Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Elements of new asylum services “set up to fail”
Local and health authorities not consulted or informed as hundreds of Covid-risk asylum seekers moved into hotels in their areas.
The Home Office is responsible for the delivery of housing and support services to people seeking asylum in the UK while their cases are being processed. These services are contracted out – in 2016 the PAC Committee raised concerns about the management of COMPASS, the previous contracts, and in late 2019 the Home Office introduced new contracts to provide accommodation and a new helpline and support service, AIRE.
The Department is paying an estimated 28% more to the new providers than for the COMPASS contracts, and in a report today the Public Accounts Committee says it must now prove it is getting value for both the taxpayer and those who rely on its services. Early signs showing there is a long way to go before the Home Office delivers what it has promised on accommodation and essential services for asylum seekers.
The lack of preparation and failure to share data meant elements of the new services were “set up to fail”. The failure to have effective services fully up and running in the first year has had a significant impact on the lives of asylum seekers, hugely exacerbated by the pandemic crisis.
Lack of discussion with local authorities
In response to this inquiry, MPs from across the UK have raised concerns with the Committee about the lack of discussion with local authorities as service providers moved asylum seekers who had contracted Covid-19 into new, temporary accommodation. In one instance notified to the inquiry a group of people were moved a hotel in a different local authority area, at the last minute and without notifying either the relevant local authority or the NHS bodies affected. In another instance, the asylum services provider had told the affected local authority, but had not informed the local health commissioner that 160 asylum seekers were moving to a local hotel, who could need medical and other services.
The Committee says the pace at which the Home Office had to work does not excuse the lack of discussion with local authorities and local NHS bodies about how to manage this resettlement. Vulnerable people, including families with children, have been living in accommodation that does not meet their needs, and for far too long – which also masks an underlying problem in ensuring adequate accommodation for people when they first apply.
Thousands of people continue to be placed in hotels rather than more appropriate accommodation. Approximately 9,500 asylum seekers are currently accommodated in 91 hotels across the UK. However, hotel use was high even before the COVID-19 pandemic, with more than 1,000 people in hotels each night since October 2019.
Meg Hillier MP, Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, said:
“MPs from across the country responded to this inquiry with examples of lack of consultation and information when large numbers of people were moved into hotels in their area at pace. Quite simply, there was a wholly unacceptable failure of the Home Office to communicate with local authorities and health services as they rapidly shifted hundreds of asylum seekers into hotel accommodation. In some cases people who had contracted Covid-19 were moved to another borough without the authorities being informed. Even at the pace of events there was no excuse for this lack of communication.
“The Home Office has cranked up the payments for these new contracts – now it must prove it can correspondingly crank up performance and deliver at least decent, suitable accommodation and services to people fleeing war and persecution to seek asylum in this country.”
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Government must act now to fix crisis in local audit, say MPs27/11/2023 16:25:00
Local audit is in crisis and the Government must take urgent action to fix it, says the cross-party Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (LUHC) Committee in a report published recently (Friday).
Connected tech: Smart or sinister?: CMS Committee publishes Government response to report24/11/2023 14:10:00
The Culture, Media and Sport Committee has today published the Government response to the first report from its inquiry Connected tech: smart or sinister?
Administration Committee publishes recommendations on parliamentary communications, highlighting potential for increased engagement with the public23/11/2023 15:20:00
Sir Charles Walker MP, the Chair of the Administration Committee, today launched the Committee’s report focusing on how the House of Commons can improve the way it communicates with the public about Parliament.
Incentivise EV battery supply chain investment to prevent decline of the UK car industry, say MPs22/11/2023 12:25:00
The UK Government is falling behind its competitors and needs to urgently create an attractive environment for electric vehicle (EV) battery production in the UK, according to a report by cross-party Committee of MPs.
DB pensions with Liability Driven Investments (LDIs): Work and Pensions Committee publishes Government response to report21/11/2023 16:25:00
The Work and Pensions Committee yesterday published the Government Response to its report on defined benefit pensions with Liability Driven Investments (LDIs).
Government ignores calls for sex education targeted at boys to tackle harassment21/11/2023 09:25:00
The Government recently (17 November 2023) refused to commit to a new strategy in schools on issues of sexual harassment and gender-based violence that is specifically aimed at engaging boys and young men, despite calls in a recent report from MPs on the Women and Equalities Committee.
Government takes leisurely approach to tackling food security20/11/2023 16:25:00
The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee recently (Friday 17 November) published the Government’s response to its report on Food Security, published in July.
Media Bill: CMS Committee publishes Government response to pre-legislative scrutiny reports20/11/2023 11:05:00
The Culture, Media and Sport Committee has today published the Government response to its reports on the draft Media Bill.
Lords Committee publishes new report on services that could transform patient care17/11/2023 11:10:00
The Public Services Committee has published its new report, Homecare medicines services: an opportunity lost. The Committee concludes that the services which deliver medicines to patients in their home could improve care for patients and reduce pressure on the NHS but that this significant potential is not being met.