Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Government accepts Committee recommendations following Concentrix debacle
The Work and Pensions Committee has published HMRC’s response to its report on Concentrix. The Committee was highly critical of both HMRC and its contractor for failings that left thousands of people, many of whom were vulnerable, without benefits to which they were entitled for weeks on end.
- Concentrix: Government Response to the Committee's Fourth Report of Session 2016-17
- Concentrix: Government Response to the Committee's Fourth Report of Session 2016-17 (PDF 160KB)
- Inquiry: Concentrix
- Work and Pensions Committee
The Government has accepted many of the Committee’s recommendations:
- HMRC has agreed to undertake a review of cases where Concentrix amended or terminated a benefit award but an appeal was not requested by the claimant. Of the 59,000 claimants whose benefits were stopped or cut by Concentrix, 36,000 requested an appeal called a 'Mandatory Reconsideration'. 87% of those were upheld in favour of the claimant. The Committee was concerned that the complex and demanding Mandatory Reconsideration procedure, which HMRC and Concentrix accepted as "a routine feature of the process" was daunting for claimants and there was "no doubt" that some people who wrongly had their tax credit stopped had not appealed. HMRC plans to complete this new commitment by March 2017.
- The Government has agreed to publicise better the availability of hardship payments. It acknowledged that there has been "an absence" of such guidance on gov.uk and will publish new content in February 2017.
- HMRC has committed to detailing the reasons it suspects fraud and error in letters to claimants. One of the Committee’s main concerns was that Concentrix did not inform tax credit claimants of the nature of suspicions against them, with claimants left not knowing what they had to prove or disprove, or how. For example, claimants tasked with proving they were single were not told the identity of the person with whom they were suspected of cohabiting. In some cases the person was a former landlord or a dead relative - potentially easily resolved.
- HMRC has agreed to extend any future deadline for the submission of supporting information by claimants to be extended if telephone handling performance again falls below acceptable levels. It has also begun work on enabling claimants to supply information electronically. The Committee found that claimants were "unfairly disadvantaged by the failure of the telephone system". One single mother told the Committee she had spent 19 hours and 57 minutes on the phone trying to resolve her tax credit problems.
- HMRC is taking independent advice on the next annual tax credit renewal process and will write the Committee in March 2017 with its proposals for improvements before proceeding. It intended to "shift the focus of compliance activity to a greater emphasis on education and preventing error and fraud at the point of entry to the system". A longstanding criticism of HMRC’s approach to fraud and error is its focus on detection rather than prevention, with the consequent costs and hardship to claimants this causes.
Rt Hon Frank Field MP, Chair of the Work and Pensions Committee, said:
"The Committee is very pleased that HMRC has accepted our recommendations, which is testament to the work of Parliament on this issue. HMRC was right to fire its contractor, but many of the processes used by Concentrix were the same as those used by HMRC itself.
In particular, the Committee welcomes the review of cases where claimants had their tax credits stopped but did not submit a formal appeal. For many claimants, particularly those who were unwell, lacked self-confidence or had caring responsibilities, the document-heavy process of challenging a wrong decision by Concentrix was surely prohibitively daunting. The real answer is of course to root out fraud and error at entry to the system rather than stopping benefits in payment as first resort."
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Carbon assessments of buildings and targets to boost low carbon construction could come within years30/09/2022 15:33:00
In a statement of intent to tackle emissions from the UK’s built environment, the Government appears willing to explore whole-life carbon assessments and ratcheting targets to reduce emissions.
Draft Victims Bill won’t achieve Government’s aims, says Justice Committee30/09/2022 13:33:00
The Justice Committee today (30 September) publishes a report on its pre-legislative scrutiny of the Government’s draft Victims Bill, finding that it will have limited effect on police and other agencies’ delivery of victims’ rights.
Time to turbo-charge the transport supply chain, urges Transport Committee30/09/2022 11:38:00
New Government must put growth before red-tape and industry inertia, say MPs.
Committee publishes Government response to reports on the Code of Conduct28/09/2022 15:33:00
The Committee on Standards has said it grateful for the Government providing its response to the Committee’s reports on the Code of Conduct for MPs.
Privileges Committee comments on legal opinion26/09/2022 11:38:00
The Committee of Privileges yesterday announced it has published comments on a legal opinion supplied by Lord Pannick KC and Jason Pobjoy.
Revised timetable for election of Committee Chairs announced23/09/2022 11:38:00
The Speaker has announced a revised timetable for the election of the Chairs of the Science and Technology and Foreign Affairs Committees.
Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Committee Chair response to government plans to tackle energy crisis08/09/2022 15:05:00
In response to Prime Minister Liz Truss’ announcement of a freeze on energy bills.
Treasury Committee publishes Government and regulator responses to ‘Future of Financial Services Regulation’ report08/09/2022 11:25:00
The Treasury Committee yesterday published responses from the Government, Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to its report on the Future of Financial Services Regulation.