ESB Independent Generation Trading Limited and Carrington Power Limited agree to pay £6 million for breaching wholesale energy market regulations
Between March 2019 and September 2020, ESB Independent Generation Trading Limited and Carrington Power Limited regularly submitted misleading data to NGESO about the minimum amount of energy the Carrington power plant could supply, Ofgem market monitoring has found (1,2,3).
- ESB Independent Generation Trading Limited and Carrington Power Limited submitted inaccurate data to National Grid Electricity System Operator (NGESO) about the amount of energy a power plant could supply, breaking rules around market manipulation
- NGESO in turn bought more energy from the plant than needed, leading to higher costs for consumers
- The two companies have admitted to inadvertent breaches, taken action to prevent it happening again and agreed to pay £6 million to the energy redress fund
This caused NGESO to purchase more energy from the plant than needed, and at times spend more money than it needed to, to help it balance supply and demand on the system.
NGESO routinely buys power from power plants to prevent there being too much or too little power on the system. It relies on receiving accurate information from generators to make sure it can do so economically and efficiently.
The companies considered their approach compliant with their obligations and believed it would benefit the NGESO. Ofgem found that the companies did not have the internal processes in place to ensure staff understood and applied the rules correctly.
The companies subsequently took corrective action and have since confirmed that they have improved their compliance processes and training around market manipulation and submitting data to NGESO. ESB Independent Generation Trading Limited and Carrington Power Limited have admitted that they inadvertently breached the rules and have agreed to pay £6m to the energy redress fund to support consumers in vulnerable situations.
Ofgem has now closed this issue, taking into account the companies’ admission of the breaches, the steps taken to avoid any future reoccurrence and the redress they have agreed to pay (4, 5).
Cathryn Scott, Regulatory Director at Ofgem said:
“Ofgem has taken strong action against another generator for submitting inaccurate data to National Grid Electricity System Operator. Data accuracy is essential for keeping the costs of running the electricity system as low as possible for consumers. This case sends a clear signal to all generators that we are closely scrutinising their conduct and will not hesitate to act if they fall short of the standards we expect.”
Notes to Editors
- ESB Independent Generation Trading Limited (IGT) is the controller of the generation output of Carrington Power Limited (Carrington)’s power plant.
- See our compliance decision for more details.
- From March 2019 to September 2020, Ofgem found Carrington, at the direction of IGT, regularly submitted data to NGESO which inflated its plant’s Stable Export Limit (SEL) above the minimum level at which the plant could, under stable conditions, export power. On some of these occasions, Carrington also submitted data to NGESO on request of IGT traders which inflated the plant’s Minimum Non-Zero Time (MNZT). This relates to the minimum time that a Balancing Mechanism unit (i.e. a generating plant providing balancing services to NGESO) must run for in response to an instruction to generate from NGESO. These practices both meant that NGESO was required to purchase a greater volume of power from IGT than needed when it instructed the plant to turn on and generate at its SEL.
- Carrington has admitted it inadvertently breached its Grid Code and licence obligations around submitting data on its plant's technical capabilities to NGESO.
- IGT and Carrington have also admitted they inadvertently breached Article 5 of Regulation (EU) No 1227/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2011 on wholesale energy market integrity and transparency (‘REMIT’), which prohibits market participants from engaging in or attempting to engage in market manipulation.
- The Voluntary Redress Fund provides money to charities to deliver energy related projects that support energy consumers in vulnerable situations. It also helps to deliver benefits to consumers, who were negatively impacted by the specific issue that triggered the redress payment. For more information about Ofgem’s Voluntary Redress Fund, see: Ofgem appoints Energy Saving Trust to distribute payments from rule-breaking energy companies to charities.
For media, contact
Ruth Somerville: 020 7901 7460 / 07990 139504 firstname.lastname@example.org
Media out of hours mobile: 0792 882 9894 (media calls only)
General enquiries (non-media)
If you are an energy customer looking for help and advice, including complaints about energy firms, please see our Household gas and electricity guide. Citizens Advice also provide a free, impartial helpline service across a range of issues on 0808 223 1133.
We also regularly share news and post general advice to help consumers get the most out of their energy services via our @Ofgem twitter and Facebook pages. If you have an enquiry or complaint relating to Ofgem’s policies or functions, contact us at email@example.com or on 020 7901 7295.
For all other non-media related enquiries, please visit our Contact us page.
Ofgem is Britain’s independent energy regulator. Our role is to protect consumers now and in the future by working to deliver a greener, fairer energy system. We do this by:
- Working with Government, industry and consumer groups to deliver a net zero economy at the lowest cost to consumers.
- Stamping out sharp and bad practice, ensuring fair treatment for all consumers, especially the vulnerable.
- Enabling competition and innovation, which drives down prices and results in new products and services for consumers.
For energy insights and updates straight to your inbox from Ofgem, please subscribe.
Latest News from
Ofgem protects customers of GOTO Energy (UK) Limited19/10/2021 15:15:15
GOTO Energy Limited yesterday announced they are ceasing to trade. GOTO Energy (UK) Limited supplies gas and electricity to around 22,000 domestic customers.
Ofgem appoints Shell Energy Retail Limited to take on customers of Pure Planet Limited, Daligas Limited and Colorado Energy Limited19/10/2021 12:33:00
Ofgem has appointed Shell Energy Retail Limited to take on supplying Pure Planet Limited, Daligas Limited and Colorado Energy Limited’s combined total of approximately 252,000 domestic customers and 600 non-domestic customers. This follows a competitive process run by Ofgem to get the best deal possible for customers.
Ofgem protects customers of Daligas Limited15/10/2021 10:10:00
Daligas Limited yesterday announced they are ceasing to trade. Daligas Limited supplies gas to around 9,000 domestic and non-domestic customers.
Ofgem protects customers of Pure Planet and Colorado Energy14/10/2021 10:25:00
Pure Planet Limited and Colorado Energy Limited have announced they are ceasing to trade. Pure Planet supplies gas and electricity to around 235,000 domestic customers and Colorado Energy supplies gas and electricity to around 15,000 domestic customers.
Ofgem appoints E.ON Next to take on customers of ENSTROGA, Igloo Energy and Symbio Energy05/10/2021 10:25:00
Ofgem has appointed E.ON Next to take on supplying ENSTROGA, Igloo Energy and Symbio Energy’s combined total of approximately 233,000 domestic customers.
Ofgem protects customers of failed suppliers ENSTROGA, Igloo Energy and Symbio Energy30/09/2021 10:20:00
ENSTROGA, Igloo Energy and Symbio Energy announced yesterday that they are ceasing to trade. ENSTROGA supplies gas and electricity to around 6,000 domestic customers. Igloo Energy supplies gas and electricity to around 179,000 domestic customers. Symbio Energy supplies gas and electricity to around 48,000 domestic customers and a small number of non-domestic customers.
Ofgem appoints Shell Energy to take on customers of Green Supplier Limited27/09/2021 15:43:00
Ofgem has appointed Shell Energy to take on supplying Green Supplier Limited’s (‘Green’) approximately 255,000 domestic customers, and a small number of non-domestic customers.
Ofgem appoints Octopus Energy to take on customers of Avro Energy27/09/2021 11:43:00
Ofgem has appointed Octopus Energy to take on supplying Avro Energy’s approximately 580,000 domestic customers. This follows a competitive process run by Ofgem to get the best deal possible for customers.