Economic and Social Research Council
Don't blame the robots
Education, rather than technology, is a main factor in the decline of mid-skilled jobs.
Several developed countries have seen their labour markets becoming polarized in recent decades as the numbers of middle-skilled jobs have declined relative to those of low- and high-skilled jobs. Technology has been singled out as the main culprit: automation has reduced the demand for workers with mid-level skills in production lines and offices, while increasing demand for high-skilled managers, professionals and technicians. Meanwhile, there has been little impact on the demand for low-skilled service occupations.
As advances in technology lead firms to require fewer workers in mid-skill occupations, these jobs should see both employment and wages decline relative to low- and high-skill jobs. This ‘double polarisation’ was indeed what happened in the US in the 1990s, but it did not continue into the 2000s. And wage polarisation has generally not been detected in other countries that have experienced job polarisation, suggesting that factors other than technology may have played an important role.
A study by Dr Andrea Salvatori of the Institute for Social and Economic Research finds that the steady decline in middling occupations in Britain over the last three decades has resulted in a substantial shift of employment: out of 100 employees, 19 fewer could be found in middle-skill occupations. Of these, 16 had moved to higher-skill occupations and only three into lower-skill ones.
A distinctive change in Britain since the early 1990s is the expansion in university education, which has led to a tripling in the share of graduates among employees, accounting for the entire growth in top-skilled occupations, as well as a third of the decline in middling occupations.
In parallel, the relative performance of wages in high-skill occupations has deteriorated relative to mid-skill ones, indicating that the supply of workers for these jobs outpaced demand and contributed to the continuing shift from the middle to the top. These facts are highly suggestive that the improvement in the education of the workforce has contributed significantly to the reallocation of employment from mid- to high-skill occupations.
Technology could even be complementary to mid-skilled workers. Since the 1990s, the share of clerical jobs in Britain has indeed declined, but over the same period the wages of clerical workers have grown at a rate similar to those of professional occupations. This could be, for example, because technology enables administrative staff to take on responsibilities that were once the domain of managerial staff.
Across countries, there is generally little evidence to support the idea that automation has been dramatically disrupting the labour market in recent times. Instead, there are clear indications that changes in the composition of the workforce are likely to have played a significant role in the shift from mid- to high-skilled jobs in the last three decades.
- Andrea Salvatori: The anatomy of job polarisation in the UK (IZA Working Paper)
This article was originally published in our Britain in 2016 magazine.
Latest News from
Economic and Social Research Council
MPs need better support to talk to their constituents about climate change, study finds09/02/2018 13:20:00
Many politicians want to see action on climate change but some admit they avoid mentioning it to their constituents because they do not think their views will be supported, according to new research based on interviews with MPs.
£54 million funding to transform health through data science08/02/2018 13:48:00
Health Data Research UK (HDR UK), the UK’s new health and biomedical data science research institute, is awarding £30 million funding to six sites across the UK to address challenging healthcare issues through use of data science.
Eight ESRC research centres granted transition funding under new model07/02/2018 09:25:00
Eight established research centres have been awarded a total of £6.9m to continue their work under a new funding model designed to secure the long term sustainability of social science research excellence in the UK.
International research call on the future of Canada-UK trade relations06/02/2018 16:10:00
ESRC and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada have launched an international competition to assess the state of research knowledge on Canada-UK trade relationships.
University-educated and men from the South are most likely to consider becoming an MP, new findings show18/01/2018 09:25:00
Gaps in class, income, gender and education are major factors in who runs for political office in Britain as well as the north-south divide, according to the first research of its kind in Britain.