DEMOS - Enlist Social Media Users to Tackle Online Extremism
A new report by the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media (CASM) at Demos, supported by Facebook, examines the activity of counter speech and populist right-wing groups on Facebook and makes recommendations for counter-speech groups to diffuse their messages from within.
The interim report is the first in a series of break-through pilot studies, exploring the potential of counter-speech to mobilise social media users to play an active role in defending and moderating their communities. It is hoped that successful counter-speech could offer an effective response to extremism, whilst maintaining the principle of free and open public spaces for debate.
While Facebook’s standards prohibit and remove hate speech, there are often instances of what the authors describe as “disagreeable” content, which do not violate these policies.
The study explores whether counter-speech, which is faster, more flexible and responsive than platform-led interventions, could prove a useful tactic to address these types of posts.
The researchers collected almost 30,000 public posts and interaction data from 150 right-wing populist Facebook pages from the UK, France, Italy and Hungary over two months between October and December 2014. These were then compared and contrasted with the content (2,364 posts) on the 26 identified counter-speech pages.
- In the UK, counter-speech pages are smaller in number and more limited in their activity, but achieve a greater amount of sharing and interactions than populist right-wing pages
- Counter-speech pages tend to focus on parodying or satirising extremist language
- UK-based right-wing populist pages tend to have more concentrated networks than counter-speech pages, with few, more active users
- The most popular content type on right-wing populist pages is commentary, and the most popular tone is ‘celebratory’ (ie. commemorating war dead or patriotic pride), followed by ‘angry’
- Populist right-wing pages are far more effective at posting content which goes beyond their network of page fans. Counter hate pages can be more effective at producing content which appeals to a wide audience
The report concludes that counter-speech pages not as active as right-wing populist pages – and particularly so in France and Italy. The authors recommend that efforts are made to increase the level and quality of content on counter-speech pages, and to ensure it can be shared more widely.
Further reports in the series will examine speech and content that challenges extreme Islamist ideology, in the UK and beyond.
For further information regarding this series, please contact: Jamie Bartlett.
Sophie Gaston – Press and Communications Manager, Demos
0207 367 6325 | (Out of Hours) 07472745678
Latest News from
Work Foundation - Outdated attitudes risk widening inequalities in hybrid workplace, think-tank warns15/10/2021 15:10:00
Employers could undo the progress made over the last 18 months and deepen workplace inequalities if organisations fail to override the deep-rooted perceptions of ‘office culture’, a leading think tank has warned.
The King's Fund responds to the Department of Health and Social Care announcement to improve access to general practice14/10/2021 13:15:00
Beccy Baird, Senior Fellow at The King’s Fund, commented on the announcement from NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care of a blueprint to improve access to general practice
JRF - Invest in social housing to fix 'policy black hole' for almost 1m families paying private rents they can't afford13/10/2021 15:10:00
New analysis from JRF highlights that almost one million families on low incomes in England (956,000) are paying rents they cannot afford in the private rented sector.
No need for further tax rises after promising GDP figures, says IEA expert13/10/2021 13:20:00
Julian Jessop, Economics Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the latest GDP figures, published by the ONS today
IEA - Bad policy is to blame for heavy industry’s woes12/10/2021 10:35:00
Andy Mayer, Chief Operating Officer at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on calls to bail out energy-intensive industries
IFS - Despite planning biggest tax rises in more than 25 years, and an historic increase in size of the state, the Chancellor is still likely to have little money for hard-pressed public12/10/2021 09:35:00
This year’s historic, and manifesto-breaking, announcements of tax rises will increase the UK’s tax take to its highest sustained level in peacetime. Spending will settle at 42% of national income, more than 2% above its pre-pandemic level and its highest level in ‘normal times’ since 1985.
IEA economist comments on ending of furlough scheme30/09/2021 12:35:00
Professor Len Shackleton, Editorial and Research Fellow at free market think tank the Institute of Economic Affairs, commented on the ending of furlough scheme
IPPR - Revealed: NHS and care integration postcode lottery leading to unequal access to treatment and support30/09/2021 11:35:00
Following the new funding announced for the NHS and social care system, the IPPR think tank warns that improved outcomes will only be delivered if combined with changes to the way healthcare is organised and how services work together.
IFS - Londoners face quadruple whammy of labour market challenges as furlough scheme ends30/09/2021 10:35:00
Workers in London look in the most precarious position as the furlough scheme comes to an end today. During the pandemic, Londoners have suffered from higher rates of redundancy, lower rates of re-employment after redundancy and lower growth in vacancies. In addition, the latest data show they were still more likely to be furloughed this summer than other parts of the country. These challenges compound to heighten the risk of longer-term unemployment in the capital.