Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Covid-19 and the Probation Service - “an incredibly different situation out there”
The Justice Select Committee yesterday released a report on the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on Her Majesty’s Probation Service and at the same time launch an inquiry into ongoing reforms in the service.
The report, ‘Coronavirus (Covid-19): The impact on the probation system in England and Wales’ sets out how the pandemic has profoundly affected the way probation services are delivered.
Many former prisoners and those serving community sentences are now supervised remotely by Probation Officers – through phone calls or Skype. Released prisoners who would often need help finding accommodation or accessing Universal Credit benefits may well find physical offices dealing with these matters closed, with staff working from home.
Helen Berresford's comments
An official from the prisoner and ex-prisoner charity Nacro, Helen Berresford, painted a picture of the situation for the Committee:
“It’s an incredibly different situation out there. Almost all support is being provided remotely at the minute, so we need to make sure everybody leaving prison has access to a mobile phone. They will also need to have enough money to get them started. To be honest, they will need some of the essentials like soap, a toothbrush and some basic food and drink to get them through the first few days. They may be released to somewhere they do not know. They may be released having to take public transport – which may or may not be running.”
Minister of State's comments
The Minister of State at the Justice Ministry, Lucy Frazer, told the Committee that the Ministry was working very closely with the charitable sector:
“We are working very closely with them to see how we can feed in offers of support outside the core services we have to set up. We have had a number of very interesting offers.”
The Committee report welcomed the Ministry’s commitment to work with the charitable sector but said it was unclear what specific additional support had been put in place for those released from custody during this time.
The Committee recommended that the Ministry of Justice and Her Majesty’ Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) set out what additional measures they have put in place to support prison leavers.
'Exceptional model of delivery'
The delivery of probation supervisory services in the wake of Covid-19 is officially known as an ‘exceptional model of delivery’. High risk offenders are supervised by the National Probation Service (NPS) through a combination of remote methods and doorstep visits. Medium and low-risk offenders are currently supervised by private sector organisations called Community Rehabilitation Companies (CRCs).
The National Association of Probation Officers told the Committee that there was some inconsistency in the way the model was delivered across the NPS and CRC systems. This led, the Association said, to anxiety among staff about their own safety. Another witness said the inconsistency led to concerns among individuals trying to adhere to their licence conditions to avoid potential recall to prison.
The Justice Committee report said it was concerned about these inconsistencies and recommended that the Ministry of Justice and HMPPS set out what guidance had been issued to CRCs and how they are monitoring the models being delivered by different CRCs.
Backlogs and staffing issues
The Committee’s report also said it was concerned about the backlog which the lockdown measures have necessitated – for example the unpaid work which some people have been sentenced to has stopped. The Committee said it recognised why this had happened but recommended that the Ministry and HMPPS set out how the probation service intends to address the backlogs.
Finally, the report also looked at staffing issues in the NPS. It found that even before the pandemic, there were over 600 vacancies across the service in England and Wales and that workloads were heavy. Since Covid-19 hit, around 20% of the NPS staff of 11,000 have been off work each day, putting considerably more stress on remaining employees. The Committee recommended that government and HMPPS set out what existing and additional measures are in place during this time to support staff well-being.
The coronavirus pandemic has severely affected the probation service at a time when it was already in the throes of its second major restructuring programme in the past five years. In addition to its report on the effect of the pandemic, the Committee yesterday launched an inquiry into the latest proposed reforms, which are due to be in place by 2021.
A new model
In 2014-15 the Ministry of Justice implemented a programme of privatising parts of the Probation Service. This led to the CRCs contracting to deliver some strands of work, including supervisory services for medium and low-risk offenders. HM Inspector of Probation released a series of reports on this new model which variously described it as having ‘deep-rooted problems’ to being ‘irredeemably flawed’. The previous Justice Committee Chair described the system as ‘a mess’.
In June 2020, the Secretary of State for Justice, Robert Buckland, said the disruption caused by Covid-19 meant it was vital that the Ministry obtained the flexibility to deliver a national response to any future challenges. For this reason, he said, he was to streamline the reforms by unifying the management of offenders under a single operation.
This new model means the effective renationalisation of the Probation Service by 2021. It would mean all key elements of offender case management and supervision of unpaid work would return to the overall control of the NPS – although some elements of delivery are still to be outsourced and overseen by the National Probation Service.
New inquiry on proposed reforms
The Justice Committee inquiry being launched today will ask for written submissions and take oral evidence from stakeholders on the new model for the delivery of probation services.
The deadline for written submissions, which should be sent to the Committee website here will be September 7. It is anticipated that a report will be published in February 2021.
The Chair of the Justice Committee, Sir Bob Neill, yesterday said:
“We’ll want to know if this new model will work and whether it will be capable of clearing the backlog of probation work caused by the pandemic. We’ll be asking whether private sector providers were consulted about these proposals, whether there were counter-proposals, and how the new model will supply the necessary services.
But above all we will want to see improvements in the rehabilitation of offenders, improvements in probation service staff morale and robust protections for the public.
In short, we want to make sure these latest reforms do not repeat the errors of the past so that the Justice Committee will, in future years, be scrutinizing a Probation Service fit for the twenty-first century.”
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Chair urges the Prime Minister to engage with the hospitality sector22/01/2021 15:33:00
Chair of the Petitions Committee, Catherine McKinnell MP, has written to the Prime Minister urging him to engage with the hospitality sector after raising the issue at the latest session of the Liaison Committee.
Committee publishes industry-wide evidence in music streaming inquiry22/01/2021 15:33:00
More than 150 pieces of written evidence in the economics of music streaming inquiry were yesterday published, giving an industry-wide perspective on the impact of streaming and business models operated by platforms.
NS&I responds to Treasury Committee22/01/2021 14:38:00
Following various concerns about National Savings and Investments (NS&I), Rt Hon. Mel Stride MP, Chair of the Treasury Committee, wrote to its Chief Executive Ian Ackerley last month.
Greater transparency needed in UK food safety framework22/01/2021 11:38:00
The Common Framework Scrutiny Committee has written to Emily Miles, CEO of the Food Standards Agency (FSA), with its concluding thoughts on the Food and Feed Safety and Hygiene (FFSH) Provisional Framework.
Parliament must continue to scrutinise UK-EU relationship, says final committee report21/01/2021 15:33:00
In its final report, the cross-party Committee on the Future Relationship with the European Union says that with the UK and the European Union having signed the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), Parliament needs to ensure effective future scrutiny of the UK-EU relationship.
Committee to step up review of Commons COVID procedures with new sessions21/01/2021 11:38:00
The Procedure Committee will hear from witnesses including the Clerk of the House of Commons and the Leader of the House, as it continues its detailed review and inquiry into procedure under coronavirus restrictions.
EU Committee seeks evidence for new inquiry on EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement20/01/2021 15:33:00
The House of Lords EU Goods Sub-Committee today invites written contributions to its ongoing inquiry into Future UK–EU relations: trade in goods.
Committee calls for evidence for two inquiries20/01/2021 11:38:00
The Home Affairs Committee calls for evidence for its Home Office preparedness for Covid-19 and post-transition management of the border inquiries.