Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Evidence-based approach must be at heart of TTIP debate
The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) could bring significant benefits to the UK but the debate on the agreement is marked by ‘dog-whistle’ politics on each side, says a report from the Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) Committee.
- Report: Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership
- Report: Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (PDF)
- Inquiry: Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership
- Business, Innovation and Skills Committee
The BIS Committee finds that while a lack of detail on negotiations makes it difficult to assess the benefits of TTIP, all involved in the debate – campaigners, lobbyists, business groups, the UK Government and the European Commission – must ensure they take an evidence-based approach when assessing TTIP’s potential.
Adrian Bailey, Chair of the Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) Committee, said:
"Too much of the debate on TTIP has been based on oversimplication and misrepresentation of arguments. TTIP has the potential to have a significant impact on the UK economy, on jobs and on public services but the 'dog-whistle' politics on both sides has made a considered approach to the agreement problematic. More detail needs to be made available to allow greater public scrutiny of this extensive trade agreement. Campaigners, lobbyists, business groups, Government and the European Commission also need to do more to engage with the evidence rather than make unsupported claims about the benefits or risks of TTIP."
Investor State Dispute Settlement provisions
The Committee believes the case has not yet been made for Investor State Dispute Settlement provisions (ISDS) in TTIP and is deeply concerned at the Government’s intention not to submit a formal response to the European Commission's consultation on ISDS provisions. The Committee calls on the Government to submit a formal response, open to public scrutiny, which argues for the inclusion of clauses to dismiss frivolous claims; the exclusion of any clauses which would require the State to pay in all outcomes; and a statement ensuring the right to regulate by Sovereign Nations takes precedence over an investor's right to invest is placed at the heart of the Government's response on ISDS provisions.
The Committee also urges the Government to ensure an unequivocal statement guaranteeing the protection of public services at present—and the right to expand them in the future—is set out in any ISDS provisions.
Adrian Bailey, Chair of BIS Committee, said:
"Concerns have been raised about ISDS provisions in TTIP. We are not convinced the case has been made for the inclusion of ISDS clauses and we urge the Government to set out a clear statement guaranteeing the protection of public services at present—and the right to expand them in the future—is set out in any ISDS provisions. Several Select Committees have now considered the potential impact of TTIP and we hope the Government will now share a greater amount of this information to help better inform the public about the detail of any future agreement and the issues at stake. TTIP negotiations will continue into the next Parliament and we hope that our successor Committee will continue to scrutinise the negotiations as a matter of priority."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Committee urges COP26 to include nature-based solutions in its decision text18/10/2021 11:25:00
The House of Lords Science and Technology Committee has written to Alok Sharma MP, President for COP26 ahead of the conference on 31 October.
New website launched for Parliament’s Heritage Collections06/10/2021 15:33:00
Parliament has launched a new website dedicated to its historic and important Collections, including the Parliamentary Art Collection, the Historic Furniture and Decorative Arts Collection, and the Architectural Fabric Collection.
EU must follow UK-Spain deal on Gibraltar06/10/2021 11:38:00
When the UK left the EU Gibraltar did too, which left the region exposed to checks on goods and workers coming from Spain on which it relies.
Conduct Committee recommends changes to Code of Conduct for House of Lords Members’ Staff04/10/2021 11:38:00
The House of Lords Conduct Committee recently published a report recommending a number of updates to the Code of Conduct for staff who work for members of the House.
Government 'unprepared to press go' on 'evident and ready solutions' to post-Brexit movement of animals between UK and EU01/10/2021 11:38:00
The Government's lack of urgency to address 'glaring holes' in its post-Brexit provisions for the agri-food and livestock trade has left the UK at a competitive disadvantage, and could cause UK businesses to close.
UK Government and businesses must take decisive steps to boost sustainable consumption critical to protect global nature30/09/2021 15:33:00
The Government must strengthen its own sustainable procurement policies, and it should be illegal for UK businesses to use deforestation-linked commodities, if the UK is to demonstrate global leadership to protect nature, MPs say today.
Give Parliament and public ways to measure transport levelling up ‘infrastructure revolution’29/09/2021 11:25:00
The Government’s ‘levelling up’ concept needs to move beyond rhetoric and on to delivery, requiring targets and metrics to enable Parliament and public to identify success, says a new report from the Transport Select Committee, Major transport infrastructure projects.
Justice Committee calls for root and branch reform of prison mental health support29/09/2021 10:25:00
The mental health crisis in prisons will continue unless root and branch reform takes place, a report by the Justice Committee has found.
Government response to Business Committee Industrial Policy report published27/09/2021 13:43:00
The Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee recently (24 September 2021) published the Government’s response [include link] to the BEIS Committee’s Industrial Policy report (which was published on 28th June 2021).