Institute of Education
Global review finds financial rewards could help teacher recruitment and retention
Financial incentives could be an effective way to support teacher recruitment, particularly in schools with high levels of socio-economic disadvantage, finds a new review led by IOE researchers and published by the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF).
Academics at the IOE, UCL’s Faculty of Education and Society, looked at global evidence on recruitment and retention strategies, to find out which areas have the most potential to explore in future research.
Researchers found that offering financial incentives – such as higher salaries, writing off loans, performance and recruitment bonuses – could be effective for attracting teachers to roles in challenging schools.
The review, Teacher quality, recruitment and retention, Rapid Evidence Assessment, shows that incentives have been used with different levels of success across different countries, but that financial rewards given directly to teachers – rather than allocated to their school of employment – show particular promise.
Researchers also found that strategies to reduce workload and improve working conditions were associated with improved retention. Heavier workloads were consistently associated with higher staff turnover, with factors such as working hours and leave entitlement strongly influencing teachers’ decision making.
Access to professional development, induction support and effective school leadership also show potential in supporting recruitment and retention, according to the review.
High-quality teaching is one of the most powerful levers for improving outcomes for children and young people, particularly for socio-economically disadvantaged pupils who stand to benefit the most. Yet attracting and retaining teachers, particularly in schools serving a high proportion of disadvantaged pupils, is one of the biggest challenges our education system faces.
Recent research shows that many schools in England are struggling to recruit and retain teachers. Applications for initial teacher training have fallen by a fifth compared to their pre-Covid levels, while schools are posting 93% more vacancies than before the pandemic.
The review draws predominantly on international research as very few studies have taken place in English contexts. The EEF aims to supercharge the evidence base in this area through a multi-year research agenda focused on strategies for improving recruitment and retention.
Dr Becky Taylor, Principal Research Fellow at IOE's Centre for Teachers and Teaching Research, and lead author of the review, said: “Through this review we have identified new and promising areas for future research into teacher recruitment and retention, which we hope in time will enable new strategies for attracting and retaining teachers in schools that serve disadvantaged communities.
“Many of these areas, such as the role of effective school leaders in recruitment and retention of teachers, or the use of induction and mentoring, have not yet been investigated at scale in England and we are looking forward to seeing what research develops from these themes.”
Professor Becky Francis CBE, Chief Executive of the Education Endowment Foundation, said: “Supporting the recruitment and retention of teachers should be a central focus of any effective education system.
“This initial review is an exciting first step in our work to understand more about what can be done to attract teachers to, and keep them in, schools with pupils who need their expertise most.
“These findings will be hugely helpful in sharpening the focus of our future research, making sure we put our resources behind trialling strategies with the greatest potential to make a difference in this crucial area.”
The EEF has recently commissioned a range of new evidence reviews, each of which will focus on specific practices which show promise in supporting teacher recruitment and retention in English schools, including school leadership, flexible working, and workload management. One of the reviews commissioned will look at recruitment and retention practices used specifically by schools serving disadvantaged communities.
These reviews will explore the evidence base and current practice using a range of methods, including analysing teacher job descriptions and school policies as well as gathering perspectives from teachers and leaders using surveys and interviews.
Latest News from
Institute of Education
Under-represented STEM students most at risk of not completing degrees, report finds04/12/2023 11:25:00
Students from under-represented backgrounds such as working class or racially minoritised people record the highest rates of degree non-completion, particularly in subjects such as computing, finds a new study led by UCL researchers.
Beyond Ofsted inquiry calls for ‘transformational change’ in school inspection24/11/2023 09:25:00
The school inspection system should be transformed to build trust with parents and teachers and drive improvement across all schools, according to the Beyond Ofsted inquiry carried out by a team of UCL researchers.
UCL academics recognised in annual global list of influential researchers21/11/2023 09:10:00
A total of 60 UCL academics are featured in Clarivate’s annual ‘Highly Cited Researchers List’ 2023, recognising authors of the most influential research papers around the world, ranking UCL 12th globally for the number of “one in 1,000” researchers.
UCL academics embedded in government offices as UKRI Policy Fellowships16/11/2023 14:10:00
Six UCL researchers have been awarded a UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) Policy Fellowship, enabling them to work within government departments and What Works Centres across the UK to address key national and global challenges.
Four in 10 young people in deprived areas struggle to get mental health support when needed13/11/2023 11:25:00
A quarter of Year 13 students in England have sought some form of mental health support in the last year, yet many struggle to access help, finds a new national study led by UCL researchers.
IOE’s Thomas Coram Research Unit (TCRU) celebrates its 50th anniversary07/11/2023 10:25:00
TCRU, a leading centre for social research into children, parenting and families since 1973, commemorates its trailblazing history of influencing policy and practice.
At least 14% of Americans have had long Covid06/11/2023 12:25:00
One in seven people in the US reported having had long Covid by the end of 2022, suggests a large-scale investigation of long Covid and symptom prevalence by academics at UCL and Dartmouth.
Teachers call Ofsted inspections unfair and inaccurate, even in Outstanding or Good schools03/11/2023 10:10:00
Most teachers from both ‘winning’ and ‘losing’ schools believe that Ofsted inspections do not provide a fair and accurate picture, according to new research led by UCL academics.
IOE academics among team behind creation of National Portrait Gallery’s new Schools hub18/09/2023 10:05:00
IOE academics have collaborated with the National Portrait Gallery in London to develop the newly launched online Schools hub, with resources that explore themes including identity, empire, and migration through portraiture.