Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
European Union (Withdrawal) Bill report released
The recent report on the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill follows a short inquiry to examine aspects of the Bill in order to inform the Committee and Report Stage.
The inquiry focussed on the Bill’s provisions for converting the acquis communautaire into British law, the implications for the devolution settlements and the power to implement the withdrawal agreement. The report concludes that:
- The Government’s amendments to set the exit day as 11pm on 29 March 2019 would create significant difficulties if EU negotiations go down to the wire.
- More clarity is needed on the scope and status of retained EU law.
- Article 191 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU – which covers the precautionary principle – should be converted into domestic law as a directly effective right.
- The Government should justify the purpose of Clause 9 of the EU (Withdrawal) Bill given its announcement of a separate EU Withdrawal Agreement and Implementation Bill.
After leaving the EU, some retained EU laws could be amended to better reflect the UK’s regulatory and business environment. In other areas, it will be in the UK’s interest to keep pace with changes to laws in the EU as seems to be suggested, for example, by the delegated powers in the Trade Bill and the Nuclear Safeguards Bill. Government should also publish details of how they will ensure the UK’s regulatory agencies have the necessary resources and enforcement powers which are vital for consumer confidence and access to markets.
The Committee heard evidence for and against the Bill's removal of the Charter of Fundamental Rights from domestic law. The purpose of the Bill is to provide legal certainty for the UK the day after it leaves the EU and not to reshape rights in the UK. It would be helpful if the Government published its memorandum on rights set out in the Charter, as referred to by the Minister, before Clause 5 is considered in Committee Stage of the Bill.
The Committee encourages the Government to improve engagement with the devolved administrations in order to break the current deadlock on devolved powers and reach agreement with the devolved administrations on how and when reserved competencies will be devolved.
An estimated 800 to 1,000 statutory instruments will need to be passed before exit day. In the course of the Committee Stage of the Bill, the Committee recommends that an interim Report prepared by the Procedure Committee on the scrutiny of delegated legislation under the Bill is given further consideration by the House. Uncertainty will only be removed if all the necessary legislative amendments are in place by any potential exit day to ensure no gaps are left in the statute book.
Exiting the EU Committee Chair, Hilary Benn MP, said:
"The EU (Withdrawal) Bill marks a significant moment in the process of leaving the EU. As our Report makes clear, this is anything but a straightforward task as all existing EU legislation will need to be copied across into UK law to ensure continuity after exit day. With an estimated 800-1000 statutory instruments, Parliament will need to work hard to make this happen.
We need to maintain flexibility as the negotiations proceed, but ministers are now proposing to remove from the Bill the power to set different exit days for different purposes and replace it with a single exit day – 11pm on 29 March 2019. This would create significant difficulties if the negotiations were to continue until the 59th minute of the 11th hour, as the Secretary of State suggested to us might happen.
Our inquiry has also revealed that there is not a consistent view about how the Bill’s provisions will work in practice. Government should provide more clarity and information for citizens, businesses, regulatory authorities and the courts about the scope and status of retained EU law. This should include making clear whether it is to be treated by the courts as primary legislation, so that they cannot rule it to be invalid, or secondary. Greater clarity should also be given to assist judges on exactly how they are to apply European Court of Justice decisions issued after exit day.
We also want to see Article 191 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – which covers the precautionary principle and polluter pays – included as a directly effective right to be converted into domestic law.
We welcome the Government's announcement that there will now be separate primary legislation to implement any EU withdrawal agreement and transitional period, but this does beg the question as to what Clause 9 of the EU (Withdrawal) Bill – which is all about implementing a withdrawal agreement – is now for?"
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
European Statutory Instruments Committee publishes third report of Session 2019-2127/03/2020 11:15:00
Following the Committee’s meeting on Tuesday 24 March, its third report of Session 2019-21 has been published.
The impact of COVID-19 on education and children’s services26/03/2020 15:33:00
The implications of the coronavirus pandemic for the education sector and the impact on children and young people will be examined in a wide-ranging inquiry by the Education Committee.
Coronavirus – workers need clear guidance, Chair says25/03/2020 13:33:00
Rachel Reeves, Chair of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee, has written to Alok Sharma, Secretary of State for BEIS to call for clearer Government coronavirus guidance for workers to help address concerns that workers are being forced to go to work or that their employer is not offering enough support.
Chair writes to Secretary of State on support for self-employed24/03/2020 15:33:00
Rachel Reeves, Chair of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee, has written to Alok Sharma, Secretary of State for BEIS to call for further support to the self-employed and freelancers who have lost work as a result of the response to Coronavirus.
Petitions Committee disappointed by Government’s response on misuse of fireworks23/03/2020 16:48:00
The Petitions Committee have received a ‘disappointing’ response from the Government following an intensive inquiry into the irresponsible use of fireworks.
Chair writes to Ministers on electric vehicles, energy efficiency, CCS23/03/2020 11:33:00
Following last week’s Budget measures, Rachel Reeves MP, Chair of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Committee has written to BEIS Ministers with a series of questions on the Government’s plans on electric vehicles, energy efficiency, and carbon capture and storage (CCS).
Committee comments on Government and regulator responses to reports13/03/2020 16:05:00
The Treasury Committee has today published the Government and regulator responses to the reports on IT failures and on economic crime.
Defence Committee revives Procurement and Prosperity inquiry11/03/2020 11:38:00
The Defence Committee yesterday announced the relaunch of its Procurement and Prosperity Inquiry from the previous Parliament.
Work and Pensions Committee Chair Stephen Timms writes to DWP06/03/2020 15:33:00
Chair of the Work and Pensions Committee Stephen Timms MP has written to Rt Hon Dr Thérèse Coffey MP, Secretary of State at the Department for Work and Pensions, about the Department’s response to a report outlining weaknesses on how it learns lessons from the death by suicide of benefit claimants.