National Infrastructure Commission
Ensuring resilience in a highly renewable energy mix
Back in July last year we launched the National Infrastructure Assessment, the first of its kind in this country and of its scope anywhere in the world. It identifies clear priorities for the UK’s economic infrastructure over the coming years and decades, based on a thirty-year forward look at the changing shape of our economy and society and at the potential impacts of environmental and technological change.
One of our key findings for energy was that the costs of future low carbon electricity systems look broadly the same, whether the majority of electricity comes from nuclear power or from renewables. Historical evidence suggests the costs for renewables are falling quicker than expected whereas nuclear costs are not falling at all. Given the projected costs, and the potential for development in supporting technologies and smart systems, we’ve recommended that government should pursue a generation mix with a high proportion of renewables, while keeping all options open by adopting a one by one approach for new nuclear power plants.
Yesterday, we released a report that we commissioned from the Met Office, looking at the current scientific understanding of the weather and climate-related risks in a highly renewable electricity system. We wanted to know where knowledge gaps still remain, and where there may be unexplored opportunities to build resilience into a highly renewable electricity mix.
The recent net zero report by the Committee on Climate Change, and the government’s legislative change committing to net zero emissions by 2050, adds fresh impetus to the recommendations the Commission made in the Assessment. There is no longer anywhere to hide. Although it is too early to say what level of supporting baseload power (such as nuclear) may represent best value for money, it is clear that renewables will need to form a much more significant part of the generation mix than they do today. Our recommendations to bring forward more renewables include opening up the Contracts for Difference auctions to allow onshore wind and solar to compete fairly with offshore wind. This would provide the framework for the cheapest mix of renewable technologies to come forward through competitive auction.
But this also means it is time to start thinking critically about how a highly renewable electricity system would perform in practice in the UK. The report shows that there will be challenges associated with future weather and climate variations, and that there are some areas where further research will be invaluable. But it also shows that there is significant scope to build resilience through intelligent deployment of a mix of renewables working alongside sources of flexibility such as storage, interconnectors with other countries, and demand side response.
It identifies how weather-based stress events on the system can be characterised in five ways:
- Two types of events where demand would outstrip supply: high demand during winter accompanied by lower than normal wind; or a summer time wind drought, where though demand may be relatively low, renewable wind supply is reduced for an extended period.
- One where supply would outstrip demand through combined high levels of solar and wind generation in summer leading to excess generation beyond demand.
- And two events where rapid changes over a short period of time could put pressure on the networks through either short term ramping up of wind in the winter, or solar generation in the summer.
The report identifies the forecasting tools which could enable us to predict and prepare for these events, and also how we could make use of insights into the known variability of weather patterns across time and space. For instance:
- the opposing weather conditions found between northern and southern Europe during stress events underlining the key role interconnection could play;
- the anti-correlation identified between wind speed and solar irradiance showing how wind and solar technologies could complement each other in a generation mix; and
- the spatial variation of weather patterns across the country further illustrating the potential benefits of a diverse mix of renewables deployed across the country.
It also highlights gaps in the way we tend to model the energy system, which in general does not properly capture both the full variability of weather and climate, and the significant role for technologies which can help manage the supply and demand of electricity.
The actual performance of the future system, and the exact level of renewables that will be optimal, will depend not only on how we can predict and manage potential extreme weather stress events, but on a variety of factors including how costs continue to fall for renewables and their supporting technologies and how alternative flexibility solutions such as inter-seasonal storage through hydrogen develop.
But we hope that through releasing this report, we can start to move into the next phase of the discussion around how to best make sure we are ready for the challenges and the opportunities that an increasingly renewable electricity system will bring.
Latest News from
National Infrastructure Commission
MPs highlight need for swift action to boost energy efficiency of UK homes and workplaces15/07/2019 09:25:00
A new report from MPs calls for urgent action to address poor energy efficiency in UK homes in order to avoid undermining the UK’s efforts to meet Net Zero carbon emissions, reflecting recommendations made in the National Infrastructure Assessment.
NIC marks one year on from the UK’s first National Infrastructure Assessment10/07/2019 16:15:00
The National Infrastructure Commission today marks one year since the publication of Britain’s first-ever National Infrastructure Assessment.
New charging infrastructure essential to build on investment in UK electric vehicle technology05/07/2019 15:15:00
News of a boost for electric vehicle manufacturing and positive sales are a vote of confidence in an electric future for UK road transport, but must be matched by investment in charging infrastructure to help drivers make the switch from petrol and diesel cars and vans to electric, reduce air pollution and support efforts to meet the country’s new Net Zero carbon emission objective.
Study highlights opportunities for interconnection and diverse renewables mix to build resilience of UK energy network to weather challenges02/07/2019 15:10:00
A new review of research on future weather patterns highlights the importance of a rollout of diverse renewable generation technologies to ensure the resilience of the UK’s energy systems to stresses brought about by a changing energy mix and climate change.
Dealing with waste is essential for a low carbon future (letter)01/07/2019 14:15:00
National Infrastructure Commission Chair Sir John Armitt recently wrote a letter to the editor of the Daily Telegraph in response to its editorial highlighting challenges facing the UK’s waste and recycling infrastructure.
Commitment to open data crucial to optimising UK’s energy system for more complex, low-carbon future14/06/2019 11:15:00
A new report calls for higher standards in data sharing across the UK’s energy networks to improve its resilience and deliver better results for consumers and the environment – in line with recommendations made in the National Infrastructure Commission’s Data for the Public Good report.
Government’s ‘net zero’ pledge highlights urgency of shift to low-carbon economy12/06/2019 16:15:00
Responding to today’s government commitment to ‘net zero’ greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, National Infrastructure Commission Chair Sir John Armitt today said the recognition of the threats from climate change was an important step, but must be followed up by tangible actions to prepare the UK economy for a low-emissions future.
‘Data now as important to UK Infrastructure as concrete or steel’ – Sir John Armitt speech to DAFNI11/06/2019 14:33:00
Sir John Armitt yesterday gave the keynote speech to the DAFNI conference. DAFNI is the Data & Analytics Facility for National Infrastructure.
Armitt challenges government to commit to building a future infrastructure fit for a post-Brexit Britain14/05/2019 11:15:00
National Infrastructure Commission Chair Sir John Armitt has called on the Chancellor of the Exchequer to use this autumn’s Spending Review to commit to a once-in-a-generation transformation of the UK’s transport, energy and technology networks.