Residential Landlords Association (RLA)
Elderly widow and her landlord son win fight for Housing Benefit
Here RLA trainer, housing benefit and Universal Credit expert Bill Irvine examines a recent case in which a local authority refused to pay housing benefit to an elderly woman renting a home from her son.
“RLA members may recall an earlier article involving an aunt and niece, where Housing Benefit had been wrongly refused, simply on the basis of their close family relationship.
With my help, both eventually secured payment, including a backdated award, but not without a prolonged period of worry and anxiety and very real possibility the aunt might have lost her property, due to threats of repossession made by her lender bank.
This same issue repeatedly arises, and, if anything, is becoming even more frequent, as DWP takes on the mantle of assessing and paying “housing costs” under Universal Credit.
However, whether it’s the council or DWP that makes the adverse decision, the good news is, the chances of successfully challenging these decisions is very high, if you know how to tackle the problem.
My latest case involved a dispute between mother (claimant), son (landlord) and one of the London Boroughs.
The mother had, in January 2019, received notice from, her then landlord, who wished to repossess the property for his own use.
The mother, in her late 70s, had only months before been in hospital and was left very frail.
Her son initially spoke to social services and the council’s housing team about securing sheltered housing but were advised there was little chance of that happening, certainly in foreseeable future, and that she’d be better looking to the private sector.
The son registered her interest on various estate agency portals but nothing suitable and affordable was readily available.
Realising they were running out of time, the son purchased a property himself, using a small personal investment company he’d set up, due to changes in tax laws.
As the mother was already in receipt of Housing Benefit (HB) and the rent, he was proposing was less expensive, they didn’t foresee any problem.
However, literally days after the HB application was made, the claim was refused on the basis – yes, you’ve guessed it – the claim represented an “abuse of the HB scheme”.
Initially, the mother, assisted by her son, appealed the decision. In response, the council, instead of referring the appeal to the Tribunal Service, sent both a long list of questions to answer.
Both completed and returned their respective questionnaires but failed to convince the council that the relationship between mother and son was commercial in nature, and its decision should be reversed.
Two further sets of questions were later sent and answered; again, with the same result. It was at that point the son sought my help.
I drafted a very detailed submission for the mother and urged referral to the Tribunal Service.
After one month, I also wrote to the council’s chief executive highlighting how the council was effectively delaying referral whilst on a fishing expedition, with its series of questions hoping to secure evidence to use against my clients, rather than resolve the dispute.
I referred him to an Upper-tier Tribunal decision relating to another HB case, which exhibited similar characteristics.
It states: “Some local authorities have abused the possibility of “reconsideration” to delay, sometimes virtually indefinitely, the submission of the appeal to the tribunal.
“The technique involves asking a large number of supplementary, often in tendentious terms, so that the “reconsideration” can be carried out.
“If the questions are not answered, or information is not supplied, the appellant is told – quite unlawfully – that the claim has been withdrawn or terminated.
“If the questions are answered, further questions are asked seeking to exploit inconsistencies.”
My email to the chief executive thankfully forced the council to review and revise its decision, in my client’s favour, avoiding the need for Tribunal, and permitting an award from the date of claim.
The outcome was of great relief to both mother and son as the alternative of having to sell the property and, in the process, make this elderly and frail lady homeless, was unthinkable.
Anyone experiencing similar problems should seek professional advice and support, as the law, whilst supportive of the claimant’s position, is complex and often involves the need to present your case to a First-tier tribunal.”
To contact Bill with queries on Housing Benefit (HB) or Universal Credit (UC) visit his website: www.ucadvice.co.uk
Latest News from
Residential Landlords Association (RLA)
New 'golden rules' to sustain tenancies18/09/2020 12:33:00
New ‘golden rules’ to sustain tenancies in the rental housing market have been published ahead of the courts beginning to hear possession cases from the 21st September.
Rent Controls would be a disaster for London renters17/09/2020 09:38:00
Proposals by the Mayor of London for rent controls in the capital would be a disaster for tenants.
Almost a quarter of landlords surveyed lose rent due to Covid-1916/09/2020 11:43:00
Almost a quarter (22 per cent) of private landlords with properties in England surveyed have lost rental income as a result of COVID-19 according to new polling.
England trailing rest of UK in support for renters and landlords03/09/2020 12:15:00
The Scottish Government recently (01 September 2020) announced that hardship loans for tenants will be made available in Scotland to those unable to access other forms of support for their housing costs.
BREAKING: Landlords welcome clarity on possession cases- but the courts must open28/08/2020 13:01:00
Ministers have today made important concessions about how repossession cases in the rental market will be handled from 20th September.
Landlords face two years without rent27/08/2020 13:01:00
The Government’s plans to extend the evictions ban could leave private landlords without any rent for up to two years.
Fury as evictions ban extended and new six month notice rule brought in21/08/2020 13:01:00
The evictions ban has been extended until September 20 with new six month notice periods brought in, it has been confirmed today.
Mayor stoking tensions between tenants and landlords17/08/2020 14:15:00
The Mayor of London is causing needless fear for renters as he wrongly assumes that everyone in arrears due to COVID-19 is at threat of eviction.