Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Government should remove Part 5 of the UK Internal Market Bill
The House of Lords EU Committee has today published its report on the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill: Part 5. The report expresses the hope that the Government will remove Part 5 of the UK Internal Market Bill, which the Committee says authorises breaches of the UK’s international law obligations under the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland and the Withdrawal Agreement.
- Report: The United Kingdom Internal Market Bill: Part 5 (HTML)
- Report: The United Kingdom Internal Market Bill: Part 5 (PDF)
- Letter to the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster from the Chair of the European Union Committee, dated 18 September 2020
- European Union Committee
The Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland and the UK-EU Withdrawal Agreement contain various safeguards, including arbitration and dispute resolution procedures that could be invoked by the UK if the EU failed to comply with its obligations under the Protocol. The Committee notes that rather than using these safeguards, the Government has instead acted unilaterally, by means of Part 5 of the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill.
This gives Ministers powers to make regulations over-riding the Withdrawal Agreement and Protocol, which were ratified by the UK only in January 2020. On 8 September 2020, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland told the House of Commons that the Bill “break[s] international law in a very specific and limited way”. Since that time the Government has failed either to formally retract the statement, or to put forward a coherent or consistent argument to support the lawfulness of the Bill.
The Committee wrote to the Government on 18 September 2020 seeking clarification of the Government’s position on the Bill, and asked for evidence to support allegations that the EU had not been acting in good faith. By the day the report was agreed, on 13 October, the Government had not responded to the Committee’s letter.
The Committee highlights the tension that is inherent in the Protocol’s objectives, which include maintaining the UK’s territorial integrity and internal market, protecting the EU’s Single Market and customs union, and an over-arching commitment to protect the 1998 Belfast/Good Friday Agreement, and its three interlocking Strands governing North-South, East-West and internal Northern Ireland relationships. The Committee notes that the UK Internal Market Bill, in focusing on the first of these objectives, fails adequately to reflect the others.
The report finds that the Government has failed to provide any evidence to support allegations against the EU, or to explain why it chose to address its concerns by means of domestic legislation rather than through the safeguards provided in the Withdrawal Agreement and Protocol.
The report notes that until the Government formally retracts the Secretary of State’s statement and puts forward a coherent and consistent argument to support the lawfulness of the Bill, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that Part 5 of the Bill contravenes international law. It is also clear that this breach of international law has been entered into knowingly.
The report also concludes that the Government’s pre-emptive action has placed the United Kingdom in the wrong, and damaged its international reputation as a defender of the rule of law. The Committee therefore hopes that the Government will indicate its intention to remove Part 5 from the Bill.
Latest News from
Parliamentary Committees and Public Enquiries
Covid has had a huge impact on key Scottish sectors22/10/2020 15:33:00
A report published by the House of Commons’ Scottish Affairs Committee has highlighted the devastating impact on Scotland’s key sectors by the coronavirus pandemic.
Committee reports on Gibraltar-Spain border arrangements and European Investment Bank22/10/2020 13:33:00
In its latest report, the European Scrutiny Committee considers recent draft EU legislation and policy documents deposited in Parliament by the Government.
New arrangements for UK nutrition policy scrutinised by committee22/10/2020 11:38:00
The Common Frameworks Scrutiny Committee has written to Health Minister Edward Argar MP on the Provisional Framework on Nutrition Labelling, Composition and Standards (NLCS), following its publication on 9 October.
Committee call for evidence on effectiveness of proposed deal21/10/2020 15:43:00
The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (EFRA) Select Committee today launches a short call for evidence in order to scrutinise the proposed Fisheries Framework Agreement between the UK and Norway.
Chair calls on Government to publish list of companies that received furlough money19/10/2020 15:33:00
The Public Accounts Committee is calling on HMRC to give a more honest picture of the likely levels of the so called “tax gap” – between tax that should be paid on the UK’s economic activity and the tax that HMRC actually collects – whether caused by deliberate evasion of various kinds or accidental taxpayer error.
Business Committee demand answers from fashion, retail and tech businesses19/10/2020 12:33:00
The Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) Committee has written to a range of businesses in sectors including fashion, retail and information technology, to seek answers in relation to the Committee’s inquiry exploring the extent to which businesses in the UK are exploiting the forced labour of Uyghur in the Xinjiang region of China.
UK Internal Market Bill violates the rule of law and threatens to undermine devolution arrangements, says Committee19/10/2020 11:38:00
The Constitution Committee has published its 17th report of the session on the UK Internal Market Bill.
MPs to examine risks to survival of community sports16/10/2020 13:43:00
A new inquiry launched by the DCMS Committee will examine the risks to the future of community sport, highlighted by the Covid-19 pandemic.