Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Financial pressures undermining confidence in the police
Public confidence ‘severely dented’ as forces reprioritise work in response to funding cuts
The Home Office needs to improve its understanding of the demands on police – and act on it.
The police funding formula must be reviewed urgently and replaced as soon as possible.
- Read the report summary
- Read the report conclusions and recommendations
- Read the full report: Financial Sustainability of Police Forces
Funding for police forces is down by nearly a fifth since 2010-11 and there are nearly a fifth fewer officers and staff. Inevitably there are consequences and forces are under increasing strain.
Forces cannot do everything and are prioritising their work by cutting back in some areas, such as neighbourhood policing meaning fewer officers on the street.
Public confidence in the police is declining and officers’ personal resilience is under pressure with this reduction in visibility.
Forces feeling pressure of 'cost shunting'
Violent crime and sexual offences have increased and forces are dealing with more incidents which are not crime related, at the same time as coping with fewer frontline staff. Forces are feeling the pressure of ‘cost shunting’ as cuts to other areas of public spending, such as health, are passed onto policing because it is so often the first line of response.
Policing by consent relies on public confidence and this is being severely dented. Despite the pressures facing forces, it is disappointing that the Budget did not address the financial sustainability of police forces, particularly in relation to neighbourhood policing which has borne the brunt of cuts.
Tough choices needed in priorities for policing
At a time when funding is tight, the Department must make tough choices about its priorities for policing. But it is not showing strategic leadership of the policing system and has acted too slowly in response to known financial sustainability problems.
It does not have a national picture of demand for police services and so has a limited understanding of what resources forces need.
The Department’s formula for distributing funds has long been acknowledged as unfit for purpose, as this Committee reported in 2015, but has still not been updated.
In the absence of a proper formula, central government funding to local forces has been subject to crude cuts across the board, which do nothing to take account of the complexities of local circumstances. Local taxpayers are paying more to fund police services, compensating for the 30% central government cuts, while seeing less local policing.
We last looked at the sustainability of police forces in 2015 and it is depressing that the Government still has a poor understanding of the on the ground reality of its funding regime.
Public Accounts Committee Chair, Meg Hillier MP, says:
"The ‘thin blue line’ is wearing thinner with potentially dire consequences for public safety. Public confidence and trust that the police will respond is breaking down.
"Funding reductions of nearly a fifth have placed severe strain on police forces, which have in turn been forced to cut back. The results are stark.
"The Police and Crime Commissioner for Merseyside told us that the impact of austerity had been immense, causing the loss of force-wide resources such as robbery and street-crime squads.
"In Devon and Cornwall, neighbourhood policing has been hit to the extent that the PCC believes ‘our communities do not feel safe’. The Chief Constable of Durham told us the public feel let down.
"Last week, the Chair of the National Police Chiefs’ Council added her voice to those concerned about what over-stretched forces can realistically be expected to do.
"In this context it is not surprising that officers’ personal resilience is under pressure, too – not least from serving as ‘first responders’ as cuts to other public services continue to bite.
"This cannot continue. Government must show leadership and get on with fixing the flaws at the heart of its approach to policing.
"In particular the Home Office must improve its understanding of the real-world demands on police, and use this information to inform its bid for funding from the Treasury. And when it secures that funding, it must distribute it effectively.
"It is wholly unacceptable that, more than three years after accepting the police funding formula needs to change, the Home Office has no firm plans to do it.
"If it is to convince police and the public that it is serious about addressing their concerns then it should set out a plan as swiftly as possible.
"The messages from communities and police forces across the UK are clear. The Government must act now."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Healthcare (International Arrangements) Bill needs more safeguards, Committee argues19/02/2019 11:25:00
The Constitution Committee yesterday released a report on the Healthcare (International Arrangements) Bill, raising concerns over the Bill's use of broad delegated powers and lack of adequate safeguards.
Rethink arms licences to Saudi-coalition, Lords Committee says18/02/2019 15:25:00
The International Relations Committee believes that the Government is narrowly on the wrong side of international humanitarian law on arm sales to Saudi Arabia given the volume and type of arms being exported to the Saudi-led coalition, they are highly likely to be the cause of significant civilian casualties in Yemen.
Second report scrutinising Brexit-related international agreements published13/02/2019 14:15:00
The European Union Committee has published its second report in its new role scrutinising Brexit-related treaties.
Uncertainty over future UK participation in Erasmus and Horizon programmes13/02/2019 11:25:00
The EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee publishes its report 'Brexit: the Erasmus and Horizon programmes', highlighting the impact Brexit will have on UK participation in the EU’s international exchange and research and innovation programmes.
UK unprepared for new fisheries conservation rules11/02/2019 14:25:00
The EU Energy and Environment Sub-Committee recently published its report on the implementation and enforcement of the EU landing obligation.
Committee asks Minister about ‘no deal’ Brexit security preparations08/02/2019 14:25:00
The House of Lords EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee has written to Rt Hon Nick Hurd MP, Minister of State for Policing and the Fire Service, as part of ongoing correspondence on its Brexit: the proposed UK-EU security treaty report.
5 proposals made to Government to reform immigration detention07/02/2019 15:05:00
The Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) makes 5 proposals to the Government to reform the immigration detention system. They conclude that the current system should be urgently reformed so that it becomes “fair, humane, decent and quick”.
First report scrutinising Brexit-related international agreements published07/02/2019 11:15:00
The European Union Committee has published its first report in its new role scrutinising Brexit-related treaties, or and international agreements.
Committee demands a future deal to support oil and gas industry04/02/2019 12:20:00
In a report published today, the Scottish Affairs Committee recommends that the UK Government agree an ambitious sector deal, to ensure that Scotland’s oil and gas industry can navigate the challenges of its future and continue to prosper.