German road toll scheme would breach EU non-discrimination rule, say MEPs
Germany’s planned road toll scheme for private cars would discriminate against foreign drivers, even though changes to it have been accepted by the EU Commission, say MEPs in a resolution voted on Wednesday.
They argue that the scheme would breach EU law by allowing German drivers to deduct toll costs from their vehicle tax, even though foreigners cannot do so.
Because even the revised scheme would allow only Germans to deduct toll costs, it “does not impose an additional burden on German drivers and therefore maintains an indirect discrimination based on nationality”, MEPs say in the resolution, adopted by 510 votes to 126, with 55 abstentions.
They ask the Commission to say why it considered the revised plans sufficient to justify suspending the infringement proceedings against Germany.
“The Commission, as guardian of the Treaties, must monitor the correct implementation and application of the law after its adoption”, said Transport and Tourism Committee chair Karima Delli (Greens/EFA, FR), who tabled the motion on the committee’s behalf.
MEPs also ask the Commission to provide relevant information on its analysis of the new “PKW-Maut” measures presented by the German authorities and their conformity with EU law.
Any national road charging system that directly discriminates based on nationality or when combined with national tax measures to the benefit of only nationals from a given member state, “e.g. a deduction from the national vehicle tax, thus pursuing the objective to charge primarily foreign users, constitutes a violation of the non-discriminatory principle enshrined in Article 18 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union”, they say.
Framework for road charging systems
There is a need for common rules to establish a coherent, fair, non-discriminatory and harmonized framework for road charging systems for any type of vehicle in the EU, MEPs say. The forthcoming revision of the Eurovignette and European Electronic Toll Service (EETS) legislation would be an opportunity to establish such a framework, they add.
The Commission was concerned that the original road toll scheme, adopted on 8 June 2015, would breach EU non-discrimination rules by allowing German drivers to deduct whatever they paid in tolls from their vehicle tax bills and by setting a the disproportionate price for a short-term vignette mainly used by foreign drivers.
It launched infringement proceedings against Germany on 18 June 2015, but then suspended them after reaching an agreement with the German Ministry of Transport Infrastructure on 1 December 2016 on a revised scheme.
Based on the “user/polluter pays” principle, many EU countries have introduced road tolls for cars on certain stretches of their road infrastructure. Although differing in design and pricing, the various systems in place apply indiscriminately to all users.
Ireland, France, Spain, Portugal, Poland, Croatia, Greece and Italy charge distance-based tariffs.
Austria, Slovenia, Slovakia, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Bulgaria and Romania use time-based “vignette” systems.
Germany, Nordic and Baltic countries, the Benelux and most of the UK still do not charge tolls on most of their networks.
Latest News from
Cutting air pollution in Europe would prevent early deaths, improve productivity & curb climate change17/10/2019 14:05:00
Europe’s air is getting cleaner but persistent pollution, especially in cities, still damages people’s health and the economy. The European Environment Agency’s (EEA) new analysis on air quality shows that exposure to air pollution caused about 400,000 premature deaths in the EU in 2016.
Antitrust: EC imposes interim measures on Broadcom in TV and modem chipset markets17/10/2019 13:05:00
The EC has ordered Broadcom to stop applying certain provisions contained in agreements with six of its main customers. This will prevent serious and irreparable harm to competition likely to be caused by Broadcom's conduct, which prima facie (at first sight) infringes EU competition rules.
European Agenda on Migration 4 years on17/10/2019 12:05:00
Ahead of the October European Council, the EC is reporting on key progress under the European Agenda on Migration since 2015, with focus on steps taken by the EU since the last progress report in March 2019.
Capital markets union: Council adopts new clearing house rules16/10/2019 15:25:00
The new framework sets out how EU and third country clearing houses should be supervised in the future, taking particular account of the effects of Brexit on the European financial system. It will be implemented through a revision of the European market infrastructure regulation (EMIR).
Call launch: supporting the food safety systems of the future16/10/2019 13:25:00
The EC has launched a call to develop a research & innovation platform on food safety. It will make it easier for national food safety authorities, EU agencies, policy-makers, the scientific community and civil society to coordinate research efforts.
Turkey's illegal drilling activities in the Eastern Mediterranean: Council adopts conclusions16/10/2019 09:25:00
In light of Turkey’s continued illegal drilling activities in the eastern Mediterranean, the Council reaffirms its full solidarity with Cyprus, regarding the respect of its sovereignty and sovereign rights in accordance with international law.
Plans to keep EU budget funding in 2020 in the event of a no-deal Brexit15/10/2019 15:25:00
UK Researchers, students and farmers would continue to get EU support in the event of a no-deal Brexit, under provisions adopted by the Budgets Committee on Monday.
Article – Hohlmeier: fighting climate change is the priority for the EU's 2020 budget15/10/2019 13:37:00
The EU's budget for 2020 should include more climate action funding and higher investment in sustainable technologies, according to Monika Hohlmeier, Parliament's budget negotiator.
EPPO: Council confirms Laura Codruţa Kövesi as first European chief prosecutor15/10/2019 12:25:00
The Council has agreed to the appointment of Laura Codruţa Kövesi to be the first European chief prosecutor. The appointment must now also be confirmed by the European Parliament.