ESMA to address regulatory concerns over Frequent Batch Auctions
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) yesterday published its Final Report on Frequent batch auctions (FBAs). ESMA identified four main characteristics of FBA trading systems through its call for evidence and intends to issue supervisory guidance on pre-trade transparency and on the price determination process of FBAs.
The Final Report also includes the feedback received to the call for evidence and presents an analysis of developments in equity trading.
FBAs have been rapidly gaining market share since the application of MiFID II. ESMA launched a call for evidence in November 2018 to better understand FBA systems and to assess whether and to which extent these systems are used to circumvent the double volume cap (DVC).
The Final Report presents ESMA’s assessment of four main characteristics of FBA trading systems: limited pre-trade transparency, short auction duration, price determination within the best bid and offer price, and self-matching features. ESMA, based on the evidence gathered, will focus on pre-trade transparency and the price determination process of FBAs.
The call for evidence identified two types of FBA systems, detailed in the Final Report, resulting in a different application of the pre-trade transparency requirements. While ESMA agrees with the views expressed by stakeholders responses that market operators should be free to decide which type of system they intend to operate, ESMA considers it important that any auction system operated provides market participants with information that an auction has started to allow for genuine pre-trade transparency. ESMA intends to clarify this via supervisory guidance.
ESMA highlighted in its call for evidence three practices which may undermine price formation and/or require a reference price waiver: the use of pegged orders, the use of price band limitations to ensure that the uncross price is always within the EBBO/PBBO, and the practice of locking in prices at the beginning of the auction.
After assessing the feedback received, ESMA remains concerned that the three practices identified in the call may weaken the price determination process of FBAs and serve as a vehicle to circumvent the DVC. Therefore, to provide certainty to the market and contribute to regulatory convergence, ESMA intends to issue in the course of the following months supervisory guidance clarifying that FBAs should be genuinely price-forming in order to operate without a waiver from pre-trade transparency.
Auction duration and self-matching
The call for evidence also highlighted ESMA’s concerns on two further characteristics of FBAs: short auction duration and self-matching. Following the assessment of the feedback received, ESMA does not consider it necessary to take further action on those characteristics of FBAs at this point. Concerning self-matching features of trading systems, ESMA will clarify through upcoming guidance that the use of self-matching should, for any trading system, be in no circumstances used to formalise pre-arranged trades.
ESMA will work on further guidance along the lines recommended in the report, covering the areas of price determination and pre-trade transparency. Furthermore, ESMA will look at the broader effects of the MiFID II transparency regime, including the general development of the market structure in the upcoming MiFID II review reports.
Final Report call For Evidence Periodic Auctions
Latest News from
Climate change puts pressure on Europe’s energy system19/06/2019 13:25:00
All parts of Europe’s energy system, from availability of energy sources to energy consumption, are potentially vulnerable to climate change and extreme weather events, according to a European Environment Agency report.
Council adopts directive for an EU emergency travel document19/06/2019 12:25:00
The EU is facilitating consular protection for unrepresented citizens of the EU in third countries by simplifying the issuing of safe & widely accepted emergency travel documents.
Biosecurity and transboundary animal diseases: Council conclusions19/06/2019 10:37:00
A high level of biosecurity is essential for the protection of EU territory against the introduction and spread of animal diseases, many of which may have devastating consequences not only for the agriculture sector but society as a whole.
Security and defence: Council adopts conclusions18/06/2019 15:25:00
EU foreign and defence ministers yesterday discussed the EU Global Strategy. Following the discussion, the Council adopted conclusions on security and defence in the context of the EU Global Strategy.
EC increases support for the EU's beekeeping sector18/06/2019 14:33:00
The EC will provide €120m to the EU's beekeeping sector over the next 3 years to support its essential role in agriculture & the environment.
Safe drinking water and sanitation: Council approves EU guidelines18/06/2019 12:25:00
2.1bn people lack access to safely managed drinking water services and 4.5bn people lack safely managed sanitation services in the world. Climate change will increasingly affect water availability & access. Across the globe, tensions and conflicts related to access to and use of water continue to rise as the threat of water scarcity spreads.
Chronic hepatitis B infections on the rise since 200818/06/2019 10:38:00
In 2017, the majority (58%) of the almost 27,000 newly reported hepatitis B cases in the EU and European Economic Area were classified as chronic infections. This follows a consistent upward trend in reported chronic hepatitis B cases since 2008.
Eurogroup agrees term sheet on euro-area budgetary instrument and revised ESM treaty18/06/2019 09:25:00
Following the mandate received by EU leaders at the 14 December Euro Summit, the Eurogroup in inclusive format discussed and took decisions on deepening of the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU).
A Europe that protects: good progress on tackling hybrid threats17/06/2019 16:37:00
The EU and Member States have made good progress in tackling hybrid threats through a number of concerted actions in a wide range of sectors to significantly boost capacities, shows the latest report adopted by the EC and the European External Action Service.