Committee
The House of Lords Constitutional Committee criticises the Government for failing to protect fundamental constitutional principles in the Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill. It follows two critical reports on the Bill by the Joint Committee on Human Rights.
- Report: Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill (HTML)
- Report: Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill (PDF)
- Select Committee on the Constitution
The Committee raises concerns about the limits placed on access to confidential legal advice, noting detainees under the Bill are not afforded this fundamental constitutional protection and recommends the Bill requires detainees to be informed of their right to consult a solicitor. The Committee highlights that the justifications for these limits rely excessively on government assurances that these powers will be executed more benevolently than the text of the Bill requires.
The Committee also warns that individuals are not given a fair opportunity to know about the law that applies to them, as individuals could be prosecuted in the UK for criminal offences that do not exist in another country.
The Committee echoes the recommendation of the Joint Committee on Human Rights by calling for a clearer definition of broadly defined offences, and observes that the Government’s failure to publish the draft code of practice setting out the planned use of the powers for the entirety of the Bill's passage through the Commons has hindered parliamentary scrutiny.
Chairman of the House of Lords Constitution Committee, Baroness Taylor of Bolton said:
"The Bill fails to respect important constitutional principles. Broad definitions for offences, excessive reliance on Government assurances, and barriers to proper parliamentary scrutiny are all deeply problematic. We urge the Government to think again, considering both the recommendations from this Committee and those of the Joint Committee on Human Rights."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Online abuse law not fit for purpose, says Petitions Committee23/01/2019 09:05:00
The Petitions Committee yesterday published its report "Online abuse and the experience of disabled people", revealing the extreme level of abuse that disabled people receive online.
Retail Price Index must be fixed, says Lords Committee18/01/2019 09:15:00
The Economic Affairs Committee publishes its report on 'Measuring Inflation'. The report considers the future of the retail price index (RPI) and its use by the Government.
Government rebuked for lack of preparation on Brexit and chemicals17/01/2019 13:25:00
The House of Lords EU Energy and Environment Committee has written to Defra Minister Thérèse Coffey MP highlighting renewed concerns about the Government's ill-preparedness to take on the regulation of chemicals and maintain chemical trade after Brexit.
Lords debate report on possibility of post-Brexit UK-EU security treaty15/01/2019 13:05:00
On Wednesday 16 January 2019, the House of Lords will debate the EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee's report on Brexit: the proposed UK-EU security treaty.
Lords debate Committee's report on consumer protection after Brexit11/01/2019 14:20:00
On Wednesday 16 January the House of Lords debates the European Union Committee's report, Brexit: will consumers be protected? which was published on 19 December 2017.
A shifting world order necessitates change in UK foreign policy18/12/2018 15:20:00
Major shifts in the world order have widespread implications for the UK's security, prosperity and global influence, says Lords report published today.
Committee demands action on Government’s strategy for NI's fisheries post-Brexit14/12/2018 09:05:00
The Northern Ireland Affairs Committee has written to Michael Gove, Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs seeking more detail on crucial elements of strategy, after Government response to Committee's report fails to match urgency of crisis facing NI’s fisheries.
Any clear expression of ‘no confidence’ could topple Government, warns Committee12/12/2018 11:25:00
A report published yesterday by the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee advises that Parliament’s power to remove the authority to govern through a no confidence motion has been unaffected by the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011.
Brexit Committee’s united verdict on the Prime Minister's deal: Uncertainty, not clarity11/12/2018 14:25:00
The Committee on Exiting the European Union publishes its report on the Government’s EU Withdrawal Agreement and Political Declaration. The Report – agreed unanimously – says that the Prime Minister’s deal fails to offer sufficient clarity or certainty for the future of the UK.