‘Don’t shoot the algorithms’, says professional body for IT
The government’s decision to not go ahead with GCSEs, A-levels’ and AS-level exams this summer is understandable considering the impact of the pandemic on students learning. But BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT is disappointed that algorithms, in general, are being blamed again for the exam results crisis of last year.
Dr Bill Mitchell OBE, Director of Policy at BCS yesterday said:
“Last year an ill-conceived algorithm was used to award exam grades to students, which assumed each school’s results had to be effectively identical to the previous year. That caused a huge loss of public trust in the very idea of an algorithm being used to make judgments of any kind.
“The real issue was poor communications and poor collaboration between government offices and departments because they were designed to be arm’s length, rather than closely integrated partners, resulting in an algorithm designed to do something woefully different to what politicians wanted.
“It is damaging to our future as an advanced technological society to blame an algorithm when the true problem was a collective lack of technology governance, which can be fixed should we choose to.
‘Please let’s all work together to sort out the design and development governance for algorithms in public service, not just shoot the algorithm. It only did what it was told to do, that is the point of algorithms.”
Last summer, in the wake of the exam results crisis, BCS carried out a survey which showed over half (53%) of UK adults said they had no faith in any organisation to use algorithms when making judgements about them, in issues ranging from education to welfare decisions. Just 7% of respondents trusted algorithms to be used by the education sector.
In a separate report, ‘The Exam Question: how do we make algorithms do the right thing?’ BCS recommended the government endorse and support the professionalising of data science, in line with a plan already being developed by a collaboration of the Royal Statistical Society, BCS, The Royal Society and others.
It would mean algorithms whose creators did not meet a strict code of practice for ethics, professionalism and competence cannot decide issues such as exam grades or make estimates about the outcomes of pandemics like COVID-19 to government.
We need more professionalism in this area of AI, so that it can be used for the greater good, ethically, and efficiently. We want to see a professionalised data science industry, independent impact assessments wherever algorithms are used in making high-stakes judgements about people’s lives, and a better understanding of AI and algorithms by the policymakers who give them sign-off.
Latest News from
Exams cancelled, but don’t blame the algorithms - says professional body for IT14/01/2021 14:10:00
A-level, AS and GCSE students in England could be asked to sit mini external exams to help teachers with their assessments after it last week’s announcement that formal exams were to be cancelled.
Waive data charges on education websites during lockdown, says IT body06/01/2021 14:20:00
Educational websites should be exempt from mobile data charges to help the poorest families, the professional body for IT said yesterday.
BBC Micro and ARM pioneer awarded BCS Distinguished Fellowship05/01/2021 14:20:00
Computer Scientist Sophie Wilson, who helped design the BBC Micro and ARM architecture, has been awarded a Distinguished Fellowship by BCS, in recognition of her pioneering work.
Record numbers choosing Computer Science degrees - new data reveals16/12/2020 14:43:00
A record 30,090 students started Computer Science degree courses in 2020, an increase of 7.6% on last year, new figures show today.
Elizabeth Denham CBE awarded Society Medal for outstanding contribution to IT10/12/2020 14:43:00
Elizabeth Denham CBE, The Information Commissioner, has been announced as the winner of BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT’s prestigious Society Medal 2020.
Many people lacking basic digital skills during lockdown, new survey finds01/12/2020 09:20:00
Most people have had no recent help to improve their digital skills, despite the pandemic moving personal and professional life online, according to a new survey.
London based firm wins SME Employer of the Year at the National Apprenticeship Awards 202026/11/2020 11:20:00
The national building services engineering partnership Troup Bywaters + Anders, have won the SME Employer of the Year category at the National Apprenticeship Awards 2020.
IT industry should have ‘ethics regulator’, public poll finds12/11/2020 14:43:00
The IT industry should be regulated to ensure ethical standards in areas like artificial intelligence, according to new public survey.