Customer support must drive CMA decisions
As the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) prepares to make final decisions over four water companies’ future plans, the Consumer Council for Water (CCW) warns that customers must not lose out on the service levels and investment they value most. Steve Hobbs, Senior Policy Manager at CCW, explains.
Four water companies in England – Northumbrian Water, Yorkshire Water, Anglian Water and Bristol Water – appealed to the CMA in April, asking it to re-examine the regulator Ofwat’s decisions on what water companies are allowed to charge customers in the period 2020-25, and what investments and service improvements customers can expect to see in return.
But while companies have the opportunity to appeal to the CMA, customers don’t, and that’s where the role of CCW comes in. As the voice of water consumers, we provided both written and verbal evidence to the CMA earlier this summer, urging it to take customers’ views into account to make sure that customers aren’t disadvantaged by its final decisions.
With the CMA due to make its provisional redeterminations in September and final decisions at the end of the year, what do we expect to see for customers of the four companies that have appealed?
For us, the key factor for the CMA to consider is what customers think of the plans, and our research puts us in a unique position to comment. Throughout the whole price review process, we have advocated for all plans and decisions to be strongly supported by customers, and we carried out our own independent research into customer acceptability of Ofwat’s draft determinations, which were announced last year.
When Ofwat set its targets for companies on issues including leakage, sewer flooding and resilience (known as performance commitments), we were pleased to see that these had been based on evidence of what customers expect their water companies to achieve. Our research showed that a high number of customers found Ofwat’s draft determinations acceptable. As Ofwat’s final determinations offered service improvements that were not significantly different, we would not want the CMA’s decisions later this year to weaken or compromise these commitments in any way.
Similarly, customers told us that they would support water companies making more investments to safeguard the resilience of services in the long term than was allowed in Ofwat’s final determination, but we think this should only be allowed if the costs and business case for extra investment can be fully justified by the company.
In fact, the issue of what costs and expenditure Ofwat has allowed for in its final decisions – and what level of financial efficiency it expects them to achieve – is what sits at the heart of the majority of the four companies’ disputes. From our annual Water Matters tracker research, we know that water companies have far to go to improve customers’ satisfaction with the value for money they feel that they receive. With many companies comparatively inefficient in the past, we feel that it was right for Ofwat to challenge them hard on this point, and we look to the CMA to determine whether Ofwat’s methodology and decisions were correct and do in fact enable companies to deliver these commitments.
Relatedly, the cost of raising finance – known as the cost of capital – has been hotly disputed by the appellant water companies, who claim that the cost of capital has been set too low. An independent report we commissioned from economic consultants, ECA, suggested that companies should be able to finance their plans efficiently without an increase, and that by allowing an increase, the CMA could be driving bills even higher for customers. As such, we have called for the cost of capital to remain the same or lower.
As we look ahead to the next phase of this process, our work behind the scenes continues, and we look forward to the opportunity to speak up for water consumers in our response to the CMA when its redeterminations are announced in September.
To find out more about the role of CCW in representing water consumers throughout the price review process, visit www.ccwater.org.uk
Latest News from
CMA plans could tip the balance for struggling households28/10/2020 09:20:00
The Consumer Council for Water (CCW) yesterday called on the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) to “think again” after voicing concerns over its provisional plans for four water companies’ future bills and service commitments.
Review targets stronger support for customers struggling to afford water bills22/10/2020 11:20:00
Stronger support for household customers who are struggling to afford their water bills has moved closer with the launch of a major review into existing assistance schemes.
CMA: is the customer voice being heard?20/10/2020 13:38:00
More customer engagement was carried out at PR19 than in any previous price review. But how has this translated into tangible outcomes for consumers, and is the CMA listening? CCW’s Mike Keil explores whether the customer voice is being heard as the appeal process continues.
CCW shares lessons learned from 2019 Price Review12/10/2020 09:20:00
Future price reviews must strengthen customers’ influence over every stage of the price setting process and beef up the incentives to improve customer service and reduce complaints.
Stark warning to several water companies as environmental performance fails to improve05/10/2020 11:22:00
Environmental performance report shows more action and investment is needed by several water companies that are failing to protect the environment.
CMA publishes its Provisional Findings in review of water price controls30/09/2020 15:38:00
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) yesterday published its Provisional Findings following four water companies’ appeals against Ofwat’s final determinations on price controls for 2020-25.
Watchdog targets poor performers as majority of water companies reduce complaints25/09/2020 09:20:00
Two-thirds of water companies reported a fall in written complaints from their customers last year – but a rapid improvement is needed from two of England’s suppliers.
Annual Review shines light on CCW’s achievements07/09/2020 09:20:00
It’s hard to recall a year in our short history that has involved more changes or challenges than 2019-20 and those are reflected in the publication of the recent (04 September 2020) Annual Review.