Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
DEFRA’s plan for post-EU land and farming subsidies based on “blind optimism”
Plans for the scheme to replace the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy depend on changes in land use that bring both increased farm productivity and environmental benefits, but in a report published yesterday the Public Accounts Committee says Defra itself concedes “its confidence in the scheme looks like blind optimism”.
- Read the full report (HTML)
- Read the full report (PDF 355KB)
- Read the report summary
- Find all publications related to this inquiry, including oral and written evidence
Defra has given no detail about how either the necessary productivity increases or environmental benefits will be brought about, nor how these will offset the new Environmental Land Management Scheme’s dramatic effect on English farmers, who will see their income from direct payments reduce by more than half by 2024-25.
Replacing the CAP which provided financial support to farmers and rural development funding for more than 40 years before Brexit - in 2019-20 farmers in England received over £1.8 billion in direct payment subsidies - is “an opportunity to reset the approach to land management in England and deliver benefits for the environment whilst also promoting a sustainable and productive farming sector”.
But the Committee says the Scheme appears “beset with many of the same issues that have undermined ambitious Government programmes in recent years” and the lack of information from Defra early enough to allow farmers to plan their businesses and take advantage of the new opportunities “is causing anxiety in the sector, exacerbated by a historic lack of trust caused by the Department’s past failures in managing farm payments”.
Defra has also “not explained how the Scheme’s changes in land use will not simply result in more food being imported, with the environmental impacts of food production being ‘exported’ to countries with lower environmental standards.”
The Committee says Defra has not established the metrics or objectives to enable it to demonstrate that the £2.4 billion a year it plans to spend on agricultural schemes is providing value for money, or contributing to government’s wider environmental goals including the statutory commitment to reach net-zero carbon economy by 2050.
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, Deputy Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, yesterday said
“We have known we were replacing the CAP since 2016 and still we see no clear plans, objectives or communications with those at the sharp end - farmers - in this multi-billion pound, radical overhaul of the way land is used and, more crucially, food is produced in this country.
“Farmers, especially the next generation of farmers who we will depend on to achieve our combined food production and environmental goals, have been left in the dark and it is simply wrong that Defra’s own failures of business planning should knock on to undermine the certainty crucial to a critical national sector.
“As the report makes clear, without subsidies the average farm in England makes a net profit of just £22,800 a year including all labour and investment in businesses. The fear therefore for small and tenant farms who are operating on wafer-thin margins is that many will go out of business and the average size of farms will increase and some of the environmental benefits of ELMs will be lost.
“The UK is also already a large net importer of food and we heard in evidence that the ELMS’ vague ambition to ‘maximise the value to society of the landscape’ may in reality mean that increases further. The recent energy price crisis should be a salutary warning of the potential risks to the availability and affordability of food if the UK becomes even more reliant on food imports.”
- Inquiry: Environmental Land Management Scheme
- Public Accounts Committee
- About Parliament: Select committees
- Visiting Parliament: Watch committees
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Culture change needed at the Ministry of Defence to ensure SMEs in Scotland receive a fair share of defence contracts24/06/2022 15:33:00
The Scottish Affairs Committee today, on the eve of Armed Forces Day, argues that small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Scotland are being overlooked by the Ministry of Defence (MOD) and its prime contractors when they select companies to fulfil defence contracts.
UK-Australia free trade agreement welcomed, but a published trade policy is needed23/06/2022 12:10:00
As the first trade deal negotiated from scratch following the UK’s departure from the EU, the UK-Australia free trade agreement (FTA) provides an insight into the UK Government’s vision for trade after Brexit. It is regrettable that it cannot be placed in the context of a published trade policy and understood in relation to other policy priorities, for example on climate, according to the House of Lords International Agreements Committee.
Government reluctant to engage with the EU on financial services says Lords Committee23/06/2022 11:10:00
The European Affairs Committee has today published a report on the UK-EU relationship in financial services.
Committee welcomes ‘positive’ government tree planting plans20/06/2022 14:25:00
The Environment Food and Rural Affairs Committee has welcomed the government’s response to its report, Tree planting, which was published in March.
All migrant victims of domestic abuse and violence must be protected, says Lords committee17/06/2022 16:15:00
The International Agreements Committee has today called on the Government to review and lift, as soon as possible, a reservation it is proposing to enter to an important protection for migrant victims of domestic abuse in an international Convention.
Procedure and Privileges Committee publishes Second Report16/06/2022 15:33:00
The Committee has updated the text of the Companion to reflect changes agreed by the House since the last edition was published in 2017. It has also adopted changes to clarify drafting and added explanations of well-established and important concepts hitherto missing from the Companion.
Procedure and Privileges Committee publishes First Report16/06/2022 11:38:00
The report summarises the views expressed by Members in response to the consultation launched by the Senior Deputy Speaker on the sitting times of the House.
Negotiations with EU over Gibraltar border ‘no small issue’: MPs launch inquiry10/06/2022 11:38:00
The European Scrutiny Committee has launched an inquiry into the progress of the negotiations with the European Union over border and trade arrangements between Spain and Gibraltar.