Independent Police Complaints Commission
Devon and Cornwall Constabulary custody sergeant and detention officers cleared of manslaughter of Thomas Orchard
A Devon and Cornwall custody sergeant and two detention officers were yesterday acquitted of manslaughter charges following an independent IPCC investigation into the circumstances surrounding the death of 32-year-old Thomas Orchard in 2012.
A jury found PS Jan Kingshott, and detention officers Simon Tansley and Michael Marsden not guilty of gross negligence manslaughter after considering evidence at a six-week trial in Bristol Crown Court.
The IPCC investigator submitted a report in January 2016 which included his opinion that the three defendants, together with four other Devon and Cornwall Police officers who were involved in the arrest and restraint of Mr Orchard, have cases to answer for gross misconduct. The final decisions on whether there is a case to answer and whether disciplinary proceedings should be brought are currently under consideration.
IPCC Deputy Chair Sarah Green said: “The IPCC carried out a thorough investigation which led to the Crown Prosecution Service conducting these prosecutions. The jury found the defendants not guilty. Subsequent disciplinary proceedings are currently under consideration for the police officers and staff involved in the arrest and restraint of Mr Orchard.”
The IPCC continues to examine Devon and Cornwall Police’s corporate decision-making around the ERB. Investigators are conducting detailed analysis to fully understand the force’s policies and processes governing its use. In addition, an independent expert with a background in health and safety has been instructed in relation to this matter.
Notes to editors
The IPCC identified a risk in the way that an emergency restraint belt (ERB) was used on Mr Orchard as a spit hood by Devon and Cornwall Constabulary and wrote to all chief constables in England and Wales in November 2012. The letter expressed concern that use of an ERB in this way posed a risk to individuals.
The threshold of proof in misconduct proceedings is the same as a civil case, ie, ‘on the balance of probabilities’. The test for a case to answer is whether a reasonable tribunal, properly directed, could make a finding of misconduct/gross misconduct.
Latest News from
Independent Police Complaints Commission
Metropolitan Police officer to appear in court after being charged with common assault14/12/2017 14:20:00
PC Kashif Mahmood, based at Stoke Newington police station, will appear at Westminster Magistrates’ Court today (14 December) charged with common assault following an Independent Police Complaints Commission investigation.
IPCC offers learning recommendation to Kent Police following death of a man in custody12/12/2017 10:26:00
Kent Police has accepted a learning recommendation highlighted by the IPCC as part of an independent investigation launched following the death of a man in police custody.
Police action prior to the tragic death of Violet-Grace Youens completely appropriate11/12/2017 08:10:00
An independent investigation into Merseyside Police’s role in the events leading up to a car crash in which four-year-old Violet Grace Youens was sadly killed on 24 March 2017, has concluded with no case to answer for any of the police officers involved.
West Yorkshire Police officer dismissed following IPCC investigation09/12/2017 07:10:00
A West Yorkshire Police constable has been dismissed following an Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) investigation into the preparation of statements, allegations of collusion between officers, and whether two officers provided false evidence, while under oath, during a criminal trial.
Investigation launched after a black man was stopped in central London and a police officer was recorded making remarks about ‘criminal profiling’ complete08/12/2017 09:25:00
An IPCC investigation launched after footage emerged of an exchange between a black man and a Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) officer after officers stopped the Bentley he was travelling in in Central London, is complete.