National Audit Office Press Releases
Devolving responsibilities to cities in England: Wave 1 City Deals
Wave 1 City Deals encouraged cities to develop capacity to manage devolved funding and increased responsibility. It is too early to tell what impact they will have on growth.
“Wave 1 City Deals were an important part of a longer-term discussion between local leaders and central government about devolution and growth. There were lessons for both sides; for example, some programmes in the Deals have had an early impact, but there have been delays to some more ambitious and innovative programmes. It is in the interests of both cities and the government to know which programmes have the biggest impact for the money invested. However, their understanding of this will remain limited without a shared approach to evaluating the impacts of the programmes”
Amyas Morse, head of the National Audit Office, 9 July 2015
The government’s Wave 1 City Deals were an important catalyst for cities to develop their capacity to manage devolved funding and increased responsibility for economic growth, according to the National Audit Office. However, it is too early to tell whether the deals will have any overall impact on growth.
Measuring the deals’ impact on economic growth will require long-term commitment from government and cities to monitoring and evaluating projects and the deals as a whole. According to the NAO, the government and the cities could have worked together in a more structured way to agree a consistent approach to evaluating the deals’ impact.
City Deals are designed to empower local leaders and businesses to create local growth, and enabled cities to present their local economic priorities directly to government decision-makers. The first City Deals – known as Wave 1 – were signed with the 8 largest cities outside London in 2012, with government departments committing up to £2.3 billion to the deals, spread over 30 years.
The government has set out its ambition to continue devolving responsibility for local growth to cities and other local places. Yesterday’s review highlights that both the government and local places can learn from the experience of Wave 1 City Deals to manage devolution to local places effectively.
There have been early impacts from some of the individual programmes agreed in the deals. It has, however, taken longer for cities and departments to implement some of the programmes that required more innovative funding or assurance mechanisms. For example, Greater Manchester’s proposed ‘earn back’ deal, which enabled the combined authority to retain a portion of additional tax revenue generated by its investment, required HM Treasury to calculate the extra tax revenues generated by local investment. It was autumn 2014 before HM Treasury and Greater Manchester agreed a simpler arrangement.
The Cities Policy Unit’s approach to the initial negotiations was effective in securing the cities’ commitment to the new approach that the Wave 1 deals represented. The Unit, however, prioritised agreeing the deals and setting out high level ambitions and commitments in a short time frame. This meant it did not consult with all the relevant departmental officials before ministers made those commitments. Some of the practical issues around funding and assurance were not considered until after the deals had been signed.
Latest News from
National Audit Office Press Releases
Appointment of Dame Fiona Reynolds DBE as next Chair of the National Audit Office01/07/2020 15:48:00
Dame Fiona Reynolds DBE has today been announced by the Prime Minister and the Chair of the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) as the next Chair of the National Audit Office (NAO).
Department for Work and Pensions annual report and accounts 2019-2001/07/2020 11:15:00
Benefit overpayments are at their highest ever estimated rate, and the quick response and focus on ensuring prompt payments for new benefit claimants during the COVID-19 pandemic means fraud and error are likely to further increase.
Carrier Strike – Preparing for deployment29/06/2020 11:15:00
The National Audit Office (NAO) recently reported that the Ministry of Defence (MoD) needs to focus on developing crucial supporting elements to make full use of Carrier Strike, as well as develop a better understanding of how much it will cost in the future.
Guide for Audit and Risk Committees on Financial Reporting and Management during COVID-1925/06/2020 11:15:00
The National Audit Office (NAO) yesterday published a guide to help audit and risk committees of government departments and arms-length bodies advise their organisations on financial management and reporting during, and in the period immediately after, the COVID-19 outbreak.
Investigation into remediating dangerous cladding on high-rise buildings22/06/2020 11:15:00
Progress is being made in removing dangerous cladding from high-rise residential buildings following the Grenfell Tower fire.
Immigration enforcement18/06/2020 11:15:00
Despite introducing significant changes to its enforcement activity, the Home Office cannot fully demonstrate that the actions of its Immigration Enforcement directorate are helping it to achieve its objectives, according to a report by the National Audit Office.
Readying the NHS and adult social care in England for COVID-1912/06/2020 12:15:00
Today’s report by the National Audit Office (NAO) provides a factual overview of the response by the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) and other bodies during March and April 2020 to prepare the NHS and adult social care in England for the COVID-19 pandemic. It is the second report in the NAO’s programme of work on government’s response to the outbreak.
Managing PFI assets and services as contracts end08/06/2020 11:15:00
Public sector bodies risk underestimating the time, resources and complexity involved in managing the end of PFI contracts.
British Tourist Authority’s annual report and accounts 2018-19 (trading as VisitBritain & VisitEngland)26/05/2020 09:10:00
The 2018-19 accounts of the British Tourist Authority (BTA), also known as VisitBritain and VisitEngland, have received a qualified opinion1 from the Comptroller and Auditor General of the National Audit Office, Gareth Davies, due to irregular procurement activities and payments of £1.115 million. This is the third consecutive year that irregular payments have been identified in the NAO’s audits of the BTA’s accounts.