GCEU: Europe is ‘too orange’
Although the Court is entitled to examine whether the Commission has sufficiently reliable information before adopting a decision ordering an inspection, such an examination is not the only way to ascertain that the decision was not arbitrary
Orange (known as France Télécom until 1 July 2013) is a French public limited company which provides Internet access to companies and individuals. In 2011, a competitor known as Cogent lodged a complaint with the French Competition Authority, believing that Orange had abused its dominant position by a number of practices in the sector for reciprocal interconnection services in the area of Internet connectivity. In 2012, the Competition Authority found that the practices alleged against Orange were not substantiated or did not constitute an abuse of a dominant position.
In parallel, the Commission had opened a procedure against Orange into highly similar practices. After the Competition Authority’s decision, the Commission, by decisions of 25 and 27 June 2013,1 ordered Orange to undergo an inspection (‘the inspection decisions’). The inspection took place between 9 and 13 July 2013 on four of Orange’s premises. Taking the view that the Commission did not have the right to order that inspection on its premises in the circumstances of the case, Orange brought an action before the Court seeking the annulment of those decisions.
By yesterday’s judgment, the Court dismisses Orange’s action and confirms the Commission’s inspection decisions.
Orange disputed the proportionality and necessity of the inspection decisions, in so far as the Competition Authority had already investigated into identical allegations of infringement and found that its conduct was in compliance with EU competition law rules. The Court nevertheless points out that the Commission is not, in principle, bound by decisions taken by a national court or authority pursuant to Articles 101 and 102 TFEU and that the Commission may at any time take decisions relating to competition, even if they conflict with a national decision.
Latest News from
Chemical weapons: Council renews EU sanctions regime for one year15/10/2019 10:37:00
The Council has extended restrictive measures by the EU addressing the use and proliferation of chemical weapons until 16 October 2020.
Brexit: EC statement following this weekend's technical talks with the UK14/10/2019 16:47:00
Michel Barnier briefed EU27 Ambassadors this afternoon, following constructive technical-level talks with the UK over the weekend. He will also inform the European Parliament's Brexit Steering Group this evening.
Young people, particularly those low qualified, bear the brunt of social inequalities in Spain14/10/2019 15:25:00
This week Spain celebrates the Fiesta Nacional, and we mark the occasion by sharing our research data, findings & analysis to provide a snapshot of the country’s living & working conditions.
Plant Health: prioritising the fight against 20 quarantine plant pests on the EU territory14/10/2019 14:37:00
The Commission recently (11 October 2019) published a list of 20 regulated quarantine pests qualifying as priority pests, including Xylella fastidiosa, the Japanesebeetle, the Asian long-horned beetle, Citrus greening and Citrus Black Spot, whose economic, environmental and social impact on EU's territory is the most severe. Member States will have to launch information campaigns to the public, do annual surveys, prepare contingency plans, simulation exercises, and action plans for the eradication of these pests.
Priority plant pests in the EU: 5 things you need to know14/10/2019 13:43:00
The 20 pests on the list published by the EC in October 2019 are quarantine pests that have been identified as top priorities for EU Member States based on the severity of the economic, social and environmental problems they can cause.
Article - Brexit: plans in place to mitigate impact of no deal11/10/2019 16:25:00
If the UK leaves the EU without a deal, the effects will be felt by people and companies across Europe. The EU has adopted measures to mitigate the impact of a disorderly withdrawal.
Delaying long-term EU investment plan would harm citizens and businesses11/10/2019 15:25:00
In a resolution adopted on Thursday, MEPs warn of a “clear risk” that the 2021-2027 EU investment plan will not be successfully agreed in time with Council.
Rule of Law: EC refers Poland to the Court of Justice to protect judges from political control11/10/2019 15:15:00
On 3 April 2019, the EC launched this infringement procedure on the grounds that the new disciplinary regime undermines the judicial independence of Polish judges and does not ensure the necessary guarantees to protect judges from political control, as required by the Court of Justice of the EU.
EU to take action against fake news and foreign electoral interference11/10/2019 14:25:00
Foreign electoral interference seriously threatens European democratic societies to the benefit of anti-EU, right-wing extremist and populist forces, warn MEPs.