EC welcomes General Court judgment confirming its inspection powers in the area of electronic searches
The European Commission welcomes the judgment of the EU General Court (case T-272/12), dismissing an appeal by Energetický a průmyslový holding (EPH) and its subsidiary EP Investment Advisors (EPIA) against a €2.5 million fine the Commission imposed on them in 2012. EPH and EPIA were fined for obstructing a Commission inspection in an antitrust investigation, by failing to block an email account and diverting incoming emails. The judgment sends a clear message to companies that any steps that undermine the integrity and effectiveness of inspections, including tampering with data stored electronically, are illegal and will be sanctioned.
The Court confirmed that the Commission was right to consider both the failure to block an e-mail account and the diversion of incoming emails as serious breaches of EPH and EPIA's obligation to cooperate with the Commission during the inspection. In line with previous case law (cases T-141/08and C-89/11P), the Court held that these two incidents constitute an obstruction in themselves; the Commission does not need to show that any document was actually removed or manipulated.
The Commission welcomes the Court's findings, because obstructions of inspections can severely undermine competition enforcement. The judgment makes clear that the Commission is entitled to impose appropriate and deterrent sanctions for companies' conduct that may result in destroying evidence of antitrust infringements, irrespective of whether it is stored in paper or electronic form.
Inspections are one of the Commission's most important investigative tools to detect infringements of EU antitrust rules. Commission inspectors may examine and take copies of documents related to the business, irrespective of the form in which they are stored. Business documents are nowadays largely stored in electronic files. In order to avoid any destruction of electronic files, inspectors routinely take steps ensuring them access to the complete files during an inspection.
In particular inspectors identify the e-mail accounts of key persons in a company under inspection and block access to these e-mail accounts during the inspection as one of the measures to prevent the destruction of content. The Commission needs to review not only emails that pre-date the inspection but also emails that are exchanged in the course of the inspection.
Article 23(1)(c) of the antitrust Regulation 1/2003 provides that the Commission can impose a fine of up to 1% of a company's total turnover if the company, intentionally or negligently, produces the required books or other records related to the business in incomplete form during an inspection or refuses to submit to an inspection.
This is not the first time the Commission has sanctioned a company under antitrust Regulation 1/2003 for obstructing inspections. In 2008, the Commission fined E.ON €38 million for the breach of a seal during an inspection. The Commission's decision was confirmed by the General Court in 2010and subsequently by the Court of Justice in 2012.
General public inquiries:
Latest News from
European Cooperation: Transposition of Trade Mark Directive Malta18/10/2019 16:25:00
The Maltese Commerce Department (IPRD), responsible for Industrial Property in Malta, has launched an updated version of their software to address the various changes required to comply with the transposition of the Trade Mark Directive.
Meeting of the European Council (Art. 50) on 17 October 201918/10/2019 15:25:00
Remarks by President Donald Tusk after the meeting.
European Parliament President David Sassoli’s speech to the European Council18/10/2019 14:25:00
Yesterday afternoon European Parliament President David Sassoli opened the European Council in Brussels. This is the first time he has attended the Council in his role as President of the European Parliament.
Joint press conference with Boris Johnson, PM of the UK18/10/2019 13:25:00
Remarks by President Juncker.
Remarks by Chief Negotiator Barnier at the press conference 17 October 201918/10/2019 12:25:00
Remarks by Chief Negotiator Barnier at the press conference on the EC Recommendation to the European Council to endorse the agreement reached on the revised Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland and revised Political Declaration.
Brexit: EC recommends the European Council (Article 50) to endorse agreement18/10/2019 11:25:00
Brexit: EC recommends the European Council (Article 50) to endorse the agreement reached on the revised Protocol on Ireland / Northern Ireland and revised Political Declaration.
Brexit: What did you agree with the UK?18/10/2019 10:30:00
In light of the UK's decision to withdraw from the EU, the EC has reached an agreement at negotiator level with the UK on a revised Protocol on Ireland / Northern Ireland and a revised Political Declaration on the framework of the future EU-UK relationship.
Cutting air pollution in Europe would prevent early deaths, improve productivity & curb climate change17/10/2019 14:05:00
Europe’s air is getting cleaner but persistent pollution, especially in cities, still damages people’s health and the economy. The European Environment Agency’s (EEA) new analysis on air quality shows that exposure to air pollution caused about 400,000 premature deaths in the EU in 2016.
Antitrust: EC imposes interim measures on Broadcom in TV and modem chipset markets17/10/2019 13:05:00
The EC has ordered Broadcom to stop applying certain provisions contained in agreements with six of its main customers. This will prevent serious and irreparable harm to competition likely to be caused by Broadcom's conduct, which prima facie (at first sight) infringes EU competition rules.